43 replies to this topic

[LaP]

Hum, on 21 March 2013 - 13:46, said:

It might have gone down as just a harmless (if annoying) prank. But unfortunately for Whaley, Park Hills Police Sgt. Richard Webster was working off-duty security detail at the time (must be some high rollers at this bingo hall).

Really good use of tax payers money.

When i was young the police had better things to do.

Detection, on 21 March 2013 - 14:06, said:

We should start a trend like that harlem shake thing that's going around, no bingo halls will be safe

Man that would be awesome.

[LaP]

zhiVago, on 21 March 2013 - 16:54, said:

p.s. As for the cinema, if someone disturbs my movie watching session and the administration does nothing about it, I demand a refund.

Me too. But it looks like she should call the police instead. Anyway according to this police officer ...

[Anaron]

I can understand banning the use of a word in a courtroom, but preventing someone from using a word with the threat of jail time is unfair. The kid should have simply been banned from the bingo hall.

[Stoffel]

I can't believe this made it all the way to court.
Don't they have anything better to do?

A slap against the back of the head and move on.

[HSoft]

zhiVago, on 21 March 2013 - 16:54, said:

imho it's not the same thing.

Shouting "fire" causes panic. Shouting "bingo" doesn't cause panic.

You mustn't have been to a bingo hall filled with old ladies lately then
Freedom of speech doesn't just mean you are not allowed to say something if it will cause panic. Go into a predominently black ghetto neighbourhood and start shouting n*****. If you get out alive, you can and should be charged with disorderly conduct (and possibly inciting a riot amongst others, although that doesn't apparently apply to Jesse Jackson for some reason but that's a whole other topic).

[+zhiVago]

HSoft, on 21 March 2013 - 17:28, said:

You mustn't have been to a bingo hall filled with old ladies lately then
Freedom of speech doesn't just mean you are not allowed to say something if it will cause panic. Go into a predominently black ghetto neighbourhood and start shouting n*****. If you get out alive, you can and should be charged with disorderly conduct (and possibly inciting a riot amongst others, although that doesn't apparently apply to Jesse Jackson for some reason but that's a whole other topic).

Again, it's a bad comparison.

Shouting "bingo" is harmless, it doesn't ignite riots or hate. It doesn't offend anyone.

[compl3x]

HSoft, on 21 March 2013 - 16:19, said:

Don't think you quite understand the concept of freedom of speech...

HSoft, on 21 March 2013 - 16:52, said:

lmao - so according to you it would be a cinema's fault for not arranging a safe and fair environment if someone decided to go into a crowded cinema and start shouting fire?
mmm.... not so sure you understand the concept of the first ammendment.

Do you understand? It would seem not.

Screaming fire in a theatre isn't a form of protected speech. Or screaming "I have a gun and I am going to shoot everyone in here" or "I planted a bomb under everyone's table and you all have 30 seconds before they detonate". Libel or slander aren't protected speech. Incitement is another one.

What he kid did was obnoxious and annoying but to argue it would have resulted in the same kind of panic, riot or chaos as those examples mentioned above is absurd. He should have been fined or warned and that should have been the end of it. Banning the kid from saying bingo is as about as stupid as it gets.

[Growled]

That'd be just my luck. Pull a good prank and a policeman would be there to catch me before I would even enjoy it.

[Torolol]

is he banned saying 'bingo' anywhere or just near bingo hall when he not playing one ?

[LaP]

Torolol, on 22 March 2013 - 03:15, said:

is he banned saying 'bingo' anywhere or just near bingo hall when he not playing one ?

Anywhere from what i understand.

[francescob]

torrentthief, on 21 March 2013 - 14:05, said:

bahaha! Crazy that a judge has banned him from exercising his freedom of speech. He could just ban him from going to bingo clubs instead. Sending him to jail if he does it again is crazy.

Then he would have called the bingo hall and shouted Bingo on the phone! duh!

torrentthief, on 21 March 2013 - 14:05, said:

bahaha! Crazy that a judge has banned him from exercising his freedom of speech. He could just ban him from going to bingo clubs instead. Sending him to jail if he does it again is crazy.

Then he would have called the bingo hall and shouted Bingo on the phone! duh!

[notuptome2004]

My Girl Bingo scene

[SPEhosting]

MERICA!

[Javik]

NoPanShabuShabu, on 21 March 2013 - 14:08, said:

Come on you guys, the punishment here boils down to saying "don't do it again."

The punishment amounts to him being banned from saying a word. Which violates his constitutional right to freedom of speech.