main

Apple told to halt 'world's fastest' claims for G5

Unknown   on 26 March 2004 - 23:03 · 33 comments & 4765 views

Advertisement (Why?)
The Council of Better Business Bureaus has recommended that Apple Computer discontinue comparative performance claims regarding its Power Mac G5 desktop.

Acting on a tip from Apple rival Dell, the council's National Advertising Division (NAD) "determined that the evidence provided by Apple did not provide a reasonable basis for its broad unqualified claims that its Power Mac G5 is 'the world's fastest, most powerful personal computer' and that it 'edged out the competition on integer.'"

In a statement Thursday, NAD also said it took issue with Apple's claim regarding the computer's 64-bit processor. The "advertiser's claim, 'the world's first 64-bit processor for personal computers,' could reasonably be interpreted to apply to workstations, in the context in which it was presented." This claim was unsupported by evidence, according to NAD. The organization said that although the advertisement had run its course, it recommended that Apple "modify this claim to effectively limit it to personal computers."

That decision followed doubts by analysts and others about the benchmark tests Apple used to justify the claims.

View: The full story
News source: C|Net News


    Changelog
  • made MP4 AAC the new default ripping encoder
  • fixed a crash bug when playing some AVI files in in_dshow
  • added multimedia keyboard keys in global hotkeys default configuration
  • added "Manual playlist advance" in Repeat button popup menu in Classic mode
  • improvements in MP3 encoder configuration (added --alt-preset standard, etc...)
  • made the tabs in the preferences XP correctly themed under Windows XP
  • revamped the Media Library preferences a bit
  • new experimental WMA9 input plugin
  • gen_jumpex updates from DrO
  • added "Nuke library" action in Media Library
  • more upside down videos fixes
  • fixed crash if a plugin generated a pledit wm_windowposchanged on shutdown
  • fixed crash exploit in in_mod (thanks Peter Winter-Smith)
  • fixed various crashes in in_midi when playing invalid files
  • made in_midi store its settings in winamp.ini instead of the registry
  • fixed error during installation on computers with chinese/oriental regional settings
  • removed AOD from installer
  • added Shift-R to toggle manual playlist advance
  • updated VP6 video decoder to latest VP6.2 code
  • fixed crash when launching winamp with very long filenames from explorer
  • made registration dialog to appear in Explorer's taskbar when installing pro verion
  • fixed pledit/video windows showing up at startup when minimized
      modern skins updates:
    • winamp modern skin now uses a 3 state repeat button: no repeat/repeat all/repeat track
    • added appplication desktop toolbars capabilities for layouts, add
      appbar="left|top|right|bottom" to use them
    • upped maki binary version, improved stack protection
    • current skin version number is 1.2 (this should not change for a long while now, and of course we continue to support 0.8 to 1.1)
    • (very) limited maki debugger (for now you can bring it up with invokeDebugger(); in a script then use 'x' to continue and 'i' to trace into)
    • fixed obscure capture problem with dragging windows
    • fixed rectrgn being forced to 1 in xml xuiobject buttons that are originally imageless
    • fixed hilited state not on after clicking on buttons while the mouse stays in area
    • fixed scripted onEnterArea/onLeaveArea not being always correctly called while mouse button stays down
    • fixed getToken being passed NULL throwing guru
    • fixed clipping of painting within the background's region of a group rather than
      within the composed region (the one you can change with sysregion)
    • fixed image cache problem when using the same bitmap as a map and a button image parameter

Post a comment · Send to friend Comments · There are 33 additional comments
(2 replies) #1 BTallack on 26 Mar 2004 - 23:09
It says that they should modify it to be limited to personal computers, even though the claim specifically says "personal computers"
What the crap?
#1.1 norky on 26 Mar 2004 - 23:39
what they're saying is, word your ad so it can't be reasonably interpreted to include work stations.
#1.2 Himosan on 27 Mar 2004 - 02:49
So pray tell how can a reasonable person interpret 'the world's first 64-bit processor for personal computers,' as applying in any way to workstations?
(2 replies) #2 Chicane-UK on 26 Mar 2004 - 23:35
Confusing.

I know i'd sure as heck like one though.. dual 2GHz 64bit goodness in one of the sweetest cases? Yes please
#2.1 NeoSoft on 26 Mar 2004 - 23:39
Yeah, those towers that Apple has the G5’s in are so beautiful. Every time I go to Best Buy or an Apple story I start drooling!
#2.2 Mav Phoenix on 27 Mar 2004 - 03:22
Really? I find them to be horrid looking and the one 5 1/4 bay truly sucks ass.
(9 replies) #3 Dashel on 26 Mar 2004 - 23:38
A fair decision. Apple's marketing department has always left a bad taste in my mouth.
#3.1 NeoSoft on 26 Mar 2004 - 23:40
I can't argue that point, however, I feel that the iPod ads are just perfect! They are catchy and exciting!
#3.2 Starcom826 on 26 Mar 2004 - 23:50
Good thing you didn't see those ipod/itunes ads that said "fair to artists". Those were totally fake.
#3.3 Phillip on 27 Mar 2004 - 02:41
i rekon apple does great marketing its products... and everyone should just remember its just really well... marketing... and anyway, apple did get tones of free publicity saying the g5 is the worlds fastest... so it paid off
#3.4 TooPackShaker on 27 Mar 2004 - 05:04
QUOTE (#3.3)
it paid off

really? did they move up to 4% market share?
#3.5 Phillip on 27 Mar 2004 - 06:08
nup...but apple did get a lot of free publicity for it so imo it paid off
#3.6 gawdflesh on 27 Mar 2004 - 06:12
And that did what, exactly? So, a million or so people sitting at home eating dinner took a brief pause to say "Hey, that Apple ad that was just on TV...that was pretty interesting", then go about their lives, forgetting about the commercial, and never owning an Apple or wanting to.
#3.7 Phillip on 27 Mar 2004 - 08:15
so then whats a better way to make people turn their heads?
#3.8 pixlnet on 27 Mar 2004 - 20:31
<!--NeoquoteBegin--><center><table width=90% border=0 cellspacing=0 cellpadding=1><tr><td><font class=darkfont>QUOTE (#3.6)</font></td></tr><tr><td><table width=100% bgcolor=white border=0 cellspacing=0 cellpadding=3 style="border: 1px solid #90A0B0"><tr><td>And that did what, exactly? So, a million or so people sitting at home eating dinner took a brief pause to say "Hey, that Apple ad that was just on TV...that was pretty interesting", then go about their lives, forgetting about the commercial, and never owning an Apple or wanting to.
</td></tr></table></td></tr></table></center><!--NeoquoteEnd-->
No it's more like whoa that's a pretty nice computer. We should look into those. Moron
#3.9 gawdflesh on 27 Mar 2004 - 21:39
"moron"?

Getting people to pay attention is far far different from getting them to pay money for something, as a global 4% marketshare would show to anyone with more than two braincells to slam together. I will pay attention to a really horrible car crash too, and go "whoa, that's a pretty horrible car crash". Doesn't mean it's *good* attention. The goal of advertising is to sell products, moron, not to get people to go "whoa". When Apple's marketshare goes through the roof, then I'd say it's a success. Just because their commercials are enough to get a chimp like you to force his two-second attention span into a standstill for a moving picture on tv, I don't consider that a "success".

Btw, nice quote. Need a little help with that?
(1 reply) #4 kennyout on 26 Mar 2004 - 23:59
Hmmm maybe Dell is worried bout their market share...so they trying to keep anyone from taking it....
#4.1 bluarash on 27 Mar 2004 - 17:09
Ha, ha, ha! Wait your serious, Dell concerned about anything Apple does, maybe they should wait until they get above the 2% margin that they are at...
#5 PHiZZy on 27 Mar 2004 - 01:01
lol, dells just worried that some dumb corporate customers are gonna think that apple's a better choice

lmao
(2 replies) #6 Fonze on 27 Mar 2004 - 01:41
didn't know there was a group that tightened down on false advertising. False advertising, basically trying to fool the consumer, is one of my most hated things. They should do this more often, like when they quote someone about "BEST MOVIE EVER" and then at the bottom in size 3 font, it says 'says Bill the guy on the street corner'.

Apple definitely deserves this one.
#6.1 geetarbill on 27 Mar 2004 - 02:11
HEY NOW!!!! That was the best movie ever!!!
#6.2 Octol on 27 Mar 2004 - 06:25
How about:

BEST MOVIE EVER!



Says the film's producer.
(3 replies) #7 frod on 27 Mar 2004 - 02:58
so let's see, they're telling apple to make "the world's first 64-bit processor for personal computers" aim solely at personal computers... umm? okay...

i think the "fastest personal computer" removal is fine. apple is not even advertising it as that anymore as far as i know. they used that saying for about a month and then moved on.

i think people take those things too seriously. i don't see this group target car companies for having commercials that say "best car in its class" without having "in the year 2004 based on jd consumer's blah blah blah" in the commercial as well. i don't hear people complain about those ads either.

i remember when people were screaming at apple when they released itunes for windows as "the best windows app ever". talking about how "it's not true" and blah blah blah. get over it.
#7.1 Fonze on 27 Mar 2004 - 04:36
oh, i bitch about that too. Car commercials are the worst!
#7.2 Phillip on 27 Mar 2004 - 06:11
QUOTE (#7.0)
i think people take those things too seriously

agreed... people need to realize its only advertising and marketing and they need to get over it
#7.3 Octol on 27 Mar 2004 - 07:14
Yeah, it's "only advertising"—in the same sense that losing a few hundred acres of rainforest every day is "only a few trees".

Advertising—especially TV advertising and its subgenre, News—is an art that has taken brainwashing and psychological warfare to its highest levels. It tells the masses what to think and believe, and it works perfectly.

If you don't believe this, ask yourself why the smartest and richest and most successful people in the world continue to spend billions of dollars on advertising year after year after year. It's not because they like throwing away their money.

Whatever else you can say about advertising, it isn't "only" anything.
(1 reply) #8 keratosis on 27 Mar 2004 - 04:53
About time they had to stop those
#8.1 bogd on 27 Mar 2004 - 04:56
yeah, to bad Apple pulled the plug on those ads months ago huh?
(1 reply) #9 diabulos on 27 Mar 2004 - 06:43
If there is a false advertisement guardian, could they take a look at point 2 of this claim?:
http://www.apple.com/switch/whyswitch/

2-It doesn't crash
Are you just a tad too well acquainted with the notorious “blue screen of death?” Bid it a fond farewell. With Mac OS X, you’ll become accustomed instead to industry-leading stability. In this elegant new operating system, memory is fully protected and applications can’t conflict with the OS or one another. And, oh yes, Mac OS X is built on the industrial strength of UNIX. Most Fortune 500 companies, governments and universities rely on UNIX for their mission-critical applications. And now, so can you.


now, that is a lie in an y language, OSX crashes as badly as any other computer system, I can get designers, newspaper people from 10 of the best newspapers in the world and they will tell you horror stories about even the latest update of OSX, and they use it industrially.
#9.1 Simon- on 27 Mar 2004 - 12:12
and they are advertising UNIX, which just isn't the same as OSX.

That's like saying the my french fries are the best because I use someone else's best in the world salt
#10 rocks1985 on 27 Mar 2004 - 07:31
Why doesn't apple just start leasing its OS for 200 bucks
#11 Simon- on 27 Mar 2004 - 12:06
grrr but not even Apple refer to their own computers as "Personal Computers"... which they are, but not when it is ever confusable with x86, in which the x86 is called the PC.
#12 MindTrickz on 27 Mar 2004 - 21:22
Those people at Dell are Snitches.

Commenting has either been disabled on this article or you are not logged in. Click here to login or register, its free!

Note: Anonymous commenting is disabled in order to keep the quality of responses to a high standard.

Advertisement (Why?)