Debian drops Xfce, reinstates GNOME as default desktop

Back in August, we reported that Debian was switching to Xfce as its default desktop environment. GNOME had become to big too fit on a CD for the next release called Debian Wheezy, according to a developer of the Linux distribution. It's more plausible that the declining popularity of the GNOME desktop environment was the real reason behind the developers' move.

But now, the developers have chosen to revert that decision, making GNOME the default environment once again. This time, however, no reason was given. The commit placed by Christian Perrier simply states, "Again revert xfce default."

One reason could be that Xfce still relies on the older GTK+ 2 toolkit and the next version won't be based on GTK+ 3 either. Or it's just as simple as the developers beginning to like GNOME Shell, the new highly polished interface introduced with GNOME 3 that took a radical departure from the previous interface. In a recent Q&A chat with students from the Aalto University in Finland, even Linus Torvalds himself has returned to GNOME 3:

“I have to say, things are so much better now that were one year ago, I am actually back to using Gnome 3″

Xfce is lighter than GNOME though, and that difference will likely become bigger. With the upcoming GNOME 3.8, there's no GNOME 2-like fallback mode anymore. Instead, users will be forced to use GNOME Shell, even if the GPU (or driver) can't handle it. In that case the interface will be software rendered with LLVMpipe. Ubuntu recently moved to LLVMpipe with Ubuntu 12.10, which hasn't been a popular decision for owners of low-end systems incapable of running the 3D accelerated Unity interface.

Xfce remains available for those who would rather use it.

Source: Phoronix, woGue | Image via woGue

Report a problem with article
Previous Story

Walmart selling $49.99 Lumia 920 and free Lumia 820

Next Story

HTC and Apple settle patent dispute; sign 10 year license agreement

15 Comments

Commenting is disabled on this article.

Why not have a dialogue box pop up and ask you what you want for a default - and then download what you need - right from the installer? Are we still in the era of dial-up, where every bit of space on a disc is essential?

bjoswald said,
Are we still in the era of dial-up, where every bit of space on a disc is essential?

In this case of it still fitting on a CD or being relegated to DVD, yes, yes every bit of space is apparently essential. Just like Ubuntu no longer fitting on a damn CD. Lots of older systems can't boot off USB and only have CD readers.

just installed the lastest ubtuntu and then loaded up gnome, im not a fan of the black bar on the top, but over all gnome3 isnt too bad, Will look at LXDE when i get home today.

MsftGaurav said,
Oh it should adopt LXDE as default and improve it. LXDE is the BEST and extremely fast.

The word "Best" is subjective and should be replaced with " Very good".

MsftGaurav said,
Oh it should adopt LXDE as default and improve it. LXDE is the BEST and extremely fast.
Improving it most likely means it will become bloated and slow.

MsftGaurav said,
Oh it should adopt LXDE as default and improve it. LXDE is the BEST and extremely fast.

It feels way too "barebones" to me.

I think that XFCE is the golden mean between the minimalist and do-it-all DEs.

Well,
The headline is misleading! Debian is not dropping XFCE; the commit clearly states: "Choices: gnome, kde, xfce, lxde". It is only that they set Gnome as default, XFCE is still available and most Linux users would know how to switch.

Tumultus said,
Well,
The headline is misleading! Debian is not dropping XFCE; the commit clearly states: "Choices: gnome, kde, xfce, lxde". It is only that they set Gnome as default, XFCE is still available and most Linux users would know how to switch.

Seriously. Anyone that uses Debian knows how to set it up.