Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Ipod Mini vs. Zen Micro
Neowin Forums > Help & Discussion Center > PDA, Tablet & Mobile Devices > Personal Media
Pages: 1, 2
levianthen
The Zen Micro is selling fast, but how does it compare to the Ipod Mini. You decide right here!!! Ipod Mini vs. Zen Micro, and why did you choose that...[attachmentid=127094]
LispyGlitter2
ipod mini cos it's sexy as **** blush.gif
.Atlantis
Zen Micro.

Awesome Support
Genuinely awesome sound quality
Size
Price
Looks (prefer up and down (for up and down) compared to circles)
david622
i just got a mini 2 weeks ago and i'm very happy with it.

it looks great and it's extremely easy to navigate. it's very small and lightweight too.
planetik
Yes, I have heard myself how good the sound is on the creative one compared to the ipod...
I think it also looks sexy + it's smaller height-wise
Fog Dogg
This probably would have been better as a poll in the Personal Media Forum.. But the Zen micro looks much better in my opinion. In addition, the sound quality, extra features, and better colour selection just makes the package that much better smile.gif.
ShmengeTravel
I just got a Zen Micro and man, I was totally blown away by the sound. I previously owned a Rio Cali, which was equally awesome, but there is a sound quality difference and you can totally tell them apart. Plus, Zen Micro has wma support, an FM radio, and a todo list, which the mini does not. (AFAIK.)
Jay R.
Creative Zen Micro -> read my reviews in the reviews forum smile.gif
levianthen
QUOTE(Fog Dogg @ Jun 1 2005, 16:03)
This probably would have been better as a poll in the Personal Media Forum..  But the Zen micro looks much better in my opinion.  In addition, the sound quality, extra features, and better colour selection just makes the package that much better smile.gif.
[right][snapback]586002313[/snapback][/right]


Well I like the Zen Micro more, i just got one, and i was just seeing if people thought the same. The Zen Micro has so much more features. Good sound too, its awsome, I'd suggest Zen Micro
VGVL
iPod mini, I'm on my second one. The seamless aluminum design and iTunes Music Store integration did it for me.
wak1zashi
zen micro

-smaller
-better sound
-IMHO, looks better
Hypoxiaicon
Zen Micro, I own one and im glad I do smile.gif
IK47
ipod mini. The Zen micro is too good.
305
Zen Micro all the way. Tops just about every category, sound/look/size/price...ect

No competition!
gdodson
Zen Micro. Much better sound, smaller, 5gig, less expensive, better looking, user-serviceable battery.
levianthen
i honestly think that if zen micro had a new name it would have sold more than ipod. cause i feel that the name ipod is just a lot more catchy
goheels681
iPod mini
levianthen
So far the rusults are Zen Micro is the favorite 10 to 4.
kak
11 to 4

I love my Micro blush.gif
levianthen
me too yes.gif
Storm
Zen, so you dont have to use iTunes wink.gif
icecaveman
Go micro and be sure to install the PlaysForSure firmware if you intend to use it with more than one computer
5Horizons
I love my zen micro. smile.gif

I've used an iPod mini and it's fine too. For me, I liked the zen's size and features better.
Elmo
i really like the zen

had a go on a girl in schools one
Axel
This should be a poll! Zen Micro... simply because it looks way nicer. The iPod mini looks absolutely horrible and cheap... I'm sorry but it doesnt compare to the sexiness of the original iPod in any way!
Boxster17
I'd go with the iPod mini. Much prefer that interface as I've found it a lot easier to use and navigate. I also don't really care for the looks of the Zen Micro that much, and I always found it feels a bit cheapish.
Brandon Live
My only problem with the Zen Micro was that it didn't ship with the PlaysForSure firmware last I checked. Once you install that, using it is a dream. It's not a big deal for me, but it was a bit harder for my sister (whom I guided through the process over the phone).

It's my hope that the new ones ship with it.

The device itself is leaps and bounds ahead of the Mini (which, IMO, is also the ugliest portable player). And with other great offerings (the Rio Carbon and iRiver iH10), I don't see why anyone would buy a Mini unless they own a Mac.
kak
QUOTE(Boxster17 @ Jun 2 2005, 22:30)
I'd go with the iPod mini.  Much prefer that interface as I've found it a lot easier to use and navigate.  I also don't really care for the looks of the Zen Micro that much, and I always found it feels a bit cheapish.
[right][snapback]586006865[/snapback][/right]


Cheapish? The iPods fall into the entire new 'plastic it out' look that is trendy. The Zen Micro has a pressure pad and a scroll bar. Up/Down is also more logical than using a ciruclar motion to move up an down. It also has a much wider acceptance for music file types.
5Horizons
QUOTE
I'd go with the iPod mini. Much prefer that interface as I've found it a lot easier to use and navigate. I also don't really care for the looks of the Zen Micro that much, and I always found it feels a bit cheapish.


Their interfaces are basically the same, unless you meant the scroll wheel. Menu-wise, there's not much difference.
)(RockerBoy
zen micro all the way
PaulCabby
Zen Micro, hands down.
phedot
I love my Zen micro... But the only thing I dislike about it is the problem with deleting contacts (you can't)
Outsider
I'll go with IPod Mini too. Their model just seems more appealing to me..
Slimy
zen micro, ipods are only good for two reason: the clickwheel/appearance and their advertisement campaign. other than that, everything else is better.
edit: can you add a poll please?
retri
Zen Micro, Thumbs Up thumbs_up.gif

but.... take a look at this:

http://creative.com/products/mp3/zenneeon/
Andy07
I've only had a mini in my hand.
jeffeh
iPod mini: sound quality, wheel, look, ease of use
peterish

I've owned both players and there's no question in my mind, Zen is better. Seriously dude, get the Zen Micro; it's truly a better product. When I see people holding ipods in their hands walking down the street, I laugh to myself; what a bunch of brain washed trend whores.
jeffeh
hahaha I was thinking about moving away from the iPod, I have a shuffle and think thats enough... whats the sound quality on the Zen... is it practically the same as a ipod? and how about price?
levianthen
QUOTE(jeffeh @ Jun 2 2005, 15:56)
iPod mini: sound quality, wheel, look, ease of use
[right][snapback]586007268[/snapback][/right]


Dude...are you out of your mind, the sound quality on the zen micro is way better. That's wanna of the good features for the zen. The ipod sound quality doesn't compare to my butt!!! And the last guy asked bout price.

Ebay's Buy it Now

Zen Micro
159, but i saw one for 154, buy it now, brand new yesterday
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewI...5778366145&rd=1


* Stores 3,000 songs on 6GB1 hard drive
* Stores 2,500 songs on 5GB1 hard drive
* Stores 2,000 songs on 4GB1 hard drive
* Micro-sized (3.3" tall, 2" wide, 0.7" deep)
* Available in 102 electrifying colors (Black, White, Silver, Dark blue, Light blue, Red, Purple, Citrus Orange, Lime Green and Pink)
* Features a removable lithium ion battery
* Get up to 12 hours playback time on a single charge3
* FM radio to listen and record
* Integrated voice recorder gives up to 10 hrs of recording time
* Vertical touch pad for easy and intuitive navigation
* Access over 2 million songs through Zen supported music services
* Highest audio clarity at 98dB SNR
* High fidelity earphones with dynamic bass response
* Contacts, Calendar and Tasks4
* Plays MP3, WMA, WAV files
* Functions as an external hard drive for backup of computer files
* Backlit LCD displays track info
* Repeat, resume, and random play
* 8 EQ settings (Acoustic, classical, disco, jazz, new age, pop, rock and vocal)
* Sleep and wake timers
* Customizable main menu, so the features you want are right at your finger tips
* USB 2.0 interfaces (cables included)
* Belt clip / stand
* Weight: 3.8 oz. (includes removable battery)
* Warranty: 1 year limited hardware warranty / 90 day service warranty


Ipod Mini
170 buy it now, some were cheaper but they were pink, so, that's fruity
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewI...5778174501&rd=1


* Enjoy long battery life: Up to 18 hours on a single charge(1)
* Charge and sync via one simple USB 2.0 connection
* Wear or carry up to 1,500 songs
* Use iPod mini with Mac OS X or Windows 2000/XP
* Take it everywhere — it weighs only 3.6 ounces
* Find songs fast with the Apple Click Wheel
* Play MP3, AAC, Audible and Apple Lossless files
* Walk, jog or work out with up to 25 minutes of skip protection
* Sync music seamlessly with iTunes
* Store files along with your music
* Remind yourself with Text Notes
* Play games on the go
* Stay organized with contacts, calendars and to-do lists



I'd suggest buy it now on ebay, you can get a buy it now mp3 player for about 30-40 dollars cheaper.



As you can see Zen Micro looks way sexier
pc2005
zen micro
giga
QUOTE
As you can see Zen Micro looks way sexier

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. The iPod mini is tall and thin while the Zen is short and fat.
levianthen
sorry, but i dont reall have a zen micro, i do have an ipod mini though, im getting a zen in the mail
theyarecomingforyou
I finally held a Zen Micro the other day... boy is that thing small. I've obviously held regular iPod's, and the iPod Mini, but I hadn't ever seen a Zen Micro in person. I really like the look/feel of it and sound quality is always great on Creative players, but I'm still waiting for better players (the Zen Neeon looks real nice, but has a lower SNR sad.gif).
Brandon Live
Wow, I didn't know they had a new 20GB full-size Zen coming.

It's not listed on the North America store yet, but you can see it here.

About time. Until I saw that I figured there was still a reason for some people to buy iPods. I think that anyone who bought an iPod Mini since the release of the Carbon and Zen Micro is insane.

But until now, I didn't think the big iPod had any clearly superior competition. Looks like those days are over.
PrototypeX2
QUOTE(levianthen @ Jun 2 2005, 18:04)
Dude...are you out of your mind, the sound quality on the zen micro is way better. That's wanna of the good features for the zen. The ipod sound quality doesn't compare to my butt!!! And the last guy asked bout price.

EDITED[right][snapback]586007607[/snapback][/right]

Not really.
It's just preference. Although the output SNR of Zen Micro is much stronger than iPod mini, the impedance of the headphones take a significant role, too.
I do personally like Zen Micro better, but when comparing sound quality, iPod has a very balanced, clean, neutral sound to it. Preferably good for Classical, Jazz, Blues and other genres related to that.
NetRyder
I had a choice to pick one as a birthday gift. I chose the Zen Micro, of course.
I think the reasons have been well summed up already - superb sound quality, tiny size, great controls, the user-replaceable battery, and the extras (FM tuner, voice recording) for when you need them.

I've had it just for a week, and I've already managed to make a few iPod Mini owners quite jealous. wink.gif
sharpy2k4
i have a Zen Mirco, and all my mates have Ipod Minis. I chose the Micro cause its small, changeable battery and the fact that EVERYONE has an Ipod/Ipod mini just irritates me. The only problem is, i think my battery is screwed....if i take it to school, i can listen to it for around 3/6 hours im there, but by the time im home the battery is like on the last bar. I think i have the 4Hour battery version which Pi$$e$ me off!!! other than that its amazing xD
SkaterAustin
zen micro, its nice looking, size, sound quality, features.

Im waiten on the new zen 20 thats based on the zen micro, its taking creative to dam long to get it out!
eversor
· Swappable battery
· better looks IMO
· Outlook snychronizing
· no need to have special software to use it (i don't like itunes)
· you can put any file on it ( ok. you can do this on the ipod but you have to allocate the space for other files in itunes - silly behaviur)
· everybody has a frickin iPod. They annoy me just like the Louis Vitton bags. It seems every second women her in the town has this combi....
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.