Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Man can sue for distress over surprise pregnancy
Neowin Forums > Member Submitted News > The Hum's Real World News
macrosslover
http://www.cnn.com/2005/LAW/02/24/sperm.theft.ap/index.html

this story is absolutely hilarious
Mx²
rofl.gif laugh.gif
scaredmogwai
QUOTE
she secretly kept semen after they had oral sex, then used it to get pregnant.


blink.gif
lcg
QUOTE
she secretly kept semen after they had oral sex, then used it to get pregnant.

shocking.gif rofl.gif blink.gif
Serves the man right
insurektion
If he's telling the truth he has every right to be 'emotionally upset' though I would call it being ****ed off. I would never pay child support for a kid that I had no intention of having (assuming there was no accident) but for her to impregnate herself is really kinda of sick.
macrosslover
sad thing is they're both doctors. not sure if they're medical or phd, but still you'd expect better behavior from people with this level of education.
sdb815
Wow. blink.gif
nvizible
there are some rather depraved people in this world. here lie two prime examples!

edit: oh ye, i think it should be "here kneels one and stands the other" rofl.gif
Samoa
QUOTE
But he can't claim theft, the ruling said, because the sperm were hers to keep.


With that line of reasoning, she could do with the sperm as she liked. However, it was still wrong of her to impregnate herself and then claim a peternity suit. But yeah the guys a doctor he could afford to pay it, and she's a doctor and she definatley could have afford to pay it.
MadDog
Probably going to get in trouble for this one... ninja.gif

Guess that's a reminder to make sure they either spit or swallow.
nvizible
true, so true!
oddcrap
People will can and will sue over anything in our society.
[hxc]
i can see the relationship going downhill from the moment she told him what she had done
Max™
QUOTE
"There's a 5-year-old child here," Mirabelli said. "Imagine how a child feels when your father says he feels emotionally damaged by your birth."

Imagine how a child feels when your mother says she used your fathers sperm to make you after I kept it in a mug for years.

rofl.gif
kennyout
QUOTE(MadDog @ Feb 24 2005, 15:23)
Probably going to get in trouble for this one...  ninja.gif

Guess that's a reminder to make sure they either spit or swallow.
[right][snapback]585528157[/snapback][/right]


so true...or watch them spit it out in front of you onto a rag


let alone now we have to worry about girls learning to do this in order to keep their boyfriends/whatnot to get their money/ect.... unsure.gif

NeoXY
QUOTE(neotool @ Feb 24 2005, 20:09)
Wow. blink.gif
[right][snapback]585528087[/snapback][/right]


wow is right.....blink.gif
Snipe™
holy sh** that is funny, he get screwed big time
PermaSt0ne
QUOTE(kennyout @ Feb 24 2005, 14:56)
let alone now we have to worry about girls learning to do this in order to keep their boyfriends/whatnot to get their money/ect.... unsure.gif
[right][snapback]585529105[/snapback][/right]



bingo. this is along the lines of extortion. she's forcing him to pay money for a kid that he never wanted nor thought he could possibly had.

i feel sory for him that that b*tch did this to him. it's just so f*cked up..........
Persephone
What that woman did is so wrong (what a selfish b*tch). That kid is going to have issues when he finds out how he came into the world.

As for the father having to pay child support, I think that is a load of bs. He is not in any way to blame for this but he has to pay? That really is unfair. I'm all for absent fathers paying for their offspring, it's only fair when they helped create them, but technically this man didn't help at all.

Btw, for all you people out there going on about women getting pregnant on purpose to keep their bfs/for money, I do not think it is a very common tactic at all, especially when the bf can just walk away. It is also rather arrogant of you to think a someone would want you that much as well.
Mattc55
Nutz laugh.gif
Brandon
QUOTE(Mattc55 @ Feb 24 2005, 19:38)
Nutz  laugh.gif
[right][snapback]585529909[/snapback][/right]

hahah
Lumiplaty
Hopefully the guy does the right thing and kills the bitch.
Steffan
QUOTE
"She asserts that when plaintiff 'delivered' his sperm, it was a gift -- an absolute and irrevocable transfer of title to property from a donor to a donee," the decision said. "There was no agreement that the original deposit would be returned upon request."

so I can give sperm as a gift to my gf? I wish I knew this before now. I could have saved hundreds of dollars in gifts and she could never return it to the store
Quick Reply
The woman is absolutely wrong, and the man should not have to pay any kind of support. He shouldn't even be considered the parent of the child in a legal sense.

By the way, wrong forum.
HeavyTwenty
QUOTE(Angelhood @ Feb 24 2005, 20:48)
Hopefully the guy does the right thing and kills the bitch.
[right][snapback]585529944[/snapback][/right]
LMAO devil.gif.

But anyways, I'm not surprised by the whole child support thing. Didn't some a lady sue a sperm donor for child support after she was artifically inseminated?
Deaf Spacker
That is pathetic, the man didn't willingly create a child so he shouldn't have to pay support.
insanekiwi
haha. nice find rofl.gif
Matt
QUOTE
Phillips accuses Dr. Sharon Irons of a "calculated, profound personal betrayal" after their affair six years ago, saying she secretly kept semen after they had oral sex, then used it to get pregnant.


that is so messed up. thats one conniving bitch.
ZZOOzzoo
That is just so disgusting.

That b!tch should be punished.
Toastyone
QUOTE(insurektion @ Feb 24 2005, 15:05)
but for her to impregnate herself is really kinda of sick.
[right][snapback]585528074[/snapback][/right]


Talk about it.... She is really sick...I mean who in their right mind would do something like that and then go after the guy for child support..... wacko.gif
ConfusedFusion
Quoting from the original Article : " she secretly kept semen after they had oral s*x, then used it to get pregnant."

Just wondering, did she have a cup ready by the side. man, that is one whack job.

5Horizons
And I thought I had seen it all ohmy.gif

That's really messed up and I hope he wins.
Toology
Ridiculous.

If the sperm was delivered during oral sex, there was clearly no intention on his part to create a child. Semen a gift? Bah! This tops the charts on the bull-s*it-orometer.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.