Students failing to meet reading goals punished with face painting


Recommended Posts

DECLO, Idaho (KBOI) - Some parents are outraged in Cassia County after they say their students experienced principal approved teacher bullying.

The incident occurred at Declo Elementary. A teacher allowed fourth graders to paint the faces of fellow classmates who didn't reach their reading goals.

The Cassia School District confirmed to KBOI 2News that if a child in the class didn't reach their reading goal, they could either miss recess or have their face painted on. Students were allowed to use markers to draw mustaches, goatees and names on the face of slower readers in the class.

"Not only was my son punished with bullying but the other students were rewarded with bullying," a parent who's son's face was painted on said. "They are being taught that bullying is OK and that there's nothing wrong with this."

The principal of the school says she knew about the drawings. The superintendent of the district says the fourth graders had a say in the decision.

"The class had discussed their accelarated reading goals and tried to put together incentives," said Gaylen Smyer, Cassia superintendent. "One of the incentives is that those who met their goal would be able to paint the face of those who didn't meet their goal."

There are 24 students in this particular fourth grade class. Nine of the students did not reach the reading goals and six opted for the face painting option. The other three skipped recess.

Parents seem to be divided on the issue. Some say this is an unfair teaching tactic while others are standing behind the school.

"I'm one of many parents who stand by the teacher's methods and what she does," said Carla Christensen, a local mom. "We think she's a wonderful teacher and we want to see her stay at Declo for many years to come."

Smyer said the school district is taking the bullying accustations seriously and the incident is under investigation.

source

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Cassia School District confirmed to KBOI 2News that if a child in the class didn't reach their reading goal, they could either miss recess or have their face painted on. Students were allowed to use markers to draw mustaches, goatees and names on the face of slower readers in the class.

So the choice is given to the kid, or they could just do their homework / reading assignments. Just another non-issue being blown out of proportion by useless entitled soccer mums.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't agree with singling out the slower kids. I prefer positive reinforcement as regards education.

Reward those who work hard, or who perform well. Those who are lazy (note I said earlier work hard or perform well...both should be rewarded) shouldn't be. I don't think they should be singled out...but those who do well deserve a reward.

Letting kids paint and stuff on the slower kids? Not so nice...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So the choice is given to the kid, or they could just do their homework / reading assignments. Just another non-issue being blown out of proportion by useless entitled soccer mums.

Basically this.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So the choice is given to the kid, or they could just do their homework / reading assignments. Just another non-issue being blown out of proportion by useless entitled soccer mums.

It doesn't matter, it's bullying, and done by the school, and they should know better!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Fair enough. If the kids collectively decided on rewards/punishments, then it is a good life lesson for those to be meted.

Can't people see that this attitude of "Oh, we did well, let's have a raise" vs "Oh, we failed, but failure's ok too" has nurtured the same sense of entitlement that a lot of people are against? Stop giving kids this notion that no one loses, or that it's ok to set goals and consequences, and should you fail, just...write them off.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This topic is now closed to further replies.