What the hell happened there was newcastle scoring first with a nice little finish from dyer and then it all starts to go to pieces...any newcastle fans care to comment about this torrid display of defending??

They were a disgrace tonight and had no tactics at all. Man United will rip them apart

I watched the whole game today. Obviously, I'm portuguese so I was rooting for Sporting. Can't believe they managed such a comeback

Sporting!!!

We were robbed in england with the ref allowing all the brute english football to be played and not blowing for those fouls. Here on portugal our flair was a lot superior.

PortugaL!!!

When Dyer went off injured Newcastle had to change their way of play and thats when they fell apart. It would of probably been a different story if Boumsong was playing in the defence becuase without him, Newcastle look very fragile at the back. I want Man Utd to knock Newcastle out to and im hoping Van Nistlerooy will start getting his scoring touch back.

It was a very poor performance. I am going to the game on Sunday and I hope Robert is recalled! It was only bringing Robert back into the team that stopped Souness getting sacked already!!

Well it was poor. 1-1 after the 60th minute then conceding 3 goals. making it 4-2 on aggregate. I'm happy that this will be good for Sunday. Man U should win this.