main
Report a problem

Microsoft Max Killed Off

Computer Guru   on 02 November 2006 - 11:04 · 54 comments & 25077 views

Advertisement (Why?)
Yesterday Microsoft announced Vista's final RTM date - and yesterday they killed the last bit of Longhorn still in Vista. Microsoft Max, the digital media collaboration/sharing and information visualization is suit is officially dead. What was Microsoft Max, and is there still hope for a media-based team collaboration software? And if Microsoft Max was already so far along, why did it have to be killed?

Quote -
Well, it’s official at any rate. Contrary to what you’ve heard, Windows Vista will not be shipping with any of the original technologies, features, capabilities, or subsystems originally promised. First it was the real Aero – complete visual control over one’s system. Amazing graphics, sidebars that were a part of the Windows Core, Aero Diamond. Then it was NGSCB and its amazing security features – not DRM, but total privacy control; your privacy. Monad. Last we heard, it was WinFS, the king-pin feature that was promised to change the way you think of data… And now the last one is gone: Microsoft Max is dead.


Link: Microsoft Max Murdered
News source: NeoSmart Technologies

Post a comment · Send to friend Comments · There are 54 additional comments
(2 replies) #1 Electronic Punk on 02 Nov 2006 - 11:10
They announced the business launch date, not the RTM date if I remember correctly.
#1.1 rIaHc3 on 02 Nov 2006 - 17:21
business launch date = RTM will be before
#1.2 Electronic Punk on 03 Nov 2006 - 09:55
Quote - rIaHc3 said @ #1.1
business launch date = RTM will be before


I tried reading that a few times and just couldn't figure out what you were trying to say.
Anyway, it will RTM before business customers get it, I am still hoping it will be very soon.

Bored to hell with x64.
#2 Timan on 02 Nov 2006 - 11:18
We can only hope they release packs (plus anyone?) after its released that adds more functionality and stuff people actually wanted in a new windows.
#3 HawkMan on 02 Nov 2006 - 11:19
ummm. since when was MAX a Longhorn/Vista thing?

MAX was a .net/Avalon demonstration project, and was freely availabel for XP as well. it was created simply to deomstrate the possibilities of the new technologies presented in Vista but also backported to XP.

oh and the technologies MAX was based on is still in vista. Maybe time to get a source that is not some anti MS zealot with a grudge or something ? someone with an ounce of clue what vista is and what is in Vista. since the quote there obviusly is not such a person...
(2 replies) #4 Jugalator on 02 Nov 2006 - 11:23
Hehe... "Max Killed Off"... "Max Murdered"... "Microsoft Max is dead"... :o
What a necrophilic post

Anyway, I didn't expect that .NET tech demo app going anywhere really. Wasn't it just to demonstrate WinFX / .NET 3.0 a little? If you were looking for an actual usable application, I think you'd be better off looking at Picasa anyway.

Oh, and Max wasn't "the last bit of Longhorn in Vista". It was neither in Vista, nor a part of Longhorn. It was just a small standalone application.
#4.1 Daffy_Duck on 02 Nov 2006 - 12:03
Quote - Jugalator said @ #4
Hehe... "Max Killed Off"... "Max Murdered"... "Microsoft Max is dead"... :o
What a necrophilic post


Well, not really. Look up the definition. I didn't see anything sexual about the post.
#4.2 Jugalator on 02 Nov 2006 - 12:15
Yeah, I knew I was sloppily using the term; I meant "the love of death", not "the love of corpses", but hopefully you saw my point anyway.
(3 replies) #5 Deniss on 02 Nov 2006 - 11:29
Longhorn is the ****. Vista - sucks.
#5.1 MioTheGreat on 02 Nov 2006 - 12:47
I'm going to guess you haven't been beta testing, or you'd realize what an idiot you sound like. Vista is amazing.
#5.2 mrmckeb on 02 Nov 2006 - 14:28
Quote - MioTheGreat said @ #5.1
I'm going to guess you haven't been beta testing, or you'd realize what an idiot you sound like. Vista is amazing.

Well put my friend.
#5.3 yert* on 03 Nov 2006 - 07:24
Vista isn't really amazing. It's like XP with a new shiny theme and a couple extra features...
#6 ClintEastman on 02 Nov 2006 - 11:35
I hear it's all going into a Live app.
#7 altermind on 02 Nov 2006 - 11:49
booo.... i used this for sharing photes with family alot
(4 replies) #8 +thefunkymunky on 02 Nov 2006 - 12:32
So Vista is going to ship without any of the new breakthrough technologies orginally planned. Is this correct? What's the difference between Vista and xp, besides the fancy UI.
#8.1 HawkMan on 02 Nov 2006 - 12:49
Quote - thefunkymunky said @ #8
So Vista is going to ship without any of the new breakthrough technologies orginally planned. Is this correct?

no
#8.2 Primetime2006 on 03 Nov 2006 - 00:14
Quote - thefunkymunky said @ #8
So Vista is going to ship without any of the new breakthrough technologies orginally planned. Is this correct? What's the difference between Vista and xp, besides the fancy UI.


If that is what you think, you should kill yourself now. Vista is still a worthwhile upgrade.

#8.3 Kushan on 03 Nov 2006 - 05:59
Then blame the author of this news source, not the person who commented here.
#8.4 ANova on 03 Nov 2006 - 17:45
Quote - Primetime2006 said @ #8.2
If that is what you think, you should kill yourself now. Vista is still a worthwhile upgrade.


You're not very bright are you.
#9 specialtech on 02 Nov 2006 - 12:40
could have been worse
Max Pain for Vista
#10 Lare2 on 02 Nov 2006 - 12:57
R.I.P ....
(2 replies) #11 mrmckeb on 02 Nov 2006 - 13:14
Max was a technology development program - not a Vista feature. Who lets these idiots write articles?
#11.1 GreyWolfSC on 02 Nov 2006 - 16:33
Quote - mrmckeb said @ #11
Max was a technology development program - not a Vista feature. Who lets these idiots write articles?


The Constitution? But it also lets us tell them they're idiots... ;D
#11.2 rIaHc3 on 02 Nov 2006 - 17:23
Quote - mrmckeb said @ #11
Max was a technology development program - not a Vista feature. Who lets these idiots write articles?

And, Computer Guru, is the other idiot that believes, copies, and pastes this article on here.
#12 naap51stang on 02 Nov 2006 - 13:26
LOL........by the time Vista is released, they should call it WindowsXP SP2.5 W/eye candy.......
Yes, for those of you who don't understand humor, that was a joke.
I've been running it on my laptop as an upgrade to windows XP MCE and it caught 100% of my
hardware, and 100% of my software works perfectly. At least for me, it was very stable out of
the box, but I'm sure as with any OS, once it is "in the wild" it will have a few bugs.


(4 replies) #13 Magallanes on 02 Nov 2006 - 13:28
Quote -
Bill Gates died in a car accident. Arriving at the pearly gates, he
finds himself being sized up by St. Peter.

"Well, Bill, I'm really confused on this call; I'm not sure whether to send you to Heaven or Hell. After all, you enormously helped society by putting a computer in almost every home in America, yet you also created that ghastly Windows Vista. I'm going to do something I've never done before.....

I'm going to let you decide where you want to go."

"So what's the difference between the two?" Bill asked.

St. Peter said, "I could let you visit both places briefly, if it will help your decision."

"Fine! Where should I go first?"

"You decide."

"Okay then," said Bill, "Let's try Hell first."

So Bill Gates went to Hell. It was a beautiful, clean, sandy beach with clear waters and lots of bikini-clad women running around, playing in the water, laughing and frolicking about. The sun was shining; the temperature perfect. He was very pleased.

"This is great!" he told St. Peter. "If this is hell, I'd REALLY like to see heaven!"

"Fine," said St. Peter, and off they went. Heaven was a place high in the clouds, with angels drifting about, playing harps and singing. It was nice, but nothing like Hell. It didn't take long for Bill to reach his decision.

"I think I prefer Hell," he told St. Peter.

So Bill Gates went to Hell. Two weeks later, St. Peter decided to check on the late billionaire to see how he was doing in Hell. When he got there, he found Bill, shackled to a wall, screaming amongst hot flames in a dark cave, being burned and tortured by demons.

"How's everything going?" he asked Bill Gates.

His voice filled with anguish and disappointment, Bill responded, "this is awful! This is nothing like the Hell I visited two weeks ago! I can't believe this is happening! What happened to that other place, with the beautiful beaches, the scantily-clad women playing in the water?"

"Oh, that was a demo," replied St. Peter. "This is the RTM."
#13.1 mrmckeb on 02 Nov 2006 - 14:31
Funny... So funny I couldn't even begin to think of a reason to laugh. You can't blame Bill Gates if Vista isn't the operating system turned computer game that you seem to want (which is what MacOS is). Give the man some credit. You probably wouldn't even have a half the things on your PC if it wasn't for Microsoft's efforts to bring computing to everybody.

...and a demo? It's not a game. An Alpha release would have been more precise.
#13.2 Boogiman on 02 Nov 2006 - 16:09
Quote - mrmckeb said @ #13.1
Funny... So funny I couldn't even begin to think of a reason to laugh. You can't blame Bill Gates if Vista isn't the operating system turned computer game that you seem to want (which is what MacOS is). Give the man some credit. You probably wouldn't even have a half the things on your PC if it wasn't for Microsoft's efforts to bring computing to everybody.

...and a demo? It's not a game. An Alpha release would have been more precise.


dude, lighten up. It's a joke....... Well, I found it funny ....
#13.3 rIaHc3 on 02 Nov 2006 - 17:25
Quote - Magallanes said @ #13
Quote -
Bill Gates died in a car accident. Arriving at the pearly gates, he
finds himself being sized up by St. Peter.

"Well, Bill, I'm really confused on this call; I'm not sure whether to send you to Heaven or Hell. After all, you enormously helped society by putting a computer in almost every home in America, yet you also created that ghastly Windows Vista. I'm going to do something I've never done before.....

I'm going to let you decide where you want to go."

"So what's the difference between the two?" Bill asked.

St. Peter said, "I could let you visit both places briefly, if it will help your decision."

"Fine! Where should I go first?"

"You decide."

"Okay then," said Bill, "Let's try Hell first."

So Bill Gates went to Hell. It was a beautiful, clean, sandy beach with clear waters and lots of bikini-clad women running around, playing in the water, laughing and frolicking about. The sun was shining; the temperature perfect. He was very pleased.

"This is great!" he told St. Peter. "If this is hell, I'd REALLY like to see heaven!"

"Fine," said St. Peter, and off they went. Heaven was a place high in the clouds, with angels drifting about, playing harps and singing. It was nice, but nothing like Hell. It didn't take long for Bill to reach his decision.

"I think I prefer Hell," he told St. Peter.

So Bill Gates went to Hell. Two weeks later, St. Peter decided to check on the late billionaire to see how he was doing in Hell. When he got there, he found Bill, shackled to a wall, screaming amongst hot flames in a dark cave, being burned and tortured by demons.

"How's everything going?" he asked Bill Gates.

His voice filled with anguish and disappointment, Bill responded, "this is awful! This is nothing like the Hell I visited two weeks ago! I can't believe this is happening! What happened to that other place, with the beautiful beaches, the scantily-clad women playing in the water?"

"Oh, that was a demo," replied St. Peter. "This is the RTM."

That joke is a very old programmer joke. The original doesn't have Bill Gates.


and yes you have failed at being funny.
#13.4 Magallanes on 02 Nov 2006 - 19:12
Quote - rIaHc3 said @ #13.3

and yes you have failed at being funny.


No, the joke was from MS, giving some preview and new features of the OS and later removing it.


#14 Havin_it on 02 Nov 2006 - 13:50
Oh well, bye then Microsoft Max.

Off you go to the Last Chance Saloon. Microsoft Bob is waiting there to buy you a drink
(4 replies) #15 Stebet on 02 Nov 2006 - 14:01
What an utterly stupid and wrong "news" item.

There is only one "framework/technology" that has been killed off from Vista: WinFS

All the rest are still there, including the new audio stack, new networking stack, Windows Communication Foundation (Indigo, part of .NET 3.0), Windows Presentation Foundation (Avalon, part of .NET 3.0), DWM (Deskptop Composition) and tons tons tons more. A lot of new stuff was even added to the .NET 3.0 framework later on, such as Windows Workflow Foundation, CardSpaces etc.

Microsoft Max was never a part if Vista. It was a .NET 3.0 demonstration project.

Monad was never a part of Vista either.
#15.1 HawkMan on 02 Nov 2006 - 14:23
Quote - Stebet said @ #15
What an utterly stupid and wrong "news" item.

There is only one "framework/technology" that has been killed off from Vista: WinFS

All the rest are still there, including the new audio stack, new networking stack, Windows Communication Foundation (Indigo, part of .NET 3.0), Windows Presentation Foundation (Avalon, part of .NET 3.0), DWM (Deskptop Composition) and tons tons tons more. A lot of new stuff was even added to the .NET 3.0 framework later on, such as Windows Workflow Foundation, CardSpaces etc.

Microsoft Max was never a part if Vista. It was a .NET 3.0 demonstration project.

Monad was never a part of Vista either.


And even WinFS wasn't truly removed form Vista.

WinFS "the project" was killed. but 2 of the 3 major parts of winfs exist in vista, after WinFS was split
#15.2 GAM on 02 Nov 2006 - 15:04
Quote - HawkMan said @ #15.1
And even WinFS wasn't truly removed form Vista.

WinFS "the project" was killed. but 2 of the 3 major parts of winfs exist in vista, after WinFS was split



B.S.
WinFS is NOT in Vista. Period.
#15.3 HawkMan on 02 Nov 2006 - 15:10
ANd you don't even know what WinFS is.


WinFS was split in 3 main parts.

Of wich the search in vista is one of them, and the smart/virtual fodlers is another. both of them shared full codebase with WinFS.
#15.4 Stunna on 02 Nov 2006 - 20:39
Quote - HawkMan said @ #15.3
ANd you don't even know what WinFS is.


WinFS was split in 3 main parts.

Of wich the search in vista is one of them, and the smart/virtual fodlers is another. both of them shared full codebase with WinFS.

isnt it suppose to be implemented in the next versions of sql?
(1 reply) #16 webeagle12 on 02 Nov 2006 - 15:04
can microsoft give me at least one excuse to buy vista?

redesigned desktop is not one of them, jack up prices for useless reasons
#16.1 5HORiZONS on 02 Nov 2006 - 16:08
Vista comes in a sweet box, what more reason do you need?
(3 replies) #17 zomber38 on 02 Nov 2006 - 15:45
Basically, I don't see any reason to upgrade to vista. Perhaps only for DX10. What has MS implemented in Vista that cannot be added as an add-on to Windows XP?

And I have tried all builds up to 5744, and till now, no stable drivers for my ATI IGP340, blue screen everytime I shut down. CPU usage always 70%, Too many processes running.....

I think Microsoft has start to wake up and see what they are doing....maybe stop wasting $$ on money losing projects like Zune and XBOX and get back to its core business. Building OSes.
#17.1 Kushan on 03 Nov 2006 - 06:17
The Zune hasn't been released yet, you can't say it's a "loosing project". And last I checked, the Xbox was a pretty big success, with the 360 poised to do even better. However, you can't comment on that either until the Wii and the PS3 have been out for a while.
And as for the drivers for your ATI chipset, guess what, that's ATI's fault, not Microsoft's. It's not up to MS to ensure that all your hardware works fine under a completely new driver model, it's up to the manufacturer.
#17.2 zomber38 on 03 Nov 2006 - 06:29
Quote - Kushan said @ #17.1
The Zune hasn't been released yet, you can't say it's a "loosing project". And last I checked, the Xbox was a pretty big success, with the 360 poised to do even better. However, you can't comment on that either until the Wii and the PS3 have been out for a while.
And as for the drivers for your ATI chipset, guess what, that's ATI's fault, not Microsoft's. It's not up to MS to ensure that all your hardware works fine under a completely new driver model, it's up to the manufacturer.


Actually, its Microsoft's responsibility to ensure that Vista supports the currently available hardware out-there.
I'm not saying hardware that is more 3 yrs old, I mean those that are in the market for 1-2 yrs.
It is only in the best interest of MS. Otherwise, who would want to upgrade to Vista?
Do you honestly think the Zune will out-sell the ipod?
Till now, XBox has not made any $$ for MS. Go figure.

Last edited by zomber38 on 03 Nov 2006 - 06:35
#17.3 badazzEVO8 on 03 Nov 2006 - 18:17
Quote - zomber38 said @ #17
maybe stop wasting $$ on money losing projects like Zune and XBOX and get back to its core business. Building OSes.


hmm sony fanboy perhaps? lol

actually i think they'd do better focusing on games and xbox
(1 reply) #18 Dr.Jones on 02 Nov 2006 - 15:49
Stupid article, claiming Max was a technology. Max was a DEMO project of all the technologies CURRENTLY in Vista. Max's existence was in fact, proof that a lot of technologies are still in Vista, proving most of what the author said to be crap.

Morons always pick on the 5 features that were cut out, why can't they embrace the hundreds that are still there ?
#18.1 gadean on 02 Nov 2006 - 18:06
Quote - Dr.Jones said @ #18
Stupid article, claiming Max was a technology. Max was a DEMO project of all the technologies CURRENTLY in Vista. Max's existence was in fact, proof that a lot of technologies are still in Vista, proving most of what the author said to be crap.

Morons always pick on the 5 features that were cut out, why can't they embrace the hundreds that are still there ?


Well said!
#19 PureLegend on 02 Nov 2006 - 16:20
Max was **** anyway. Good riddance!
#20 cchance on 02 Nov 2006 - 16:52
This was stupid... very stupid

Max was not a pillar of vista, in fact from what i recall it didnt work on vista... what idiot wrote this????

It was a tech preview to help microsoft demo and test different technologies for later use in other programs... as the blog dictates the time for playing is over and now that they have worked it out it will be inocrporated into other products....

And winfs indeed still exists 2 of the 3 main aspects of it were put into vista... projects die and their assets get devided into different groups and programs thts what winfs was and thats what max was ... stop posting crap
#21 vetneufuse on 02 Nov 2006 - 18:04
umm max wasnt part of longhorn ever... it was a lab project to see what they could do with WinFX
#22 Ferret on 02 Nov 2006 - 19:29
This is starting to sound like a cut-down version of XP - But i'll wait til it's released.
(1 reply) #23 yanowhiz on 02 Nov 2006 - 20:47
I agree with #22. Microsoft is making more and more mistakes by dropping features. First it was WinFS, and now it is Microsoft Max... next thing you know they will remove the task bar and say "ha! good luck at opening anything! :-P"
#23.1 XerXis on 02 Nov 2006 - 21:16
Quote - yanowhiz said @ #23
I agree with #22. Microsoft is making more and more mistakes by dropping features. First it was WinFS, and now it is Microsoft Max... next thing you know they will remove the task bar and say "ha! good luck at opening anything! :-P"


and you should read more comments besides the ignorant #22
(1 reply) #24 fergiej on 02 Nov 2006 - 22:52
Reading IS fundemental, people...Stop allowing yourself to just be spoonfed what you want to hear. ooooh, Max is gone, whoa is me, Vista sure is becoming barebones. MS are idiots. Whatever. Read the more intelligent posts above for once in your lives. Research what you don't know. Neowin is certainly NOT helping the situation by posting this kind of cr@p. I've been coming here for a long time, but it's just degenerating into articles like this one and FUD from the Register. And those of you who feel it neccessary to Hate M$ (sic) just fall right in line. I'm outta here.
#24.1 mrmckeb on 03 Nov 2006 - 00:47
Quote - fergiej said @ #24
...Neowin is certainly NOT helping the situation by posting this kind of cr@p...

They are helping their status as number one Mac fanboy site! But I think of Neowin as the Al-Jazeera of the computing world.
#25 randomevent on 03 Nov 2006 - 01:06
Monad eh....why not just call it PowerShell like it already is. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_PowerShell
#26 danj205 on 03 Nov 2006 - 03:26
Yes, this article is stupid, and where it came from is also full of idiots as well. One even claimed that "Orcas" was being split from Vista (but, Orcas is the code name for the next version of Visual Studio).

Neowin could've just said "Microsoft Max has announced it is finishing development of the demo app." But no, they had to link to some idiot dramaqueen instead, even quoting some of what this guy said.

*sigh*

Edit: Speaking of which - why doesn't Neowin ever retract articles?

Commenting has either been disabled on this article or you are not logged in. Click here to login or register, its free!

Note: Anonymous commenting is disabled in order to keep the quality of responses to a high standard.

Advertisement (Why?)