Post games that are non horror but freaked you out of your jimmies.
This boss fight right here
O HELL NAW, WUT U KNOW 'BOUT DAT VECTORMAN 2 SON?! Hahahah, can't believe you posted The Shadow. Loved that boss fight. And man, the music for this game was epic!
Anyway, I know you said non-horror, but it's kind of in-between. The zombie squirrels and teddy bears from Conker's Bad Fur Day rustled my jimmies a bit. I don't like being chased, and I can't stand being chased by smaller things especially. I think bad controls are often what scare me though.
Also, heights. Some of the jumping puzzles on Guild Wars 2 screw with my head and make me want to quit, especially when I'm trying to follow someone just so that I can help them kill a boss that's back there. I'm a great platformer, as I used to do all sorts of trick jumps back in the day, but heights aren't my thing. ><
Hmm, I would have to say the most recent non-horror scared was in dishonored. I had just done a tonne of sneaking, and was near a bunch of people so I was scared that I would be seen. I heard foot steps and freaked out, killed the person only to find it was a person I didn't want to die.
Playing TES IV: Oblivion, was in the dungeon that you get Mehrunes Razor (believe that is the name).. guy in the coffin behind me after I ignored him got up, stood behind me. I only turned around to see him staring at me because I heard footsteps.