main
Report a problem

eBay bans Online Auctions of Virtual Game Booty

Slimy   on 31 January 2007 - 01:11 · 19 comments & 5523 views

Advertisement (Why?)
The San Jose, California-based Internet auction site has decided to bar sales of virtual goods in video games due to "legal complexities" regarding ownership. The policy has been in place for the past few weeks: the company frequently removes virtual game related auctions. Enterprising young gamers have earned livings playing games like WoW and selling their weaponry, armor and other items. eBay has decided, however, not to ban the auctioning of items from virtual societies. ebay spokesman Hani Durzy compared this ban to the firm's decisions to bar sales of alcohol or tobacco, which are lawful products controlled by complex governmental regulations.

"We decided it was best to just not allow sales of them. We are not saying they are legal and we are not saying they are illegal. Right now, Second Life is not considered a game so we are not applying the restriction to it. Remember, our policies are ever evolving. We will change them if the communities, state of the culture, or laws dictate such," said Durzy.

News source: Physorg

Post a comment · Send to friend Comments · There are 19 additional comments
#1 vetneufuse on 31 Jan 2007 - 01:16
good
(4 replies) #2 Brandon on 31 Jan 2007 - 01:17
huh? im confuzed. how could you sell somehting in a game?
#2.1 RiVaLSSJ on 31 Jan 2007 - 01:35
"Give me $10 and I'll transfer my lv 10 Uber-Galactica Sw0rd 4000 to you."
#2.2 MrCobra on 31 Jan 2007 - 02:57
I once sold 134 ectos in GuildWars for $150.
#2.3 RiVaLSSJ on 31 Jan 2007 - 03:23
Quote - (MrCobra said @ #2.2)
I once sold 134 ectos in GuildWars for $150.

I have no idea if 134 "ectos" is alot or not, but that sounds pretty crazy. Who buys this stuff!?
#2.4 MrCobra on 31 Jan 2007 - 03:32
Quote - (RiVaLSSJ said @ #2.3)
Quote - (MrCobra said @ #2.2)
I once sold 134 ectos in GuildWars for $150.

I have no idea if 134 "ectos" is alot or not, but that sounds pretty crazy. Who buys this stuff!?

Ectos in GW are special and rare drops that only happen in a couple of select places in the game and at the time I was selling them were worth $7,500 in game gold. They are also used for crafting items in game. You had to go farming for these items and it can take a long time. The 134 I sold took around a month to get.

A lot of people buy/sell game items simply because some of the better items rarely show up. I have a sword/shield set that goes for $125K in game (if you find someone willing to part with them). $15 actual money bought myself a cool $500K in gold. I purchased that weapons set plus a couple of other items.
#3 RiVaLSSJ on 31 Jan 2007 - 01:29
Even if I ever played these games, I would NEVER pay actual money for an in-game item How much do these things go for anyway?
(1 reply) #4 imachip on 31 Jan 2007 - 01:47
Good for the games themselves as 'playing for profit' takes the fun out of it for others who try to enjoy it. I guess there will be a backlash with more people ingame spamming gold selling websites but to be honest Blizzard doesn't care much from what I've seen.

They don't intervene fast enough to discourage this behavior as it should be easy to an audit to find the accounts of gold sellers (all they need do is purchase some gold from a website and cancel where it comes from).

Glad Ebay is at least taking a stance although it's out of 'legal complexities' than against playing for profit because they wouldn't care otherwise :/
#4.1 MrCobra on 31 Jan 2007 - 02:58
Honestly, if I want to buy 60K in gold or sell it to someone for that matter, what does it hurt you or anyone else?
#5 7Dash8 on 31 Jan 2007 - 02:05
If you ban one sort of "stupid tax" you inevitably get another. Stupid people need to be taxed, it's just a question of how, not if or when.
#6 Xeta on 31 Jan 2007 - 02:05
W00T!!
#7 xxdesmus on 31 Jan 2007 - 02:29
This is great. About freakin time.
#8 ANova on 31 Jan 2007 - 02:29
People are dumb.
#9 Turbonium on 31 Jan 2007 - 04:17
About time. Ruins game economies and overall quality of experience.
(1 reply) #10 purplehaze32 on 31 Jan 2007 - 05:23
Translation: "Second Life paid us to exempt them from this rule."
#10.1 RichardK on 31 Jan 2007 - 06:17
Nope, Second Life encourages people to buy/sell in-game land/items for real money. They just told eBay that they don't object to items being bought/sold via auctions.
(1 reply) #11 LVirus on 31 Jan 2007 - 05:26
EVE-Online allowes legit buy and sell of ingame currency
#11.1 SHADOW-XIII on 31 Jan 2007 - 13:05
Quote - (LVirus said @ #11)
EVE-Online allowes legit buy and sell of ingame currency
yeah Eve's awesome game, the best MMORPG I've seen
you pay monthly with ingame currency - this is something
#12 DaveAlmighty on 31 Jan 2007 - 17:57
I sold virtual furniture, little green, red sofas and drink machines for £340/$680.

Commenting has either been disabled on this article or you are not logged in. Click here to login or register, its free!

Note: Anonymous commenting is disabled in order to keep the quality of responses to a high standard.

Advertisement (Why?)