Hello, trying to choose between these two edits of a surfer strutting his stuff.
Would appreciate your opinions, thoughts, criticisms, abuse, etc.

Here are the edits;

Shot A

Click to view attachment

Shot B

Click to view attachment

Thanks a lot.

i would say the first one. I find the second one boring, a black and white (or sepia) shot of the sea just doesn't cut it.

The sea lives, it's wild and untamed, making it black and white ruins that.

Shot B is too dark and I agree with XerXis but Shot A needs more colour

+1

Ok, thanks for the input.
You're going to say you like the plain colour version now aren't you?


Shot C (Normal Colour Version)
Click to view attachment

well i will choose the first one A its look more appealing and much cooler than other

That's the best one of all three indeed

Normal colour version for sure.

Crap I said A, but i prefer c

No probs, thanks for the replies guys.
Anymore?

C
The true color one looks good.

C

-Rich-

i'm for a mixture of A and C

Honestly, i'm B.

lol

yeah, mix of A and C. Perhaps C as an Overlay layer?