main

Flat-Screen Makers Face Patent Lawsuits in U.S.

malebolgia   on 14 March 2005 - 15:30 · 16 comments & 2911 views

Advertisement (Why?)
Two industrial manufacturers, Guardian Industries Corp. and Honeywell International Inc., have sued dozens of companies in the global PC and video display businesses in a U.S. federal court to try to recoup royalties on liquid-crystal technology. Guardian Industries, a maker of industrial glass, and Honeywell, known for making weapons systems, assert in filings in the U.S. District Court in Delaware that their intellectual property for liquid crystal displays, used in notebook computers, TVs, and cellular phones, have been infringed.

Taiwan and South Korea are the two primary centers of LCD production, which is growing rapidly as demand for LCD-based televisions rises. The lawsuits target the LCD industry directly, but also assert claims against companies that incorporate LCDs into final electronic products. Jin Kim, the director LCD market research for research firm DisplaySearch, said the LCD business largely avoided patent lawsuits through its earlier years, but has attracted litigants as the business blossomed into a $40 billion market.

News source: Reuters


What's New in This Release:

· added support for PCI-Express cards
· fixed 16x AF mode
· fixed image sharpening status for 6xxx series GPU
· added new ForceWare Direct3D database
· updated Pixel shader settings for 6xxx series GPU
· updated Vertex shader settings for 6xxx series GPU
· updated Performance wizard
· updated Russian translation
· AGP setting page option is not show if PCI-e card is on board
· some others small fixes and changes

Post a comment · Send to friend Comments · There are 16 additional comments
#1 Lexcyn on 14 Mar 2005 - 15:36
Oh wow, I'm guessing this is another attempt to cash in on something that's becoming bigger in the industry. Correct me if I'm wrong.
#2 dekaranger on 14 Mar 2005 - 15:48
You're probably right. It doesn't surprise me anymore to see these lawsuits popping up. I just have a problem when a company waits years to start a lawsuit. Hey, I have an idea how about a spin-off site just for the lawsuits that keep popping up. It could be called neolawsuit.net
#3 raduking on 14 Mar 2005 - 16:22
wrong...
#4 g-n-t on 14 Mar 2005 - 16:44
better get one now before the prices go up....
#5 Mando on 14 Mar 2005 - 18:09
i cant wait for the lawsuit on C: prompt heheh afterall BT tried to start a lawsuit on the hyperlink
(3 replies) #6 EduardValencia on 14 Mar 2005 - 19:02
i agree with that lawsuit,americans deserve a big chunk of credit of the LCd technology,i hope they beat asian arses.
#6.1 Foub on 15 Mar 2005 - 00:39
Why would they want to do that when they are selling their own "asses" to Asia wholesale already? Much of the tech the USA developed they eagerly sold as soon as they could. What is happening now is mainly due to their own corproate greed.
#6.2 EduardValencia on 15 Mar 2005 - 04:43
yup foub i agree with you
#6.3 sverti on 16 Mar 2005 - 13:21
are you for real? be serious
(4 replies) #7 yizuman on 14 Mar 2005 - 19:29
People predict ideas and they go to the copyright office to patent that idea, then they wait for someone to come up with the idea as the patent gets buried within the office files for some number of years.

Then when the idea gets marketed, they wait until millions of dollars flows into the company, they then hire a lawyer and fire up a lawsuit claiming the idea was stolen.

It's a scam for lazyass people who won't lift a finger to work the money for themselves, they just wait for someone else to do it for them and then spunge it all off the company for themselves.

I don't know about you guys, but I hate lazy people who won't earn some real work and money for themselves.

#7.1 Serenis on 14 Mar 2005 - 21:35
exactly my point of view
#7.2 Foub on 15 Mar 2005 - 00:42
They have to provide a proof of concept to the Patent office first to qualify for a patent. Plus, any company is going to serach the patent office as well to make sure that no one can steal it from them or that they are using an already existence concept. If so they would probably buy the patent outright.
#7.3 Jstphish on 15 Mar 2005 - 05:01
Don't you have a certain amount of time to try and make use of the patent? ... or is that just trademarks?
#7.4 YaddaMe on 15 Mar 2005 - 13:28
QUOTE
Then when the idea gets marketed, they wait until millions of dollars flows into the company, they then hire a lawyer and fire up a lawsuit claiming the idea was stolen.

It's a scam for lazyass people who won't lift a finger to work the money for themselves


People are way to quick to label each & every patent lawsuit as a scam/squat/etc.

Based on what I've read, these patents cover recently introduced LCD technologies. And these companies are in active business with the technologies that these patents cover. There are many patent-squatters and investment companies that fit your critisism, but I just don't see it in this case.

And in all fairness... if the patents are legit, isn't it the company being sued that is the lazy one for not diligently researching who owns the rights to the technology? Granted, quite a many patents overlap each other and are questionable... but it's something one has to account for (and something that many do not).

QUOTE
Don't you have a certain amount of time to try and make use of the patent?


No, but that would be a great idea to help thwart the squatters. They are valid for 20 years, but no requirements about actually making use of it.
However, if you invented something... even if it were something you could not use/produce/etc... wouldn't you want to be compensated if someone infringed on your idea? OVerall, the squatters & investment coompanies usually do exactly what yizuman say they do, however, if they are valid patents, they are still entitled to their right to charge for the use of their idea... no matter how much we all disagree with that practice.
(1 reply) #8 TruckWEB on 14 Mar 2005 - 23:16
WHY WAIT 10 years, and then wakeup and start a lawsuit on something you «think» you own from the begining??

Easy money hey? Why work or be creative? Lets create a bunch of patent and wait.....
#8.1 Jelly2003 on 15 Mar 2005 - 21:27
its what plenty of people do

Commenting has either been disabled on this article or you are not logged in. Click here to login or register, its free!

Note: Anonymous commenting is disabled in order to keep the quality of responses to a high standard.

Advertisement (Why?)