QUOTE(FuLouZero @ Dec 19 2004, 00:22)
I'm more of a critique person then a praising person so don't take it the wrong way.
I don't like this wallpaper because...
I don't think it was necessary to add that gradient aura around the earth and the moon. I think that makes it look horrible. If you made earth and moon MAJOR PROPS If its just a cut-out and enhance... 4/10
[right][snapback]585124539[/snapback][/right]
Good work on your detailed critique... You are one of the few on about 20 websites who finds that this wallpaper looks horrible.
I would usually point out that the people who give harsh criticism are usually people that have no background in art or have any idea what it takes to create wallpapers...
There is no such thing as "cut and enhance" when it comes to quality wallpapers.
I am sure you would have rather had the Earth and Moon sit behind a bevel with light dropping on it and have absolutely no shadow or "aura" - but then again you didn't make the wallpaper.
Now, dont take this the wrong way... but what have you made lately?
Also, please share with the rest of the site what your credentials are for making such criticisms about wallpapers... I give your critique a 1/10 - thanks.