These 2 wallpapers are made for a contest on a forum, i want to know the opinion of the neowin users what they think is the better wallpaper, especially look at the vector, cause the contest was about making a vector of the following photo:
Original Photo


TurkForce:

Made in Adobe Illustrator, background in Adobe Photoshop

Barryman:

Made in Adobe Illutstrator, background (not selfmade) added in Photoshop

choice is to you i like them both

Ahh...theyre both good. Second one has a bit more detail fromwhat I can say.

i prefer the 2nd ones bg and colors

Second one looks nicer to me. Btw, good choice of subject

I like the first one the best! The backgrounds give it the right touch imo

TurkForce's "Aishwarya Rai" .
The first one is big and better.

The eye (especially the outer region) needs more work on both.

First would be better without the text if text has to be there then second one .

which text do you mean? the ©2005 tfx ?

no the aishwray ray

umm if you open the wallpaper, you don't see it.. the text is only on the splash screen

Woh the indian Beauty...... I like both..... but i 've to choose one... so i'll go for the second one.

Second one for shizzle.

Vectoring on the 1st is better.
The eye on the 2nd is better. Thats the only thing.

So #1

Btw, where did you get that background print?? The weird shapes. Looks mighty similar to something my mom has. Could you link it?
Btw, aish is really good looking. Good actress too.

thx for your comment well the background consists of custom shapes that are in photoshop.. 4 different ones put together with a gradient on it

1st one man didnt realise the pictures were clickabale

I like Barryman's "Hint Gari"

Barryman's, it has better detailwork

Very cool wallpapers. I like the second one best Background on the first is too 'busy' for my liking.

i think u r right.. i also prefer more plain background when i want to use it as wallpaper.. but i like that of vectors, you can zoom, change colors and stuff, you could make a lot versions.. i liked it.. just need some more practice, especially in Adobe Illustrator, hehe.. it's a cool program but not as userfriendly as PhotoShop

I think Barryman's is better as well, I also like my backgrounds to be clean and clutter free.
The vector work is good with both though. And may I also say Aishwarya is damn fine, much more good looking than other Bollywood actresses like Kareena Kapoor, Preity Zinta and Kajol.

the first one for me...