Google: Increase in government censorship requests is "troubling"

In May, Google announced that it was adding a new page on its Transparency Report site called Copyright Removal Requests. The page showed which companies were asking Google to remove search results for certain websites. As we reported, Microsoft had the most requests to remove websites from Google's search engine, mostly due to alleged piracy content violations.

However, Google has been seeing an increase in requests from another source: governments. In a new blog post on its Public Policy page, Google said that many times, governments have asked Google to remove websites from their results that may have different political views.

Google calls this rise in these kinds of requests "troubling" and added, "It’s alarming not only because free expression is at risk, but because some of these requests come from countries you might not suspect—Western democracies not typically associated with censorship."

Google gave a couple of examples of these kinds of requests. One of them involved Spanish regulators who asked Google to remove search results "referencing individuals and public figures, including mayors and public prosecutors." A public organization based in Poland also asked Google to remove links to a website that was critical of their group. Google said it declined both of these requests.

Governments also ask Google to remove sites from its search results due to court orders. The blog states, "For the six months of data we’re releasing today, we complied with an average of 65 (percent) of court orders, as opposed to 47 (percent) of more informal requests."

Source: Google Public Policy blog

Report a problem with article
Previous Story

Former AT&T exec leaked iPhone, RIM info to investors

Next Story

What we know (and don't know) about Microsoft's Surface

5 Comments

I'd only be worried if they were all court orders..

I don't care if the Canadian Gov't asks google to take down whitehouse.gov, as long as it's not a court order, and as such has no force of law in Canada, and can be ignored by Google..

Requesting is fine, I best most requests that are made, are made by individuals in the government who don't know better, or figure it's worth a shot.. but that the requests never go through a vetting process like trying to get a court order would..

Of course that may not hold true for all gov'ts..

Ryoken said,
I'd only be worried if they were all court orders..

I don't care if the Canadian Gov't asks google to take down whitehouse.gov, as long as it's not a court order, and as such has no force of law in Canada, and can be ignored by Google..

Requesting is fine, I best most requests that are made, are made by individuals in the government who don't know better, or figure it's worth a shot.. but that the requests never go through a vetting process like trying to get a court order would..

Of course that may not hold true for all gov'ts..

Unfortunately too many people in the world hold your 'idc' view. fyi its a bad attitude to have.

Ryoken said,
I'd only be worried if they were all court orders..

I don't care if the Canadian Gov't asks google to take down whitehouse.gov, as long as it's not a court order, and as such has no force of law in Canada, and can be ignored by Google..

Requesting is fine, I best most requests that are made, are made by individuals in the government who don't know better, or figure it's worth a shot.. but that the requests never go through a vetting process like trying to get a court order would..

Of course that may not hold true for all gov'ts..


Democratic representatives who share this mindset of "let's try, I can't force, but I want to try essentially shutting someone up" sounds scary as hell to me.

IMHO, Google shoul publish names so I know who not to vote for or write to and express my (understatement incoming) anger.

GS:ios

Glassed Silver said,

Democratic representatives who share this mindset of "let's try, I can't force, but I want to try essentially shutting someone up" sounds scary as hell to me.

IMHO, Google shoul publish names so I know who not to vote for or write to and express my (understatement incoming) anger.

GS:ios

I doubt they got any letters from anyone elected.. they got them from middle management cronies who figured they would try something themselves. So no, their actions don't scare me.

Show me a letter from Harper to Google asking for stuff to get removed, I'll get a little more worried.. but not mot, not till I see them sending out court orders, that means the Canadian Judaical system has approved it, THEN I'll be concerned. Till then it's all little more than talk.

Commenting is disabled on this article.