People are too quick to assume that we're at fault even though 100's of others don't seem to have the issue you're having.
That's not true. The first thing I always assume is that i'm an idiot and probably doing something wrong.
I still didn't understand your explanation to my problem.
When I reply a thread I want to get only one notification \ email until I visit the thread again.
To my understanding the only line in the notification settings that responsible for this is
"v Auto follow topics I reply to. Notification frequency:"
With "Immediate" I can get 30 notifications for 30 replies from X thread regardless if I visit the thread.
With "Offline" I will get 1 Email \ Notification for 30 replies from X thread IF I'm Offline (Completely disconnected from neowin) until I'll visit the thread (that will trigger the notifications for this thread again) .
If I'm online but reading some other thread I won't be notified for a new reply on the X thread
*Of course blaming anyone from neowin was a joke , I'm just trying to figure out how to make it work for me like it used to.