main

Bit Torrent : An Analysis

Mr magoo   on 19 December 2004 - 14:05 · 164 comments & 26589 views

Advertisement (Why?)
Hardy news site, The Register, recently published a detailed analysis of the file sharing protocol Bit Torrent. Bit Torrent has received attention in the main stream news after reports that it was carrying as much as 50% of all peer 2 peer (p2p) traffic, which in tern amounted to a massive 30% of all the traffic on the internet. The paper, by Dr. Johan Pouwelse, examines the protocol and looks especially at one of the largest bit-torrent hubs, Suprnova.org. He examines how just 20 moderators solve the problem of fake files, something that plagues the traditional file sharing networks like Kazaa.

Dr Powelse notes that the major problems facing hubs like suprnova are fakes and maintaining hub availability. The availability of files on bit torrent is based on a centralised system; without it, the network fails as users cannot access the trackers. Decentralising bit torrent has already begun - Suprnova have started a project called "Exeem" which apparently has 5,000 beta testers trialling it, and has an ultimate aim of taking the best of Kazaa (a decentralised network) and merging it with Bit Torrent. Decentralisation removes the issue of poor availability at the tracker end, yet0 it also provides more scope for fake files and a reduction in data integrity at the user end.

The paper concludes that bit-torrent needs to evolve to create incentives to users to seed files. Bit-torrent as a protocol is a system that’s here to stay; it enjoys more and more usage from more main stream content providers. Yes, there is a lot of illegitimate use of the protocol, but unlike Kazaa, these users should not be allowed to over shadow the usefulness to legitimate users of the bit torrent protocol.

[Update] Since this article was published, Suprnova has shutdown as a hub for torrents. Although this cannot be confirmed, the shutdown is very likely related to legal action from the Hollywood against tracker websites; earlier in the week many other sites were taken down. The effectiveness of the takedowns could be massive; the paper below notes that when on the Suprnova mirrors went offline during their monitoring period, they saw a massive reduction in the number of users downloading files through the site.

Download: The Paper (pdf) | The Register


Cont...

In its twenty year history Reflections has created a number of break-out hits, including the Destruction Derby titles for the PlayStation, famous Amiga action title Shadow of the Beast, and, of course, the Driver series, whose success led Atari to acquire the studio in 1998.

The most recent title in the Driver series, Driv3r, was Atari's biggest commercial hope for this year, but the game launched to hugely polarised critical reaction - ultimately leading to allegations from some quarters that the firm had offered bribes or marketing deals in return from high review scores from certain publications.


Post a comment · Send to friend Comments · There are 164 additional comments
(5 replies) #1 entropista on 19 Dec 2004 - 14:15
i am in the exeem beta testing
#1.1 simpleyred on 19 Dec 2004 - 14:19
So am I :-D
#1.2 Xtreme $niper on 19 Dec 2004 - 14:59
How do you get into exeem?
#1.3 theyarecomingforyou on 19 Dec 2004 - 16:02
How is it going to protect against fake files? That is what ShareReactor (RIP) and Suprnova were designed for - to act as a source for genuine files.
#1.4 JJ-1024 on 19 Dec 2004 - 18:39
Exeem - is it any good ?, how does it comapre to say others out there ?
#1.5 Dirtie on 20 Dec 2004 - 00:50
Yes I am also in exeem. The problem is not enough users sharing files.
#2 Foub on 19 Dec 2004 - 14:17
Kazaa? What's that?
#3 simpleyred on 19 Dec 2004 - 14:18
im not too sure if this is good or bad :-|
(1 reply) #4 welshkid on 19 Dec 2004 - 14:21
bittorrent is gettin tooo common
#4.1 PayneX on 19 Dec 2004 - 16:08
It's all getting too common.
I blame Napster.
(1 reply) #5 Krpano on 19 Dec 2004 - 14:34
Thx to Bram Cohen.
#5.1 the_snitch on 20 Dec 2004 - 09:29
that man is a frickin genious. I would be so pleased if i was him, to be able to say "i am responsible for 30% of all traffic on the net".
#6 WinMacLin on 19 Dec 2004 - 14:44
Gotta love bittorent
(5 replies) #7 krono6 on 19 Dec 2004 - 15:06
Bittorrent?? Eh, I now just use DC++.............easier to find the files you want imo..
#7.1 Solarix on 19 Dec 2004 - 16:33
welcome to the past
#7.2 Hanz™ on 19 Dec 2004 - 19:06
I think you mean welcome to the future?!
#7.3 Rudy on 19 Dec 2004 - 20:09
no he meant past
#7.4 insurektion on 19 Dec 2004 - 21:44
cant it be both
#7.5 idoia on 20 Dec 2004 - 07:50
DC is pretty old skool
#8 raid517 on 19 Dec 2004 - 15:34
Suprnova has apparently voluntarliy committed kamakaze. Their forums are completely trimed/decimated of any talk at all of illegal content and clicking on any link to torrents on their official site simply gives a Java script message saying 'no mirrors found'.

Either they have genuinely opted to let the MPAA kick their butts hard - or they are stirring up hysteria in order to try to fuel the demand for exeem. Maybe they think they can cash in on this whole deal?

GJ

Last edited by 13486 on 19 Dec 2004 - 15:53
#9 skybl4ck on 19 Dec 2004 - 15:48
QUOTE
Hello all,

To keep this forum alive the admin have decided that we will be removing all torrent related sections immediately.

SFD Hosting is now just the host of these forums and nothing else to do with suprnova, as part of our AUP we do not allow links to P2P programs be they t0rrent or otherwise, anybody breaching these rules will be immediately banned for life. This goes for linking to torrent sites as well.

We understand that this may alarm people but in order to preserve this community we must practice this isolationism at least for the time being.

Thank you for your patience.
- FD (Suprnova Admin)

It seems that the RIAA and MPAA are cracking down on torrent sites now. FD probably doesn't want to get his company, which hosts the forums, in trouble.
(1 reply) #10 Ivand on 19 Dec 2004 - 16:09
damn.. suprnova is gone
#10.1 moeburn on 19 Dec 2004 - 16:14
Still works fine for me...

edit: Wait a minute... wtf... what happened to my precious suprnova...

NO!!!!!

Last edited by 49903 on 19 Dec 2004 - 16:27
(2 replies) #11 kennyout on 19 Dec 2004 - 16:13
why the heck do they want to combine it with KazaA?

that is the most riddled client with fakes, viruses, spyware, adware, and all around CRAPware
#11.1 Dirtie on 20 Dec 2004 - 00:52
I think you read wrong. It combines the the idea of torrents etc. with a P2P (e.g. Kazaa) style interface.
#11.2 enzo on 20 Dec 2004 - 16:16
not just a P2P style interface. P2P means a decentralized network. That's what allowed Kazaa to outlast Napster's centralized server network.
(2 replies) #12 moeburn on 19 Dec 2004 - 16:16
Sun Dec 19 11:28:50 2004

#suprnova.org 328 [+mntirGCTf] SuprNova is from today on DOWN. It will not be returning in any way that we know it now. We are very sorry for this, but it is not possible any other way. Thank you all for all your help! SuprNova crew


Last edited by 49903 on 19 Dec 2004 - 16:29
#12.1 codykm on 19 Dec 2004 - 18:21
If only it were April Fools again, if you remember suprnova said they were closed then too. but this one sounds a little more sure.
#12.2 the_snitch on 20 Dec 2004 - 09:31
i remember suprnova changed teh whole site to Japanese, and said thats how it will be from now on.
Took me a min to realise what was happening.
(4 replies) #13 Porp on 19 Dec 2004 - 16:41
SuprNova is gone. Where am I going to go now?
#13.1 markjensen on 19 Dec 2004 - 18:58
Could it be that some people may actually have to buy their software?
Of course, the less ethical will find other sources...
#13.2 insurektion on 19 Dec 2004 - 21:45
Im going for the less ethical. THey got my vote
#13.3 brew crew on 20 Dec 2004 - 03:02
QUOTE
buy their software


what about all those people who use BT to download their fav tv shows
#13.4 vhcs on 20 Dec 2004 - 12:56
i can now see a huge boost for open source coming
#14 Tartan on 19 Dec 2004 - 16:46
I can't believe they would do this. They must've had legal problems before and got around them some how?....by using redirets, proxies and whatever else. What's different now?
#15 Rishdeep on 19 Dec 2004 - 16:59
Suprnova gone?

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO...
(1 reply) #16 raid517 on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:02
Full statement:

QUOTE
Greetings everybody,

As you have probably noticed, we have often had downtimes. This was because it was so hard to keep this site up!
But now we are sorry to inform you all, that SuprNova is closing down for good in the way that we all know it.
We do not know if SuprNova is going to return, but it is certainly not going to be hosting any more torrent links.
We are very sorry for this, but there was no other way, we have tried everything.

Thank you all that helped us, by donating mirrors or something else, by uploading and seeding files, by helping people out on IRC and on forum, by spreading the word about SuprNova.org.
It is a sad day for all of us!

Please visit SuprNova.org every once in a while to get the latest news on what is happening and if there is anything new to report on.

As we wish to maintain the nice community that we created, we are keeping the forums and irc servers open.


Thank you all and Goodbye!
sloncek & the rest of the SuprNova Team


It's a bit like the day Elvis died I'm afraid. A lot of people are going to remember this.

GJ
#16.1 Rudy on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:43
this sux
(2 replies) #17 JakeM741 on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:06
too bad suprnova.org is over...

QUOTE
Greetings everybody,

As you have probably noticed, we have often had downtimes. This was because it was so hard to keep this site up!
But now we are sorry to inform you all, that SuprNova is closing down for good in the way that we all know it.
We do not know if SuprNova is going to return, but it is certainly not going to be hosting any more torrent links.
We are very sorry for this, but there was no other way, we have tried everything.

Thank you all that helped us, by donating mirrors or something else, by uploading and seeding files, by helping people out on IRC and on forum, by spreading the word about SuprNova.org.
It is a sad day for all of us!

Please visit SuprNova.org every once in a while to get the latest news on what is happening and if there is anything new to report on.

As we wish to maintain the nice community that we created, we are keeping the forums and irc servers open.

Thank you all and Goodbye!
sloncek & the rest of the SuprNova Team
#17.1 raid517 on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:09
.....
#17.2 JakeM741 on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:14
lol, sorry, i was reading the other comments and stuff, it didn't show yours
(4 replies) #18 LCPLSkyeHack on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:08
QUOTE
Greetings everybody,

As you have probably noticed, we have often had downtimes. This was because it was so hard to keep this site up!
But now we are sorry to inform you all, that SuprNova is closing down for good in the way that we all know it.
We do not know if SuprNova is going to return, but it is certainly not going to be hosting any more torrent links.
We are very sorry for this, but there was no other way, we have tried everything.

Thank you all that helped us, by donating mirrors or something else, by uploading and seeding files, by helping people out on IRC and on forum, by spreading the word about SuprNova.org.
It is a sad day for all of us!

Please visit SuprNova.org every once in a while to get the latest news on what is happening and if there is anything new to report on.

As we wish to maintain the nice community that we created, we are keeping the forums and irc servers open.


Thank you all and Goodbye!
sloncek & the rest of the SuprNova Team


damn
#18.1 raid517 on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:10
Erm, didn't you notice I just posted this?

GJ
#18.2 LCPLSkyeHack on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:11
did you notice that maybe i didn't refresh you ******
#18.3 raid517 on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:18
Now now, no need to be rude... Just trying to help you not look dumb...

GJ
#18.4 rural on 20 Dec 2004 - 00:51
Good luck.
(2 replies) #19 Cryptic_Night on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:10
This is bringing back memories of Napster.....

RIP Suprnova
#19.1 Thrawn on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:47
R.I.P.
#19.2 RaccoonSalsa on 23 Dec 2004 - 13:42
Its so sad...
(3 replies) #20 Slouch on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:13
Surely this is one of the signs of the apocalypse.
#20.1 JakeM741 on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:14
maybe for the warez scene
#20.2 Hanz™ on 19 Dec 2004 - 19:10
I hate to tell you but the warez scene does not revolve around bittorrent or suprnova, but it revolves around private FTPs/topsites...
#20.3 Dirtie on 20 Dec 2004 - 00:54
Topsites, haha, there's a joke.
#21 moeburn on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:14
This is the worst day in the history of the internet.
(3 replies) #22 bucko on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:15
Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo die you government b*asterds you know us college students can't afford the likes of 3DSM, Photoshop, XP you know we can't afford it!!!!! (hopes suprnova appears on IRC DCC). Dont start saying I need a job, cause I got an extra year of college + uni.
#22.1 D-j-M on 19 Dec 2004 - 18:36
You sound like you're in primary school, not college.
#22.2 bucko on 19 Dec 2004 - 18:44
Rofl. I may have gone a bit far on that but its the truth ^_^.
#22.3 Total_CDRW on 19 Dec 2004 - 23:41
Well the internet seems rather empty with those sites gone... Probably 5% of all internet bandwidth is related to them

Have to find some other way to use bandwidth now

I wear my SN tshirt with pride - Jinx still sells them - probably not much longer
(1 reply) #23 supernova_00 on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:16
no more suprnova?
#23.1 JakeM741 on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:18
yup
(3 replies) #24 lefty on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:19
I'm sorry to hear that you're having trouble with your piracy
#24.1 Joshie on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:30
<3 pirates.

Capitalism without theft doesn't make a good story.
#24.2 triad_man on 19 Dec 2004 - 23:34
It's not theft it's infringement. There is a difference.
#24.3 Joshie on 20 Dec 2004 - 02:38
Theft has prettier letters.
(1 reply) #25 FatCat on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:31
torrentbits got shut down too what a shame.
#25.1 GM_Axis on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:36
Damn... I died a little bit inside when I saw that big "Good-bye" on TB...

#26 R-Style on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:32
It's time for an Torrent Ressurection.....
#27 Jackalo on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:33
I bet you that Internet Traffic just dropped 10% for today.
(1 reply) #28 ~Speed_Demon~ on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:43
In regards to all the BT tracker/site raids going on people are forgetting one key thing...No charges have been filed. So until charges are filed and it is officially deemed "illegal" to run a tracker site there is no point on speculating about the future of said sites.
#28.1 zORYn on 19 Dec 2004 - 22:09
QUOTE
No charges have been filed. So until charges are filed and it is officially deemed "illegal" to run a tracker site there is no point on speculating about the future of said sites.

would YOU risk it? i bet that when the first eMule users started getting filed, they thought the same way, no?
#29 Lasker on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:43
F*c that man, I already got the files I need from suprnova, hehehehehe I don't need no more but damn is super cool not one before can beat suprnova, now is gone.......NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
#30 obiewankinobie on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:44
I can't believe they shut down. It is a terrible thing. I used the site for a long time.
(1 reply) #31 i like chips on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:46
this is truly a sad day. RIP suprnova.
#31.1 R1CK13 on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:56
#32 barcode on 19 Dec 2004 - 17:50
Oh... My... God... No...
(1 reply) #33 vetMr magoo on 19 Dec 2004 - 18:10
Links to torrent sites will be removed; please do not break the rules.
#33.1 vhcs on 20 Dec 2004 - 13:01
OMG people are that sick? well will they learn and just use open source and once you guys start using open source it will become bigger and better
#34 Elite_graphix on 19 Dec 2004 - 18:12
#35 sundayx on 19 Dec 2004 - 18:14
bye suprnova. *sniff
#36 za3zoo3 on 19 Dec 2004 - 18:14
i would to know something

how they close the site ?

i mean if the site are hosted out of U.S how they can make a lawsuits and legal move like that ?

and if the site are hosted in russia or east Asia country can they close it ??
(2 replies) #37 Elite_graphix on 19 Dec 2004 - 18:15
#37.1 R1CK13 on 19 Dec 2004 - 18:52
OMG U OWN TY SO MUCH!!!!11!!!!!1!!1
#37.2 fuelman on 20 Dec 2004 - 13:28
What an ass. To play with my emotions like that.
(3 replies) #38 darkmatter on 19 Dec 2004 - 18:20
sad day....like surpnova for HD versions of tv shows mainly...
#38.1 i like chips on 19 Dec 2004 - 18:51
there are other sites out there for tv torrents. can't post links or i'll get shot
#38.2 supernova_00 on 19 Dec 2004 - 19:42
http://tvt.milfclan.com/ Courts already deemed its legal for tv shows because we pay for cable and could have watched and recorded it on our tivos or dvd burners when watching it so we can also download it for free since its already on public airways.

EDIT: WTF its down also!?!?!