I just watched The Illusionist and thought it was quite good seeing as I dont like period stories...but the fact there was magic involved and mystery made me interested through out the whole movie and although half way through the film I worked out the ending it was a good film to watch when you want your mind tested.

(IMDB)

7/10

I thought it was a pretty decent movie. Definitely something I would get on DVD.

think i'll give it a miss then.

Jessica is hot but i can't stand her acting

i watched it earlier this evening. i thought overall it was pretty good. but for many of us that watches a lot of movies, the plot becomes predictable.

This film wasn't released in my country, so I'll just have to wait for the dvd, pirated or not.

Anyhow try The Prestige - also a movie about magicians, and also one of the best films of all time.

Yeah I wanted to see that will wait for DVD for that

Just got this on DVD. Going to watch it tonight or tomorrow. But I'm sure The Prestige is better than this.

LOL... I saw both, and The Prestige was crap compared to The Illusionist... I think most will agree.

Time to watch this film

Best movies of all time? LOL... Wow how peoples opinions vary!

Yes IMO The Prestige was the best movie of 2006.

How many movies did you see? LOL.

You went from all time to 2006. Interesting.

Did I say it was the best movie of all time? No. I said it was one of the best movies of all time. And stop LOL-ing.

No doubt one of the best movies I've seen in awhile.

Haven't seen Illusionist but I might agree with you on that. Prestige was so predictable. Ed Norton is one of my favorite actors, so the movie should be somewhat good. Checking it out soon.

No way as good as The Prestige. The one thing this is better than The Prestige is the visuals. The cinematography and colours are excellent! The plot is in reality a simple love story with a bit of mystery. There is a twist in the ending, and although I wasn't able to guess entirely through, it still wasn't very surprising to me. Where as for The Prestige, I managed to geuss quite a bit but the revelation was still shocking. Oh and the script in The Prestige was SO MUCH tighter.

All of Norton's movies have been good, so is this, but I was disappointed in his performance. He was very.. restrained and didn't realize his full potential. Paul Giamatti was brilliant though. Jessica Biel was good, but who cares anyways she's beautiful.

Also, all the magic we see in The Prestige is practical magic, aka HOAXES ([spoiler]except the duplicating device, which is real magic?[/spoiler]). Here, while I think the audience is led to believe the magic performed are all faked, it doesn't look so. Many of the tricks here are very much impossible to perform by a stage performer today.

In all honesty though, it is quite unfair to compare The Prestige and The Illusionist. The former is a tale of two competing magicians who try to outdo each other no matter what, a tale of the dangers of obsession. The latter is a love story in turn-of-the-century Vienna. They do share similarities, but not a whole lot.

That said I prefer The Prestige over this.

8/10 for The Illusionist.
10/10 for The Prestige.

whoa whoa whoa, 10/10? a perfect movie? seems kinda crazy, lol, i might have to check it out.

good movie but some of it is just so stupid.

the orange tree, the book describes that it's mechanical. that still doesn't explain how the fruit grows and the butterflies. i imagined the audience tried to eat the orange when the magic toss it them. if it was mechanical, then the fruit has to be fake. and if the orange tree can be done mechanically, why did the movie used special effects? lol, that's just contradiction and makes the mechanical orange tree book implausible.

what about the spirits? that was never explained. they obviously didn't have advanced star-trek era holographic technology. so how the F did he do it?

Haha yea that'd what I thought. The 'spirits' is impossible to perform even with the technology today. The orange tree is mechanical, and I guess the 'oranges' were balloons and after plucking them he secretly exchanged them with real ones. The butterflies has to be fake, with wires of course, though it would still be damn difficult to perfect.

BTW the score of The Illusionist, by Philip Glass, is fantastic.

I'm planning to watch this soon with a few family members. Are there any nudity or sexual scenes?

I watched it a few weeks ago, and was surprised at how good it really was. It had some slow parts but overall was really interesting and great "magic"

I think it was definitely a 8/10

The orange tree was partially done mechanically but they used CG for the oranges and some other parts because it was too complicated.

You dont see any breasts or full nudity but there is sex scene. Not very graphic though.

watched this with some family (best friends and various ladies) and we all unanimously loved the movie. i saw the previews for it when it was in theaters and thought nothing much of it, and a friend got the dvd last week so we all watched it and i was surprised by how good it was. what's ironic is that i just thought of this movie a few hours ago and added it to the top of my netflix queue. sweet movie

note that i'm a video guru and predict most every single movie i see before it happens, and this was less predictable although i did realize what was going to pan out.. but that doesn't really detract from a movie for me.. it's definitely a different movie than what's typical nowadays..

If anyone has the movie right now, can you tell me at which duration that scene is so I'm ready for it?

I rented this movie last week. Was ok, better then I thought it would be, but a bit predictable.

Yeah it is a bit at times but watch the Prestige its alot better imo...even tho I created this thread

Gonna try and watch both this week. I'm partial to the Illusionist as I'm a fan of smoke and errr, magic. A fan of magic.

Just watched this.... the ending made my hair on the back of my neck stand up...

one of the best movies ever!

Really? I thought the Illusionist was better. I thought the Prestige was good, but a bit predictable. LOL Maybe I was just too distracted by Beal.

I loved that movie. It was well done.

I'd say they were both good.

Excellent film, I loved it. Also, The Prestige is very good.

I know i'm late, but the trailers weren't interesting to me. If I am to sit for 2 hours and focus on a movie then it better be good. And this movie was gun!!

Love this film, truley amazing!
One of my top favorites.

9.5/10