This started out as part of my Galaxy Nexus review, but there was simply so much to talk about I split it into a second review. Check out the Galaxy Nexus hardware review for comments on the first Android 4.0 hardware experience.
When you come to talking about a major revision to the most popular smartphone operating system, it's hard to find a place to start because there is simply so much to cover. Android 4.0 “Ice Cream Sandwich” is perhaps the second largest step Android has taken in terms of major revisions, the largest of course being Android 2.0 back in 2009 which brought a wealth of new features.

Ice Cream Sandwich (or ICS) has included a huge amount of things to Android, from a new design and unified stylings to new functionality and features. Google has followed in the footsteps of Android 3.0 “Honeycomb” for tablets by shifting to blue as the primary color, as opposed to green in Android 2.3 “Gingerbread”. The blue design glows in a somewhat futuristic way, and interface elements are squarer and more angled than before.
Throughout all stock applications on ICS is seems like they have gone for several major styles, most of which differ to previous versions:
- Sharp angles and lines are commonplace. In the app drawer, around the search bar, under the text entry bay and even in the onscreen buttons, smooth curves or gradients have been replaced with single-color lines and sharp corners.
- The Roboto font is modern and clean. Thanks to the 720p display on the Nexus, it appears very sharp and it's very easy to read. The sans-serif and simple design makes it feel at home in a 2011/2012 world.
- Black, grey and blue are the colors used, along with transparency. The notification pane uses blue/grey icons on a black background, sliding it down reveals a semi-transparent background with blue highlights. In apps, buttons are grey on semi-transparent black with blue highlights.
For the first time in my history of using Android (and I've used it since the Google G1), a unification has been achieved. It is absolutely essential these days in a mobile operating system that moving between included applications feels like you are still “in” the OS, and never before has Google achieved this.
With Gingerbread Google may have updated the Calendar to a new style, but left Gmail with the same style from original Android. It was an awful mess of old and new, but going through ICS feels like everything is in place. I always see the same button styles, the same layouts, the same designs and the same colors used in every single included application, and it actually makes me smile at an Android design for once.

Now this may be somewhat controversial, but I really believe that the push to the ICS style was due to the threat of Windows Phone. Using Windows Phone's style is simply outstanding because every single application uses the Metro design language, so browsing from Messaging to the Browser feels like you haven't left Microsoft's world. Fonts are crisp and clean, designs are angled and minimalistic and there is a focus on text over imagery.
Of course not everything in Metro has influenced Android, in fact many, many things are quite different, but it seems more obvious than ever before how influential Microsoft have been in the mobile space. In all honesty, I don't care that Google borrowed some aspects of Windows Phone, such as the angular design, minimalist icons and swiping panes, because in the tech industry this happens all the time.
The point is Ice Cream Sandwich feels like the first Android revision that actually has a style. A proper, unified and beautiful style that feels modern, clean and even futuristic. I love it, almost to the point where it pushes out Windows Phone from my mobile OS design preference. Almost, but not quite; I guess this sets itself up well for another article…
Enough about the design and style, it's time to talk about some layout changes on the next page.
Contents
- The style of Ice Cream Sandwich
- Hardware buttons and app layout
- Launcher, lockscreen, notifications and settings
- Contacts, Dialer, Messaging and Browser
- Media apps: Camera, Gallery, Movie Studio, Music
- Google apps: Gmail, Calendar, YouTube, Maps, Google+, Market
- Other ICS features
- Conclusion

Comments (104)
ReplyGlad they took some of the best elements of webOS, wp7 and ..ios? to make android more accessible. Only version worth consideration since version 1.
Well with Matias Duarte behind the scene, it was bound to copy WebOS. iOS only copied the folders. What did it copy from WP7?
Every company borrows ideas from each other. But in this case I agree with UndergroundWire, In that I see no similarity with WP7 whatsoever. I doubt Google even knows WP exists considering its market share lol. However, WP7 has borrowed many ideas from Android.
Of course the real test is sales. Windows Phone has what < 1% marketshare, and Android has around 50%. Yeah I think we know which the consumer prefers.
Every company borrows ideas from each other. But in this case I agree with UndergroundWire, In that I see no similarity with WP7 whatsoever. I doubt Google even knows WP exists considering its market share lol. However, WP7 has borrowed many ideas from Android.
Of course the real test is sales. Windows Phone has what < 1% marketshare, and Android has around 50%. Yeah I think we know which the consumer prefers.
LOL. Weak argument for it being similar to WP7.
Things of interest I'm looking at is in the notification you can swipe to dismiss. That's from WebOS. Putting icons on top of each other create a folder that's iOS.
No one seems to answer my question though.
LOL. Weak argument for it being similar to WP7.
Things of interest I'm looking at is in the notification you can swipe to dismiss. That's from WebOS. Putting icons on top of each other create a folder that's iOS.
No one seems to answer my question though.
People style hub and icons, font, overall look. The list goes deeper. I watched the presentation video when they first showed it off and aside from the folder thing it was all almost entirely WP7. No, I didn't write down the whole list.
LOL. Weak argument for it being similar to WP7.
Things of interest I'm looking at is in the notification you can swipe to dismiss. That's from WebOS. Putting icons on top of each other create a folder that's iOS.
No one seems to answer my question though.
Here's a list: http://www.techdreams.org/mobi...ream-sandwich/6504-20111019
Here's a list: http://www.techdreams.org/mobi...ream-sandwich/6504-20111019
Dream on. WP doesn't even register on anyone's list. It has < 1% market share. WP7 is one big copy of Android and iOS features.
People style hub and icons, font, overall look. The list goes deeper. I watched the presentation video when they first showed it off and aside from the folder thing it was all almost entirely WP7. No, I didn't write down the whole list.
Icons look the same to me. The font was done by Google themselves. Microsoft didn't invent the font you know.
Dream on. WP doesn't even register on anyone's list. It has < 1% market share. WP7 is one big copy of Android and iOS features.
1) Swiping between menus is WebOS NOT METRO. That is the influence of Matias Duarte working at Google now.
2) Action Bar looks more like WebOS. Again, that is the influence of Matias Duarte working at Google now.
Only thing on that list that is almost legitimate is the People App (#4). However it seems like this stupid list wants a higher count so they also add it on #5 (Contacts).
Trust me when I tell you this, WP is not registering on Google's Radar. IF. And that is a BIG IF, Windows Phone can manage to get double digit market share (I know it is a lot to ask at the moment), they will be under Gogole's Radar.
Perhaps, you should ask: Why did Google hire Matias Duarte?, Did Microsoft also copy stuff from WebOS and I'm thinking Microsoft invented all along with Windows Phone?
The ideas used from WP7 are most liekly the implementation of a more "metro" styled interface with a sharp , clean and lite feel. My first experiance with WP was "wholly ****, this is gorgeous" Android had puled this off nicely
Well with Matias Duarte behind the scene, it was bound to copy WebOS. iOS only copied the folders. What did it copy from WP7?
People hub is very similar, all I can think of atm. And I am not trying to be negative about using competitor's ideas, it was essential Android get them.
People hub is very similar, all I can think of atm. And I am not trying to be negative about using competitor's ideas, it was essential Android get them.
Neither am I. iOS copied the notification system from Android and all I said was, "It's about time!"
Dream on. WP doesn't even register on anyone's list. It has < 1% market share. WP7 is one big copy of Android and iOS features.
Refresh my memory, how many phones did Android have at the time to get that 2% market share.
Refresh my memory, how many phones did Android have at the time to get that 2% market share.
LMGTFY... nevermind, you ought to do it yourself.
Refresh my memory, how many phones did Android have at the time to get that 2% market share.
8 phones. This was just prior to Android 2.0 coming out and Motorola's very large and successful Droid campaign. Most people I know still call all android phones "Droid", no matter what their phone is called.
8 phones. This was just prior to Android 2.0 coming out and Motorola's very large and successful Droid campaign. Most people I know still call all android phones "Droid", no matter what their phone is called.
Interesting! And how many Windows Phone in the market today to get it to its 2% market share?
LMGTFY... nevermind, you ought to do it yourself.
http://cloud.addictivetips.com.../android-phone-timeline.jpg
Dream on. WP doesn't even register on anyone's list. It has < 1% market share. WP7 is one big copy of Android and iOS features.
You're posts are just laughable. You discredit a post because of Windows Phone's market share, rather than follow a link (Big surprise, this seems to be a recurring theme) to see what was copied from Windows Phone? I wasn't going to post, because I don't troll topics like you do, but Ice Cream Sandwich copied a lot from Windows Phone (As well as iOS). That's not to say it isn't a nice OS, I like the look of the screenshots, I'm just not personally a fan of it's architecture. But see, even when I go into a topic like this, I don't troll. I guess that's the difference between us.
Here's a list: http://www.techdreams.org/mobi...ream-sandwich/6504-20111019
Lock screen to camera has been in widget locker on android for more than two years..it's not an iOS feature.
Lock screen to camera has been in widget locker on android for more than two years..it's not an iOS feature.
Correction...It's an iOS feature not an iOS idea
Whatever you are using to load pages is not working, I get that loading indicator of white square boxes in the top right of chrome and firefox, and it never stops loading. I only can access the first page. SUPER ANNOYING
Yep - getting the same issue!
NOTE: Pagination is currently broken, a fix is on the way REAL soon. Sorry about the inconvenience, it was working before...
Why not post it all as 1 page for now?
Why not post it all as 1 page for now?
Yep, I'll do that. EDIT: Turns out I can't... the multipage editor is broken as well :@
Pagination is now fixed. Enjoy the review
I cant wait to get ice cream on my Arc. Very nice review and I agree with you I hope they leave it stock as much as possible. Except for the black background
Awesome review, and now cannot wait to get it on my GS2
Do we just have to wait for the update or do we have to install it ourselves?
Do we just have to wait for the update or do we have to install it ourselves?
Its up to you!!!! If you need official Update from Samsung wait for it until it comes to you but if you need custom ROM go to Cyanogenmod (still in Alpha stage though)and install it yourself.
Its up to you!!!! If you need official Update from Samsung wait for it until it comes to you but if you need custom ROM go to Cyanogenmod (still in Alpha stage though)and install it yourself.
No idea what I'm doing with custom ROM's or any of that, any idea when the official update will be out? This year?
Well, its the best designed android so far (that was not so hard considering the disgusting base ui it had before ics), its nice to see that Google tries to develop some character for the OS not just stealing design elements from iOS and WP.
A few more versions and maybe they can make something that might be called a "consistent design language", not just a visual cacophony.
Nice review.
Seems well balanced, informative and full of pictures.
Slowly rebuilding my faith in Neowin's journalism
you need the following button "show all pages" as changing through 8 pages is a pain.
I hope I get it for my G2X D:
ICS looks great. I might consider getting an android as my next phone next year.
Great review, thanks! This has pretty much convinced me to stay with Android next year. Was thinking of switching to WP7, because I like the clean design. But now I see what Google has done with their UI, and I like it.
Anyone know if the Music app supports Genre view yet? It's been missing like forever...
Yes. The final tab to the right in the ICS music app shows all your music Genres
Genre has been in the app for a while. It wasn't in the first release but a few months later it came out.
In the time-lapse video, wheres the Ice Cream??
I can't wait for the Galaxy Nexus on Verizon.
I don't see this futuristic look last more than one major version.
Yeah i can't wait!!
Great review! That sandwhich looked good ...
What a load of drivel. So every simple design these days is "Metro Inspired"? Give me a break. You do realise that Microsoft didn't invent the "Simple Design" principle right? It's been around forever!
Nothing but WP7 fanboy drivel as far as I'm concerned. ICS is so far ahead of Windows Phone in usability, design, functionality, and customisability that it's like Android comes from a different era. Windows Phone looks like we're back in the nineties.
On ICS itself, It looks beautiful to me. I'm actually looking at getting myself a Transformer Prime. That thing is the bomb. Pair it with ICS, and the iPad looks like a fisher price toy lol.
In terms of features, I'm looking forward to playing with Face-Unlock and Android NFC Beam.
What a load of drivel. So every simple design these days is "Metro Inspired"? Give me a break. You do realise that Microsoft didn't invent the "Simple Design" principle right? It's been around forever!
Nothing but WP7 fanboy drivel as far as I'm concerned. ICS is so far ahead of Windows Phone in usability, design, functionality, and customisability that it's like Android comes from a different era. Windows Phone looks like we're back in the nineties.
On ICS itself, It looks beautiful to me. I'm actually looking at getting myself a Transformer Prime. That thing is the bomb. Pair it with ICS, and the iPad looks like a fisher price toy lol.
In terms of features, I'm looking forward to playing with Face-Unlock and Android NFC Beam.
What's better about Android usability, design and functionality?
What's better about Android usability, design and functionality?
Features
Nothing but WP7 fanboy drivel as far as I'm concerned. ICS is so far ahead of Windows Phone in usability, design, functionality, and customisability that it's like Android comes from a different era. Windows Phone looks like we're back in the nineties.
On ICS itself, It looks beautiful to me. I'm actually looking at getting myself a Transformer Prime. That thing is the bomb. Pair it with ICS, and the iPad looks like a fisher price toy.
Kind of ironic calling other people fanboys considering that fantastic post.
It came from Joey S. That's all there is to say. Move along....
I don't know why, but to me Android has always felt unfinished, unrefined, and clunky... even in version 3 it still felt that way, haven't seen 4 in person yet so not sure on that... but iOS always felt stable and polished, WP7 feels that way too, android though i duno... I loved the idea at first, but after playing with it for a while now just feels like another google wanted to beat someone project that gets cancelled somewhere down the road for something else....
I agree. You always need 3rd party software like HTC Sense to make it more complete
Agreed.
forget the older version of Android, try the 4.0 and give back your thought, I've been running ICS from CM in my SGS1, it so delicious I don't think I can go back to gingerbread
I can say the same about iOS and WP7. To me, they are very limited. You are confined to one boring design and lack of choice. I agree Android still has a lot of room to improve. But that's the beauty of it. It kept changing and getting better one version after another. Once I run ICS on my Nexus S, I don't even wanna go back to Gingerbread. And, I like the feelings of it.
But that depends on individual I guess. Some people are still fine running Window XP. It does the basic functions what an OS supposed to do.
And getting the 50% market share with it.
Does anyone know if Copy/Paste has been improved?
i hope so cut and paste is fiddley some times.
and i hope they done some thing about the block caller function. when i block a caller i dont want them to recive
an automated text/sms message saying that i cant answer the phone or to have them dirverted to my voice mail. the whole point is to block them.
It has, check page 7
It has, check page 7
Thank you!
Nice review, and I'm looking forward to getting an ICS device soon (hopefully Cyanogenmod will have ICS on the HP Touchpad quickly).
One thing however. You say about Android Beam being a new thing and not catchup. Sounds very much like one of the things that HP tried (and failed) with WebOS.
Wp7 sucks and google is not worried about it.
Try actually using a WP7 device. You'll be surprised, no, shocked, at how good it really is.
I actually sold my gingerbread based phone to get one. Only with ICS does google look like they are finally ready for prime time.
Try actually using a WP7 device. You'll be surprised, no, shocked, at how good it really is.
I actually sold my gingerbread based phone to get one. Only with ICS does google look like they are finally ready for prime time.
tbh, i have tried wp7 every time i go to Bestbuy but I dont feel that good about it... after clicking on few options i feel lost and have no idea where i was. i had to click the home to start over again.
tbh, i have tried wp7 every time i go to Bestbuy but I dont feel that good about it... after clicking on few options i feel lost and have no idea where i was. i had to click the home to start over again.
Yeah I know what you mean. Fluid animations, cool looking interface - etc. But I'm always lost as to what the hell is happening. Its infuriating.
The interface looks like a geek's pet project, instead of something you'd expect in a commercial product meant for the public. It's much like every Linux distro in existence in that aspect. Extremely clunky and busy in appearance.
Says the person who has never tried a Linux distro. Says the person who thinks everything is **** compared with the iphone. Says the person who feels threatened by the superior product.
wow..looks like you are more expert in software UI design than Matias Duarte.. can share your UI design philosophy?
Says the person who has never tried a Linux distro. Says the person who thinks everything is **** compared with the iphone. Says the person who feels threatened by the superior product.
I run Ubuntu on a secondary machine and within VMware Fusion. I never owned a single iPhone in my life. My current phone is an Android one and my next one will probably be WP7.
Could you fail any harder? Nope I don't believe you can! Do yourself a favor and don't post next time.
Sure, I like iOS and WebOS a whole lot more. Thinking that Matias Duarte got a free pass from Google, unlimited resources and time to design this interface is unrealistic. He still had to build upon what was already done, which IMO wasn't too great.
Sure, I like iOS and WebOS a whole lot more. Thinking that Matias Duarte got a free pass from Google, unlimited resources and time to design this interface is unrealistic. He still had to build upon what was already done, which IMO wasn't too great.
Oh. Nvm. Just your UI preference. I tought you are coming out with your own design philosophy. I also can say I like this ICS a lot more. It looks modern, sharp and refreshing suitable as current OS design. Besides WP7, others just looks like outdated.
Edit: nvm
Then why post at all, just to tell us you can't be bothered?
Oh. Nvm. Just your UI preference. I tought you are coming out with your own design philosophy. I also can say I like this ICS a lot more. It looks modern, sharp and refreshing suitable as current OS design. Besides WP7, others just looks like outdated.
What else would it be? When it comes to interface design it's all about personal preferences.
Nice review, very informative, but... /me clings to my tablet... I like my smooth curves and gradients.
snapshot is already there,being using it in my GS2
I hope HTC/Telus updates so I can get this on my Desire HD otherwise I'll have to wait for a good ROM...
wont be any official ICS for desire HD owners
sadly
ICS is awesome already using with custom AOSP in my Galaxs 9000B (ISDB tunner)
as an android opponent I look forward to trying ICS on a tablet as it may be the first version of the OS that actually feels like a finished product and can finally complete with WP7 and iOS.
Well after my awful experience with my Galaxy S Fascinate and Android 2.x, I was ready to jump ship to iPhone or Windows Phone at my next upgrade. But if ICS actually addressed some of the shortcomings (particularly stability and speed), and if OS updates will be released frequently and to all phones like Google promised, then I might stick with Android after all. I would after all hate to buy all my apps over again.
Just waiting for Sony to roll out the updates now then
Woah woah woah. So your telling me, that the following "
What's even better is that all the new features aren't “catch-up” features like we all saw with iOS 5. Google fixed the style issue (somewhat a catch-up), and then introduced a wealth of innovations that haven't been seen before: Android Beam, data usage, face unlock, on-screen buttons, native screenshots, zero shutter lag and more. Once you use these features for just a few days and see just how good they are, it's hard to go back and be without them.
"
bolded item was innovated and NO one has done it before?
Native screenshot ability has been in iOS since iOS 2.0. So back up here, google DID NOT CREATE THAT, Apple was the first one to innovate native screenshots and I've loved that about my iPhone, this is WITHOUT jail breaking it. Up until now android had to be rooted to screen shot.
What's even better is that all the new features aren't “catch-up” features like we all saw with iOS 5. Google fixed the style issue (somewhat a catch-up), and then introduced a wealth of innovations that haven't been seen before: Android Beam, data usage, face unlock, on-screen buttons, native screenshots, zero shutter lag and more. Once you use these features for just a few days and see just how good they are, it's hard to go back and be without them.
"
bolded item was innovated and NO one has done it before?
Native screenshot ability has been in iOS since iOS 2.0. So back up here, google DID NOT CREATE THAT, Apple was the first one to innovate native screenshots and I've loved that about my iPhone, this is WITHOUT jail breaking it. Up until now android had to be rooted to screen shot.
proof: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Screenshot#iOS
What's even better is that all the new features aren't “catch-up” features like we all saw with iOS 5. Google fixed the style issue (somewhat a catch-up), and then introduced a wealth of innovations that haven't been seen before: Android Beam, data usage, face unlock, on-screen buttons, native screenshots, zero shutter lag and more. Once you use these features for just a few days and see just how good they are, it's hard to go back and be without them.
"
bolded item was innovated and NO one has done it before?
Native screenshot ability has been in iOS since iOS 2.0. So back up here, google DID NOT CREATE THAT, Apple was the first one to innovate native screenshots and I've loved that about my iPhone, this is WITHOUT jail breaking it. Up until now android had to be rooted to screen shot.
Sorry, that must have slipped my mind. I corrected it
Sorry, that must have slipped my mind. I corrected it
While this is true you did not have to root to get screen shots you did however have to use ADB which most users know nothing about( edit to clear this us yes in android you would need root for screen shots for native mode if you were away from a computer. but if you were at home with no root you could use adb and a few tricks that did not require root to get the same result.) Also Native screen shots are also in Samsung phones running android. I know the wifes Droid charge has it as well as my SSGS2 from Sprint and every other SGS2 I've used. I'm pretty sure the Original Galaxy had this also.
fix the battery life that can last more than 6 hours at a time and i might consider buying another one.
My SGS2 lasts all day long from a turn on at 6am to 9-10pm at night with more then enough power to keep going. 19+ hour battery life and I've seen 22+ and that's not just letting the phone sit there and do nothing it's got auto sync's going for 2 gmail accounts, G+, Google Music, and many more things in the background.
i still think ice cream overall looks very unpolished, i don't like the new icons or the UI but hopefully themes will fix this in time.
No. Joke this Sandwich Look Yummy i really can't wait to get the update for my HTC sensation 4G. Looking Forward for this Update , i feel sorry for IPhone Fan Boy lol, Apple phone always look the someway all the time.
took a couple elements from the metro design language
I like the data usage monitoring. I think it's great being able to set your own caps and have the OS actually do something when those caps are reached.
Every mobile OS should innovate upon that idea!
I hate reviews that require me to click Next next 8 times. Can you make it a single page next time?
I hate reviews that require me to scroll down
Yes imagine having to move your hand a bit around...
Zero shutter lag is not something that Google has made new. To give credit where it is due HTC has had this one their Android phones Since the Sensation (I believe) with the introduction of Sense 3.0. Also Android Beam is really nothing really new either it's just the same idea as Bump (for both iOS and Android) which has been in both markets for some time now. Yes Beam does go further then what bumb was intended to do but the tech has been there for free for a long time now.
Zero shutter lag is not in the Sensation. I would have noticed when I reviewed it. Bump is not even close to being the same technology as NFC-based Beam. Beam is integrated throughout all apps and the OS itself
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LChoaaLBTDQ
was watching a video and the phone LAAAAAAAAAAAGGGGGGGSSSSSSSS!!!
By definition this OS LAGS but this is just extreme. If one core at 1GHz is not enough... Its a DAMN phone!.
Wait you are saying that it runs crappy on a HD2 (Windows Phone device) with a ported unfinished build of ICS without driver optimizations aka hacked together? Seriously?
I really don't like the default theme. That's one of the reasons my past two Android phones have been from HTC, as their Sense theme is really attractive. HTC is due to release the ICS update for the Sensation early next year, though T-Mobile UK were very slow to roll out the previous update. I guess I have a little while to wait.
I love how they refined the UI. Compared to previous versions of Android, ICS looks much more consistent. I also like the new font. It looks great on the high resolution screen of the Samsung Galaxy Nexus. Anyway, awesome review. I look forward to trying out ICS on my sister's Nexus S.
I want this on my gs2 now!