main

Microsoft keeps Windows rights, for now

Michael Stanclift   on 28 January 2003 - 06:02 · 12 comments & 245 views

Advertisement (Why?)
Microsoft will be able to keep its hold on the trademark rights for its Windows software for the next several months, but those rights appear to be in some jeopardy in a federal court case in Seattle.

In a ruling last week that was made public over the weekend, US District Judge John C. Coughenor of Seattle turned down a formal request by a Microsoft rival, Lindows.com Inc., to wipe out the trademark on Windows, which Microsoft has had for nearly eight years. It has become one of the world's best-known trademarks, and Microsoft regards it as highly valuable, having spent more than $1.2 billion to promote that identity.

The fate of the trademark, the judge ruled, must be decided by a jury at a trial scheduled to start April 7. The judge said he could not rule on that issue before a trial, as Lindows.com had asked, since there are factual disputes between Microsoft and Lindows that only a jury can resolve.

Microsoft has contended that San Diego-based Lindows.com is violating the Windows trademark by using the similar name "Lindows" for a competing operating system based on the Linux open-source software.

Lindows.com has argued that Microsoft's trademark is invalid, because the word "windows" has been used as a generic term for the overlapping windows, or graphic boxes, that are displayed on a computer desktop, leading the user into various applications. Under federal trademark law, a generic term cannot be trademarked.

News source: digitalMass


How to Obtain Exchange 2003 Beta 2, Microsoft Windows® Server 2003 Release Candidate 2 (RC2) and Microsoft Office 11 Beta 1
Choose between the following two methods to try the beta:
    Order the Exchange 2003 Beta 2 CD Evaluation Kit
    To achieve the best possible evaluation experience, you should deploy Exchange 2003 Beta 2 in a test environment with Microsoft Windows® Server 2003 Release Candidate 2 (RC2) and Microsoft Office 11 Beta 1. You can register to order the Exchange 2003 Beta 2 Kit on CD, which includes Exchange 2003 Beta 2, Windows Server 2003 RC2, Office 11 Beta 1, and a resource CD. The kit is offered at no additional charge, but shipping, handling, and any applicable taxes apply.

    Download Exchange 2003 Beta 2 ONLY
    To get started today testing the new features and improvements


Post a comment · Send to friend Comments · There are 12 additional comments
#1 vetmalebolgia on 28 Jan 2003 - 06:09
Evil Lindows
#2 MethosKel on 28 Jan 2003 - 06:25
Lindows needs to fade away
(1 reply) #3 modem on 28 Jan 2003 - 06:39
I don't get it, it's an OS and the majority of articles/comments on Neowin are hateful and lindows bashing based comments. If people don't like it, simply don't look at it, don't read articles about it and don't use it. Simple as that.
#3.1 JaggedFlame on 28 Jan 2003 - 16:47
It's a piece of plastic with magnetic switches on it. And look at these people expressing feelings of hatred towards it. Pathetic. It's like going to the park and swearing to beat the crap out of a pebble.
#4 CarbonKnight on 28 Jan 2003 - 07:07
Hmmm I hope Microsoft doesn't mind my new Window Sil XB Operating System (TM), to be release by my upstart MacroHard.

Last edited by 21395 on 28 Jan 2003 - 07:21
(2 replies) #5 azn_ricer on 28 Jan 2003 - 07:09
Right....but windows is called windows because it was the first operation system designed to have these so called "windows" displayed on the screen. THEN, windows became a general term to describe a box on the computers screen or whatever you want to call it. I hate micro$hit but its their trademark from the beginning, and they should be able to keep their [B][U]PRODUCT NAME[/U][/B]
#5.1 theh0g on 28 Jan 2003 - 08:13
Er sorry dude yer wrong. Apple released graphic OS with windows and all when Microsoft was still into DOS (remember the "Windows 95 = Macintosh 1987"?). But yeah, they should keep their name, even though the word "windows" is too commonly used so they'll lose their right sooner or later.
#5.2 frazell on 28 Jan 2003 - 17:59
MS's "Windows" OS came 1 year after Mac's OS, there was Windows 1.0
#6 vetmalebolgia on 28 Jan 2003 - 07:45
Probably knowing their luck Lindows will win over Microsofts own product name.
#7 aleks on 28 Jan 2003 - 08:04
You guys find Lindows evil but yet laugh at Sony for losing their battle over the "Walkman" trademark.
#8 P5-133XL on 28 Jan 2003 - 12:06
I have always thought the concept that if a company is too successful with their trademark then they lose it is as ironic as life can be. However the fact is that once a trademark becomes so well known that it becomes a replacement for the generic concept then it is not longer defendable as propritary.
#9 Katzy on 28 Jan 2003 - 14:34
@ #5 - Windows wasn't the first OS to use a windowing system.

Commenting has either been disabled on this article or you are not logged in. Click here to login or register, its free!

Note: Anonymous commenting is disabled in order to keep the quality of responses to a high standard.

Advertisement (Why?)