Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: What should I get?
Neowin Forums > Help & Discussion Center > PDA, Tablet & Mobile Devices > Personal Media
wutang01
Ok ... I want to know what are my options.

What are the range of Hard Disk Portable Audio Players available to me?

I want 4 or 5GB minimum, and price doesn't worry me.

And ... something that has a decent battery life!! sleeping.gif

Your input is greatly appreciated. Thanks smile.gif



Regards,
wutang01
RPatel
There are lots of good ones. Ipods seem okay. One I really like the Creative Zen Touch.
panacea
QUOTE(wutang01 @ Apr 22 2005, 01:38)
Ok ... I want to know what are my options.
What are the range of Hard Disk Portable Audio Players available to me?
I want 4 or 5GB minimum, and price doesn't worry me.
And ... something that has a decent battery life!!  sleeping.gif



Rio Carbon for sure. if you dont care about color screen - it has great battery life. very nice player.

iriver h10, if you want the latest - i think its got color screen.

ipod - no. creative zen touch - i dont like, other creative players - too bulky,
PrototypeX2
QUOTE(wutang01 @ Apr 21 2005, 23:38)
Ok ... I want to know what are my options.

What are the range of Hard Disk Portable Audio Players available to me?

I want 4 or 5GB minimum, and price doesn't worry me.

And ... something that has a decent battery life!!  sleeping.gif

Your input is greatly appreciated. Thanks  smile.gif
Regards,
wutang01
[right][snapback]585811571[/snapback][/right]

Price don't worry you?
How about iAudio X5 then?
wutang01
Just curious ... how are those Hi-MDs?
Boundy
QUOTE(wutang01 @ Apr 22 2005, 08:28)
Just curious ... how are those Hi-MDs?
[right][snapback]585811694[/snapback][/right]


Very good, I had one last Wednesday and the good thing is they are 1GB a disc and the discs only cost £5.

I have the NH-1 asnd must say it has a good build quality and comes as standard with and LCD remote and charging cradle.

THey are also very small and have a long bettery life.
macman87
QUOTE(wutang01 @ Apr 22 2005, 17:28)
Just curious ... how are those Hi-MDs?
[right][snapback]585811694[/snapback][/right]


Great if you don't have over a gigabyte of music. If you have anything more than 3 or 4 GB, swapping disks just gets ridiculous.
ventrox
i'd go for ipod wink.gif
wutang01
I was thinking of getting a Mini hard disk audio player ... something like 4 or 5 or 6 gb (up to 10?)

I just don't know my options apart from Creative Zen Micro, m:robe 100, ipod mini ...
Zeni
Don't forget the iRiver H10. tongue.gif
wutang01
I actually like the looks of the iRiver H10 ... but the price here in Australia, is nearly the same as a iPod 20GB! ohmy.gif

Wish it was about the same price as an iPod mini first generation ...
radawsonco
Get the creative zen touch. You get 20 gb for a little over the price of an ipod mini, which has 4-6 gb. The touch also has the best sound quality (97dB) and battery life (24 hours) of any of the mp3 players takled about here. That way if you ever begin to purchase more music you will always have room for it. Plus the Creative Zen Touch looks cooler!
headless_armadillo
The Zen Touch is incredible. I just sold mine --> im getting an NW-HD5 biggrin.gif
PrototypeX2
QUOTE(headless_armadillo @ Apr 27 2005, 10:37)
The Zen Touch is incredible. I just sold mine --> im getting an NW-HD5 biggrin.gif
[right][snapback]585837995[/snapback][/right]

You'll be quite dissappointed.
I really don't like the looks, especially that "Mosaic" style tile keys.
And they are not easy to use.
r0manticide17
never ever EVER buy the ipoo! Its the worst thing ive ever seen. It was lovely until i got it out and fiddled with it. It didnt work at all, my computer didnt recognise it, and gradually it got worse. Plus, iTunes isnt much cop either if youre a big media player user like myself. Im bying a zen micro next week...black or purple??

buy the h10 or the micro. but never ipoo.
ZZOOzzoo
QUOTE(PrototypeX2 @ Apr 28 2005, 09:29)
You'll be quite dissappointed.
I really don't like the looks, especially that "Mosaic" style tile keys.
And they are not easy to use.
[right][snapback]585840091[/snapback][/right]

First of all, "look" is completely subjective, and it, in fact, looks all right to me.

NW-HD5 is incredibly thin and small, even thinner and smaller than iPod, and the difference in terms of thickness between Zen Touch and NW-HD5 would be tremendous.

Also, you should clarify how it's not easy to use.

It has play/pause button in the middle, with 4 arrows surrounding, and the rest of four buttons outside are volume up/down, stop, and menu button.

I find it interesting how one could actually find uneasiness with that layout. unsure.gif
PrototypeX2
QUOTE(ZZOOzzoo @ May 4 2005, 02:22)
First of all, "look" is completely subjective, and it, in fact, looks all right to me.

NW-HD5 is incredibly thin and small, even thinner and smaller than iPod, and the difference in terms of thickness between Zen Touch and NW-HD5 would be tremendous.

Also, you should clarify how it's not easy to use.

It has play/pause button in the middle, with 4 arrows surrounding, and the rest of four buttons outside are volume up/down, stop, and menu button.

I find it interesting how one could actually find uneasiness with that layout. unsure.gif
[right][snapback]585870707[/snapback][/right]

Here is something to clarify my point:
Yes the word "looks" is completely subjective, but NW-HD5 doesn't catch my eyes as well as other players.
What I meant about it not being easy to use is the compatibility and the interface of the player.
I'm not too fond of SonicStage, but still while I read some reports/reviews on their Sony players, they had quite a few troubles. And from the picture it seems that the NW-HD5 is still using not-as-friendly interface that was introduced since NW-HD1.
wutang01
Hmm ... quite difficult to find a Small hard disk audio player that has decent battery life, hey?

H10 seems like an option atm ...
PrototypeX2
QUOTE(wutang01 @ May 6 2005, 23:00)
Hmm ... quite difficult to find a Small hard disk audio player that has decent battery life, hey?

H10 seems like an option atm ...
[right][snapback]585884543[/snapback][/right]

If battery life is important, get Rio Carbon.
wutang01
I saw Sony's NW-HD3 and NW-HD5

20GB HDD
30+ hours!

Seems perfect for me biggrin.gif
Galley
iPod photo
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.