main

Spam-bot tests flunk the blind

Mr. Black   on 02 July 2003 - 20:50 · 13 comments & 218 views

Advertisement (Why?)
An increasingly popular technique for preventing e-mail abuse is frustrating some visually impaired Net users, setting the stage for a conflict between spam busters and advocates for the disabled.

Many companies have recently begun requiring users to pass a verification test in order to access their services--typically by typing into a Web form a few characters that appear on the form in a guise that prevents a computer or software robot from recognizing and copying them. The technique, now used by Web giants Yahoo, Microsoft, VeriSign and others, seeks to block software bots from signing up for Web-based e-mail accounts that can be used to launch spam and from scraping e-mail addresses from online databases.

The scheme is winning high marks in the battle against unwanted junk e-mail. But it is also increasingly hindering the progress of Web surfers with visual disabilities--raising the ire of advocates for the blind, spurring plans for alternatives from a key Web standards group, and eliciting warnings from legal experts who say that the practice could expose companies to lawsuits brought under the Americans with Disabilities Act.

News source: news.com
View: View the full article


"Europe is under-exposed to the PC market and is therefore not benefitting to the same degree from the seasonal demand improvements," Woolf said. "If a higher exposure to the telecoms market has led Europe to underperform in May, then this increases the likelihood that STMicroelectronics could miss its second quarter revenue target."

Analysts polled by Thomson Financial expect STMicroelectronics to report revenue of $1.7 billion for the three months ended June 30. Some of the weakness in the European market could be offset in coming months by the region's strength in the automotive and industrial markets.

The entire chip market witnessed an unexpected upswing in May with the Semiconductor Industry Association reporting that its three-month moving average figures showed sales improved as the effects of SARS on the sector began to wane.

Actual May chip sales rose even more strongly as unit shipment surged at a double-digit rate. Worldwide sales increased to $12 billion, up 11% from $10.7 billion in the year-ago month. Sales increased from $41.2 billion in April.

"The revenue increased chiefly because of strong shipment of 12% month-over-month and 54% year-over-year," said Jay Kim, an analyst at Goodmorning Shinhan Securites, Tokyo, in a report. "Although the shipment growth of 54% year-over-year is lower than the previous months' 73% in March and 69% in April, strong pricing in recent weeks bodes well for the global DRAM outlook."

On a regional basis, sales in the Americas declined 7%, to $2.47 billion from $2.65 billion in May 2002, continuing a trend that has seen the region lose market share to Asia-Pacific, which grew 12%, to $4.65 billion from $4.16 billion. Japan recorded the strongest year-over-year sales increase in May, rising 26% to $2.93 billion from $2.33 billion in the year-ago month.

Post a comment · Send to friend Comments · There are 13 additional comments
(2 replies) #1 timbo3 on 02 Jul 2003 - 20:57
If I was blind, I wouldn't read email. I wouldn't surf the internet. A computer reading you text isn't cool and takes too much time. It's like a deaf person playing a trombone, or a guy with no legs climbing rocks. (i dont mean to offend people here, but this is a bit much) yeah, sure you can learn to to it, but you could use OCR software to read the numbers in the image.
#1.1 theh0g on 03 Jul 2003 - 08:06
Exactly.
It really must suck if yer disabled in any way, wish all people were healthy, but why does the whole world have to adjust now? There are other priorities first, we have to make websites work for the 99% of "normal" (non-disabled?) people first, no one is gonna do something for 1% of audiance first. Really disgusting to say, but it's not our fault and not our problem. I think everything is being adjusted to all kind of disabled people, which is great, every bigger town in the world has all sidewalks and stairs adjusted to disabled, but it'd be nice if they just once appreciated anyting, not just b*tch and threaten with a lawsuit for every dumb reason. But its probably just few of those always-angry people that are whining here, as most of disabled people I know are the sweetest people. But all this is typical american: if you don't like something, go to court.

Last edited by 11188 on 03 Jul 2003 - 08:14
#1.2 Jon on 03 Jul 2003 - 15:17
QUOTE
It's like a deaf person playing a trombone


Erm, some of the worlds most respected musicians are/were deaf....
(1 reply) #2 Mr. Black on 02 Jul 2003 - 21:06
Maybe the Screen Reader software should be updated w/ OCR capabilities instead of blaming the makers of the Website - they can't compromise for everyone and still have a decent + secure site, we have enough to deal with already (being a Webmaster myself).
#2.1 dotnetjunkie on 05 Jul 2003 - 03:51
NO! You're missing the whole point by making that comment! If the special characters were recognizable by OCR software, it wouldn't take the spammers long to create a bot which uses OCR functionality to persue their practices...
#3 Knight' on 02 Jul 2003 - 21:08
Big deal... blind people can't have Yahoo... it's not the end of the world.
#4 blind on 02 Jul 2003 - 21:19
In the uk it is a problem as the law states that websites must be accessible to the disabled. If they are not they might be at risk of having the website shut down. (Not sure on what punishments are axactly).

What do you think blind people do all day? Sit in a chair and listen to the radio all day?

The problem is that technology helps the Blind but the same technology might be used to create the accounts they are trying to prevent from being opened.
#5 Flip_Kid on 02 Jul 2003 - 21:35
why not have sound files as an alternative then?
(1 reply) #6 BuggyProgrammer on 02 Jul 2003 - 22:26
some DO have sound files, but most of them do not.
#6.1 quanta on 03 Jul 2003 - 02:14
Sound files are the way to go; say, offer the code phrase in image or audio form. How hard could it be? It should be fairly easy to implement. Many systems now use this type of bio-authentication, including PayPal.
#7 d1301 on 03 Jul 2003 - 00:55
Spam-bot tests flunk the blind
#8 dismuter on 03 Jul 2003 - 04:05
I think Neowin has forgotten a bit quickly SPAM's warning about not having its image associated with email spam. Besides, the joke's old
#9 Sickmyduck on 03 Jul 2003 - 06:07
QUOTE
In the uk it is a problem as the law states that websites must be accessible to the disabled. If they are not they might be at risk of having the website shut down. (Not sure on what punishments are axactly).


How do they enforce that? Not all website are in the UK or are they only talking about the .uk domain?

Commenting has either been disabled on this article or you are not logged in. Click here to login or register, its free!

Note: Anonymous commenting is disabled in order to keep the quality of responses to a high standard.

Advertisement (Why?)