All yall punk rock listeners out there probably know Good Charlotte and Green Day. Which is the best of the two awesome bands IYHO?
Oh instruments, I would say Green Day is the better simply because they use alot more instruments than Good Charlotte. So my vote is for Green Day.
| Good Charlotte or Green Day? | |
|---|---|
| Post #1 Mar 1 2005, 15:34 | |
Neowinian Senior   Group: News Editor Posts: 3,114 Joined: 5-October 04 From: Tennessee, US Member No.: 74,328 
|
|
   |
 
 
|
|
Log In or Register · Advertise on Neowin |
|
| Post #2 Mar 1 2005, 15:38 | |
|
Remember The Name.   Group: +Subscriber Posts: 1,271 Joined: 26-October 03 From: Israel Member No.: 38,717
|
I agree on the instruments part, and green day's new cd is simply superb. vote goes to green day.
|
|
|
|
| Post #3 Mar 1 2005, 16:28 | |
Neowinian Wise One  Group: Registered Posts: 5,518 Joined: 11-December 02 From: Auburn, Alabama Member No.: 20,406
|
Green Day, but the new CD has nothing to do with that.
|
|
|
|
| Post #4 Mar 1 2005, 16:30 | |
~ Englishman Group: Registered Posts: 2,763 Joined: 29-November 01 From: t|-|e (_)k Member No.: 4,763
|
LoL ! "Which is the best of the two awesome bands" "Good Charlotte" HAH I wouldnt call Good Charlotte anything near good.
As Chris Rock once said "Good Charlotte .. HAH more like Mediocre Greenday" Green Day hell of a lot better. |
|
|
|
| Post #5 Mar 1 2005, 16:30 | |
Neowinian Senior Group: Registered Posts: 3,817 Joined: 25-December 03 From: Colorado Springs, CO Member No.: 43,635
|
they're on two totally different levels. Green Day has been around since the days of Operation Ivy, they have a lot more talent and experience.
|
|
|
|
| Post #6 Mar 1 2005, 16:30 | |
Baxter Stockman Group: Registered Posts: 3,610 Joined: 13-March 02 From: NS, Canada Member No.: 10,697
|
if you're talking about Dookie, then Green Day, otherwise, everything they've done is mediocre at best (Blvd. of Crap sucks for crap as well)
And Good Charlotte is just a joke, I can't believe they even have arecord deal |
|
|
|
| Post #7 Mar 1 2005, 16:33 | |
|
neowin mountaineer  Group: Banned Posts: 8,777 Joined: 3-April 02 From: West Virginia Member No.: 11,321
|
green day, they have been around for over 10 years, and it just keeps on getting better, cant say the same for gc at all
when are they going to make jason white the official 4th member though? |
|
|
|
| Post #8 Mar 1 2005, 16:40 | |
Neowinian Senior Group: Registered Posts: 2,822 Joined: 28-May 03 From: Kent, England Member No.: 29,504
|
good charlotte are a joke to music and deserve to be shot. i wouldn't even class them as punk. this is coming from someone that's not even a big fan of greenday.
|
|
|
|
| Post #9 Mar 1 2005, 16:43 | |
local know-it-all idiot  Group: Registered Posts: 25,341 Joined: 22-March 02 From: Kanzem, Germany Member No.: 10,955
|
none. both are sucky bands by now. old green day was somewhat ok.
|
|
|
|
| Post #10 Mar 1 2005, 16:44 | |
|
aka Garnett  Group: +Subscriber Posts: 6,438 Joined: 24-February 04 From: Nottingham, UK Member No.: 48,603
|
Green day
 The songs are great! |
|
|
|
| Post #11 Mar 1 2005, 16:47 | |
|
Neowinian Senior Group: Registered Posts: 3,739 Joined: 25-May 04 From: Omaha Member No.: 56,800
|
how can you compare a band like good charlotte who are young to a punk band that has had amazing success for over a decade?
Green day dwarfs Good charlotte in every single way |
|
|
|
| Post #12 Mar 1 2005, 16:48 | |
Resident Elite Group: Registered Posts: 1,506 Joined: 6-August 04 From: Just South of Boston Massachusetts Member No.: 65,281
|
Good Charlotte =
 Green Day is ahhhsome |
|
|
|
| Post #13 Mar 1 2005, 16:50 | |
|
love will tear us apart Group: Registered Posts: 3,125 Joined: 30-October 01 Member No.: 2,505
|
If you're considering Green Day and Good Charlotte to be PUNK, you've got it all wrong.
POP is more like it. And I don't listen to either, really. |
|
|
|
| Post #14 Mar 1 2005, 16:56 | |
Neowinian³  Group: Registered Posts: 426 Joined: 31-May 04 From: Birmingham, AL Member No.: 57,415
|
While Green Day is CERTAINLY more talented than Good Charlotte...I am terribly frustrated that Green Day decided to make their latest album so OVERTLY political instead of just worrying about the music. Like everyone in hollywood, GD is trying to shove their opinion down everyone's throats while taking a monumental stab at America...and Americans.
Funny, you take a stab at the people who made you rich...I guess they can afford to be cynical. |
|
|
|
| Post #15 Mar 1 2005, 17:14 | |
Neowinian Wise One Group: Registered Posts: 4,637 Joined: 19-March 02 From: Phoenix, AZ Member No.: 10,879
|
Neither as neither are punk. They're the antithesis of punk.
|
|
|
|
| « Older · The Media Room · Newer » | |
8 Pages 
[1] 2 3 ... Next : Last »
|
|
