Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: About Becks Penalty shot
Neowin Forums > Recreational Activities > The Sporting Arena
Neobond
ok, leave the guy alone, he was the only player antagonized by the goal keeper (who wasn't carded by the very biased swiss ref) so he failed to notice that the penalty spot was not flat, when he placed the ball the goal keeper was virtually on top of him so Becks took a step back and left the ball where it was, with his run up the ball moved forward causing him to miss his intended contact by a good 10cm where the ball went over the bar.

In these circumstances I can't blame the guy.

I guess everyone forgot that Portugal won the toss and very arrogantly told England to go first which is in poor taste given the pressure on every penalty taker at the time.

who's with me?

oh, and why did England get a Swiss ref when Switzerland were in the same group? knocked out by England? i think you can't get more biased than that.
SOB BOT
Yes. I agree...
Radish™
Quote - (Aaryn Kasra @ Jun 26 2004, 16:32)
Yes. I agree...

Me too.

Radish™
jamesp
I agree too. Did you see that news conference yesterday? He is such a good captain.
Schmoove
It wasn't Beckham failing. On TV you could clearly see that the ball moved before he was able to shoot it.
Though, it was Beckham failing when he put the ball on the spot. You just have to make sure that you put it right..... a goalkeeper intimidating isn't an excuse, that's all in the game.

In the end England didn't deserve to win the game anyways. They played like cowards and were in defence most of the match. The Portugese were the attacking and more attractive team. The way Ricardo stopped the last penalty without gloves and scored their last decisive penalty shows arrogance, but also guts and quality, something I haven't seen in any of the English players in this tournament (well except Rooney maybe).
Portugal deseved to win.
Neobond
Quote - (Schmoove @ Jun 26 2004, 17:44)
In the end England didn't deserve to win the game anyways. They played like cowards and were in defence most of the match. The Portugese were the attacking and more attractive team. The way Ricardo stopped the last penalty without gloves and scored their last decisive penalty shows arrogance, but also guts and quality, something I haven't seen in any of the English players in this tournament (well except Rooney maybe).
Portugal deseved to win.

After Rooney left England fell apart, so defending like they did for a good 60 minutes succesfully shows what they are capable of when they are down 2 key players.

As for the gloves thing, he only took off his gloves because he thought it was his turn is what I have heard.

Denying England any mutual respect on the field in these circumstances goes beyond "its all in the game" so I have to say i hope they get their asses whipped by Holland.
Sawyer12
Yeah totally agree. The ultimate **** take was when the Goal Keeper took the winning penalty.
A. Kaladis / nw_raptor
well... i think portugal officials are to blame for the penalty spot issues... not Beckham, not the players and not the ref...
Schmoove
Oh come on...
It happens constantly in the game. Players verbally intimidating eachother. Stepping on eachothers toes by 'accident'.
Getting people out of their concentration. It has nothing to do with respect, it has everything to do with the will to win.

Players have enough respect for eachother, it is just that during the match important things are at stake, so they try to win, which is very natural. And goalkeepers trying to get the penalty taker out of concentration is a very common phenomenon.

I've seen keepers do all kinds of tricks. From telling the ref to check the ball if it is on the right place, to jumping up and down in the goal like an energizer bunny. Walking up to the player and use some verbal intimidation is very common too.....

If you can't handle such things, don't take the damn penalty then.....
Neobond
Quote - (Schmoove @ Jun 26 2004, 17:56)
If you can't handle such things, don't take the damn penalty then.....

The issue here was the spot, not the other things you are going on about.. His only failure was to check it, but Ricardo assisted in this and yes Beckham should be able to deal with it, its his job. Again tho he was the only player 'intimidated' which also says a lot.
XhaKeR
Ricardo took the gloves because he thought it would discourage the penalty taker.
Everyone knows that James is the weak point in England's team, Ricardo took the penalty because he was once a striker when he was younger.

and neobond. i know you're the admin and such.. but hey, they sent england first? what would you do? go first with that presure? anyone would do that, even if beck won the coin thing, he would send portuguese first.
tiagosilva29
Quote - (Neobond @ Jun 26 2004, 16:29)
ok, leave the guy alone, he was the only player antagonized by the goal keeper (who wasn't carded by the very biased swiss ref) so he failed to notice that the penalty spot was not flat, when he placed the ball the goal keeper was virtually on top of him so Becks took a step back and left the ball where it was, with his run up the ball moved forward causing him to miss his intended contact by a good 10cm where the ball went over the bar.

In these circumstances I can't blame the guy.


Yeap, true.
The pitch was very bad for both teams, Neobond. huh.gif Rui Costa also failed a penalty, for the same reasons as Beckham.
Also, there was a english player that took the penalty from the right-upper side of the spot, the keeper complained, but the referee said "Move along...".

Quote - (Neobond @ Jun 26 2004, 16:29)
I guess everyone forgot that Portugal won the toss and very arrogantly told England to go first which is in poor taste given the pressure on every penalty taker at the time.

This made me laught. What is your point? Have you ever taken a penalty shootout?
Every team does exactly the same. This is called stress strategy.
England would do exactly the same.

Quote - (Neobond @ Jun 26 2004, 16:29)
oh, and why did England get a Swiss ref when Switzerland were in the same group? knocked out by England? i think you can't get more biased than that.

Pure coincidence. They pick the referees that have been acting better (or that are more popular) and make a ramdom call.

Quote - (Schmoove @ Jun 26 2004, 17:44)
The way Ricardo stopped the last penalty without gloves and scored their last decisive penalty shows arrogance

Sir, I sense that you have never played football.
He took the gloves out because he wanted to scare and to make the opponent nervous: successful task!
Plus, he wanted to take the penalty because he was BELIEVING. He believed and he made the count. // With some Eusébio support , also tongue.gif!

Since when someone having faith, since when someone having THE frenzy of the moment is arrogance?!
Dazzla
Funny that both the england camp and the portugese camp complained to UEFA about the spot before the game. After Beckham took his penalty all the other players knew to watch out for it, the next 4 or 5 penalties the players were jumping up and down on the spot to compact and flatten it, after that they weren't even taking the from the spot, it was slightly to the right!

Interesting that before the France Greece game they replaced the penalty spots with fresh turf...
Schmoove
Quote - (Neobond @ Jun 26 2004, 16:59)
The issue here was the spot, not the other things you are going on about.. His only failure was to check it, but Ricardo assisted in this and yes Beckham should be able to deal with it, its his job. Again tho he was the only player 'intimidated' which also says a lot.

The issue is the spot indeed. Beckham checked it, but not carefully enough.... his own stupid mistake.
ESPECIALLY because the english squad KNEW the penalty spots were crap. Erikson complained about it at the UEFA even!!
So if you know the spots are junk you check it carefully and make sure the ball is in the right place.
Quote -
Sir, I sense that you have never played football.
He took the gloves out because he wanted to scare and to make the opponent nervous: successful task!
Plus, he wanted to take the penalty because he was BELIEVING. He believed and he made the count.

Since when someone having faith, since when someone having THE frenzy of the moment is arrogance?!

I've played football for more then 12 years....... and I go to a lot of Ajax matches and some of the dutch squad.
Also don't quote me wrong, becaus you are ripping the quote out of context.
Taking your gloves off is a sort of arrogance no matter how you look at it. He was confindent enough (and arrogant enough) to take his gloves of just to show the player he could also stop the ball without gloves.
No matter how you think of that, it is ARROGANCE......

In the Netherlands Ajax is know as arrogant. In my opinion you need to have a certain level of arrogance, it can help you in some matches.
XhaKeR
just for the record.
Ricardo told Beckham he would miss, he didnt told him he would die or wtv.
Neobond
Quote - (tiagosilva29 @ Jun 26 2004, 18:02)
Yeap, true.
The pitch was very bad for both teams, Neobond.  huh.gif Rui Costa also failed a penalty, for the same reasons as Beckham.
Also, there was a english player that took the penalty from the right-upper side of the spot, the keeper complained, but the referee said "Move along...".


This made me laught. What is your point? Have you ever taken a penalty shootout?
Every team does exactly the same. This is called stress strategy.
England would do exactly the same.


Pure coincidence. They pick the referees that have been acting better (or that are more popular) and make a ramdom call.


Sir, I sense that you have never played football.
He took the gloves out because he wanted to scare and to make the opponent nervous: successful task!
Plus, he wanted to take the penalty because he was BELIEVING. He believed and he made the count. // With some Eusébio support , also tongue.gif!

Since when someone having faith, since when someone having THE frenzy of the moment is arrogance?!

Excellent points.

but back to my point, I still don't believe Beckham can be blamed under the circumstances of the spot. You could see his contact was way off.
Redmak
I do think that it was his fault. In the end he's still the one shooting no matter what happens around him (although the pressure is high).


I agree that it's weird the game was lead by a Swiss refferee
James7
we was robbed! realmad.gif realmad.gif realmad.gif
Redmak
Quote - (tiagosilva29 @ Jun 26 2004, 18:02)
Pure coincidence. They pick the referees that have been acting better (or that are more popular) and make a ramdom call.

Coincidence or not. To avoid speculation they could have picked another reff.

I wouldn't want a German reff to lead tonights game smile.gif
.Rob
I agree
tiagosilva29
Quote - (Redmak @ Jun 26 2004, 17:24)
I wouldn't want a German reff to lead tonights game smile.gif

shifty.gif I'll have to talk with my business colleagues, ... erm blink.gif ... I mean: YES, LET US HOPE NOT! ohmy.gif
jazmon
i think he was responsible for it. he should have been more cautious about it. i mean he was the one that took it. he cant possibly blame everything on the mud pack. he was affected too much by the affair thing and the previous penalty he missed. he is not as reliable and stable as he used to be.
Redmak
Quote - (jAzMoN @ Jun 26 2004, 18:55)
... and the previous penalty he missed ...

... and the previous penalties he missed ... tongue.gif
syphern
Nope sorry Neo I disagree, why? Well because he has missed 3 penalties in a row now! Hes loosing his skill overall I say (thats just my observation). And you could clearly see he was about to chip the ball in the corner as i said in another thread the chipping went wrong, he smacked his foot into the ground and bam there was a instant sand castle! Im VERY sure that they would check the field before a match, and its been reported that they checked the penalty spot before the game. So blaming the spot just does not do it. If Beckham admits that he made a mistake, then sure I would not blame him everyone makes mistakes. But the guy still doesn't admit it was his bad.
The Prodigal Father
i agree with you neobond, but not on the "arrogance" issue. intimidation/strategy is apart of the game, plain and simple. Infact, it's apart of every sport, the fact is that every player who took a penalty had to put up with the ****ty penalty spot and beckham had no reason step back because ricardo was close to him, he should have, like most penalty takers, checked the spot properly.

either way he is still a great player and a fit captain, there is no other player on the english team fit to replace him in my opinion.

and, just for the record, portugal deserved the win, they dominated the game, and the ref WAS biased, but to both teams (look at the pictures in the offical euro 2004 thread, portugal had a goal that didn't count, and terry clearly impeded ricardo)
tiagosilva29
Quote - (Schmoove @ Jun 26 2004, 17:03)
Taking your gloves off is a sort of arrogance no matter how you look at it. He was confindent enough (and arrogant enough) to take his gloves of just to show the player he could also stop the ball without gloves.
No matter how you think of that, it is ARROGANCE......

In the Netherlands Ajax is know as arrogant. In my opinion you need to have a certain level of arrogance, it can help you in some matches.

So by arrogance, you mean that species of pride which consists in exorbitant claims of rank, dignity, estimation, or power, or which exalts the worth or importance of the person to an undue degree (yes, this was wikied tongue.gif)?

Quote - Ricardo's interview @ O JOGO
http://www.ojogo.pt/20-126/Artigo388184.htm

[Btw, he is a very religious man. Don't mock him.  wink.gif ]

(...)

Q * What was going on your head to defend a penalty without gloves in a fully crowded stadium?
A * It was like a divine signal. It that moment I thought I head a voice from the sky saying: "Ricardo,  you must do something to change this, to defend this penalty and to clear the suffering and angst of all this people". I looked at myself and the first thing that I remembered to do was to take of my gloves. I tryed to gain moral support throught that and discourage the opponent. This is all nice when it ends well and, fortunately, I had luck, because I couldn't have defended , but, I was with lots of faith to that penalty.

Q * You have volunteered to shoot the next penalty. Why?
A * Everybody knows, since my first coaches to mister Scolari, that I don't turn by back into my responsabilities. When I'm there, in the field, I feel confident to make this kind of thing, like penalties. That's why. In that moments, of great tension, some may thing that they shouldn't shoot the penalties, but, there's always that little thing inside and I made my stand there. The mister told me that I could score after the sixt one so that we could win.

Q * That penalty made you relive your childhood times, when you scored penalty and played as a forward?
A * My mom and dad didn't let me miss at anything, when I was a kid, but sometimes I played in the street and in the backyards almost without close, without gloves, in anyway, and we got all messed up. It was a childhood instinct that I had in that moment.
(...)
theyarecomingforyou
England lost Rooney and the side did then go onto defending. England also didn't play very well. Saying both these things though, the ref was useless and was hugely biased - if you watched the match you can see he made very dubious decisions MOSTLY in Portugal's favour. I'm not trying to say England played brilliantly and the game was stolen from us, but disallowing the goal was wrong because he did not see it properly and because the assistant "REFEREE" allowed it and flagged it as clean.

The ref was poor... other refs have done brilliantly, but this particular ref was a disgrace to the sport. Camera replays are needed for refereeing decisions to stop crap like this happening again - you can't have a human there making mistakes that tens of millions of people are watching and can SEE if they are right. It shouldn't be luck if you score a goal as to whether it is counted.

Portugal played well (apart from Ronaldo the punk with his diamond earings and trying to claim fouls and corners that were to BLATANTLY not his), but England was cheated of a victory. The penalties are irrevelant (though VERY annoying) because it should not have got to them.

Quote -
Well because he has missed 3 penalties in a row now! Hes loosing his skill overall I say (thats just my observation).


Wow... big deal. Beckham is a brilliant captain because he plays fair, he motivates the team, he is a great kicker (taking nearly all free kicks/corners) and because he is cool tempered. Throughout the tournament he has been shoved, pushed, kicked and beaten about and he has kept a PERFECT cool during all of this. He used to be hot headed but has now developed into a great person and a better leader.

PS - Saying all this, I don't particularly care about football. It's more the national pride and unfair refereeing that annoyed me.
FaRSightxc2
Quote - (jamesp @ Jun 26 2004, 16:41)
I agree too. Did you see that news conference yesterday? He is such a good captain.

Yeah, I saw that on Sky Sports News - he is not the cleverest or most eloquent person in the world, but he really did himself proud in that interview. For anyone that saw it, I loved the way he turned round that question on the journalist who asked him about whether he thought he should be England captain or not. I was proud for him to be our captain. It took courage to act the way he did in the interview, and a lesser man may not have handled it as well.

As for the penalty, as he planted his left foot before striking the ball it caused the turf to move and the ball to 'pop up' slightly. This meant that, as he kicked it, his foot was more underneath the ball than it should have been and the ball ballooned over the bar.


Coincidently, I found a silver football in my back garden today. Must have been where the ball finally landed after the poor sod spooned it over the bar shifty.gif
Radish™
Quote - (farsightxc2 @ Jun 26 2004, 19:25)
Coincidently, I found a silver football in my back garden today. Must have been where the ball finally landed after the poor sod spooned it over the bar shifty.gif

laugh.gif ninja.gif

Radish™
dablitz
Quote -
Coincidently, I found a silver football in my back garden today. Must have been where the ball finally landed after the poor sod spooned it over the bar 



hahaha
mdsll
Both teams had the same penalty spot, so same odds for both....

Learn to lose, England!
mihir
dealing with loss isn't difficult. unless your constantly cheated out of important victories. there's another "hand of god" always waiting for the english.
MountainSnake
"Hand of god" where?

Even if the referee made a mistake (didn't), he “made justice” when he annulled a TRUE goal from Portugal. So, shut up now because this subject is making me sick wacko.gif cry.gif
OPaul
meh, Beckham's still a jerk.
soLoredd
Maybe I don't understand soccer enough, but it looked to me like he just missed the shot, plain and simple.
FaRSightxc2
Quote - (soloredd @ Jun 27 2004, 00:47)
Maybe I don't understand soccer enough, but it looked to me like he just missed the shot, plain and simple.

I'm sure there were alot of other opportunities for England to have won the game. And don't forget about Portugal's goal that was not counted - if that was ruled a goal, there wouldn't even have been a shootout. The argument about a ball being placed wrong or whatever is hilarious. Step up and kick the ball for crying out loud.

Portugal had a goal disallowed? I must have missed that blink.gif

England certainly had a perfectly ligitimate goal disallowed *as everyone is now aware*. This, therefore, would discount the idea that Portugals disallowed goal should have put them through. If, then, I am right in thinking there was no disallowed goal for Portugal, the fact England did have a disallowed goal would reverse this argument altogether!

As for the 'its simple, just kick it' argument, it is very hard to judge how to kick a ball you think is stationary when it moves at the last possible second. It like trying to shoot a tin can off a wall, and as you press the trigger the wind blowing it off just as the bullet is firing - it happens so quickly you cannot adjust to the movement and you miss.

But, at the end of the day he did miss the shot. No one is debating that. Portugal were even the better side: it was just a shame they won in such a controversial, or no one would have any issues whatsoever with them going through.

smile.gif
Floyder
Quote - (Neobond @ Jun 26 2004, 15:29)
ok, leave the guy alone, he was the only player antagonized by the goal keeper (who wasn't carded by the very biased swiss ref) so he failed to notice that the penalty spot was not flat, when he placed the ball the goal keeper was virtually on top of him so Becks took a step back and left the ball where it was, with his run up the ball moved forward causing him to miss his intended contact by a good 10cm where the ball went over the bar.

In these circumstances I can't blame the guy.

I guess everyone forgot that Portugal won the toss and very arrogantly told England to go first which is in poor taste given the pressure on every penalty taker at the time.

who's with me?

oh, and why did England get a Swiss ref when Switzerland were in the same group? knocked out by England? i think you can't get more biased than that.

lol you really cant accept defeat. no.gif

i just want to remind you that the penalty spot was the same for both teams... Lemme see, Beckham missed cause the spot wasnt flat, and rui costa not. wink.gif

About calling arrogant us for telling you to go first you have to be kidding. w00t.gif

Are those highly paid professional soccer players or amateurs who cant handle pressure?

You still think that the disallowed goal was legitimate?the rules i know dont allow to disturb the keeper action in his area.
soLoredd
Quote - (farsightxc2 @ Jun 26 2004, 15:54)
Portugal had a goal disallowed?  I must have missed that blink.gif

England certainly had a perfectly ligitimate goal disallowed *as everyone is now aware*.  This, therefore, would discount the idea that Portugals disallowed goal should have put them through.  If, then, I am right in thinking there was no disallowed goal for Portugal, the fact England did have a disallowed goal would reverse this argument altogether!

As for the 'its simple, just kick it' argument, it is very hard to judge how to kick a ball you think is stationary when it moves at the last possible second.  It like trying to shoot a tin can off a wall, and as you press the trigger the wind blowing it off just as the bullet is firing - it happens so quickly you cannot adjust to the movement and you miss.

But, at the end of the day he did miss the shot.  No one is debating that.  Portugal were even the better side: it was just a shame they won in such a controversial, or no one would have any issues whatsoever with them going through.

smile.gif

laugh.gif

I meant England's goal. Sorry smile.gif

I understand the point you make about the ball being stationary and whatnot. The highlights I saw on SportsCenter (unfortunately, we in the USA don't get soccer coverage unless it has something to do with Team USA) the kick was so far missed I think he just booted it. It looked funky, like his right foot just stuck in the ground and the ball went sailing high above the goal.

Oh well, in the end, he gets to "shag" a hottie female and he's rich.
Floyder
i agree with the rich, but i wouldnt call hottie to a skinny girl like his .
Redmak
Quote -
i just want to remind you that the penalty spot was the same for both teams... Lemme see, Beckham missed cause the spot wasnt flat, and rui costa not.


Yes, but the ball moved just when Beckham was about to shoot. This wasn't the case with all the others. It's no excuse but it can explain that weird shot of his.
Floyder
i didnt notice that the ball moved, i have to check the replay.
Lycan
Quote -
"Beckham: I wasn't fit to lead England to victory"

David Beckham has admitted for the first time that he was not fit to lead England's ill-fated attempt to win Euro 2004 - and that his recent problems on and off the pitch have been taking a heavy toll.
The England captain, who has been widely criticised for a series of largely anonymous performances in Portugal, claims that an inadequate fitness regime at his Spanish club left him well below his peak physical condition.

Beckham said: 'I don't think we've done as much conditioning work at Real Madrid as we used to do at Manchester United [whom he left in 2003].

'I didn't feel as fit in the second half of the season as I did in the first half. Maybe that's the way the Spanish game is.'

Asked if his lack of fitness had spilled over into Euro 2004, he replied: 'Yes, maybe it has.'

Beckham has had to defend himself since England lost on penalties to Portugal in the quarter-finals in Lisbon Thursday night.

Sources inside the England camp say he was well below ideal fitness levels when he joined the squad. Fitness coaches had to give him extra sessions.

Beckham also suggested that recent troubles, including claims that he betrayed his wife Victoria by having two affairs, have been getting on top of him. 'It has been tough this season on and off the pitch because of certain situations, but I am strong enough,' he said.

'I've got to be strong because I am a father who has got to look after two young boys and my wife. When I'm down they pick me up and when they're down I pick them up.'

But he insisted: 'I will overcome this.'

source : The Observer


Beckham´s lame excuse for his bad performance
CubanPete
I'm welsh and don;t even support england but i have to agree that that penalty spot was shocking. And its obvious it was dodgy bacause in the france match they made some kind of mesh to fix it also the england team had complained the day before specifically about the penalty spot being dodgy.

I dont care what anyone say's beckham does NOT do that for a penalty without something being wrong!!!
L3thal
Quote - (Lycan @ Jun 27 2004, 07:12)
Beckham´s lame excuse for his bad performance

At least he's not whining and crying whistle.gif
specialtech
a point that was made to me the other day

whenever there was a decision to be make that was a 50/50 it always went portugals way.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.