main
Report a problem

Studios: Digital Downloads Not Ready

Doug Bemis   via TVPredictions on 13 March 2008 - 13:37 · 16 comments & 11824 views

Advertisement (Why?)
With todays launch of Hulu open to the public and recent additions to Apples iTunes store carrying movie rentals, how far are we away from primarily receiving our TV shows and movies via the internet? According to some of the top Hollywood studio executives, we are not close at all.

At a recent Content Delivery and Storage Association conference, a few people spoke out about this. The vice president of content development for Fox, Sven Davidson, stated "Demand for downloading is very small and the satisfaction is smaller." Benn Carr, the vice president of new technology for Disney, said "I don’t think we have to be worried about the replacement of physical media for some time, [...] Downloading sales are not going to ‘hockey-stick’ soon. Every time I access a site and download, it’s not necessarily seamless". They also say that hi-def movies can take several hours to download.

What are your opinions? Do you prefer a physical disk or purchasing to download? On one hand, you have HD content that cannot be backed up (according to the DMCA), so if you lose or scratch it, it is gone. On the other, most downloadable content has DRM protection. While you can back it up, if the company supplying the rights management goes under or the company licensing the content changes their DRM, you chance having your whole collection as wasted space.

Poll
What do you prefer?
  • Download movies/tv shows
     19
  • Purchase/Rent DVDs or Blu-Ray
     16
Total votes: 35
Post a comment · Send to friend Comments · There are 16 additional comments
(2 replies) #1 DTR on 13 Mar 2008 - 14:03
Where is the 3rd option?
#1.1 SkyyPunk on 13 Mar 2008 - 14:11
What would you want to see as another option?
#1.2 bush on 14 Mar 2008 - 08:03
Watch CowboyNeal in action.
#2 GreyWolfSC on 13 Mar 2008 - 14:06
None of this will ever be 'ready' as long as the suits keep treating art as a commodity...
#3 vetneufuse on 13 Mar 2008 - 14:25
Nothing better then getting kicked off your ISP for downloading TV shows and movies too much when its perfectly legal but yet "puts a significant strain on the network"... gota love Comcast... you know they will be the first to do it when downloads become mainstream because they offer the same things via VOD already on their own service......
#4 simsie on 13 Mar 2008 - 14:46
I prefer to buy the DVD and then rip it...

I can't download or stream decent quality movies on my wonderful 1Mb/s internet.
(1 reply) #5 Skwerl on 13 Mar 2008 - 15:19
I second Simsie. I prefer to store my movies on the computer, but I've never liked what I have seen on-line from Vongo or Netflix or Movie-whatever. And really- how many people have HTPCs? This is going to continue to be a minority for a while, yet.
#5.1 vetneufuse on 13 Mar 2008 - 15:24
(Skwerl said @ #5)
I second Simsie. I prefer to store my movies on the computer, but I've never liked what I have seen on-line from Vongo or Netflix or Movie-whatever. And really- how many people have HTPCs? This is going to continue to be a minority for a while, yet.


Psh the industry would rather you rent them for set periods of time and then store them in DRM formats so you have to buy new ones every time a new format player comes out... Having a physical format means you are taking money from them they could of potentially had
#6 jameswjrose on 13 Mar 2008 - 16:03
I think the best solution for all parties is to allow the purchase of a on-demand licence. The ability to stream the movie to whatever device whenever I like. As technology improves we would be able to upgrade to hi-def in much the same way we update/upgrade our software.

In this fashion I would not have to worry about dvds becoming scratched or lost, and I could be at a friend's house and simply log in and view the film.

Of course, because there will always be a way to get around DRM I have a difficult time imagining a studio going this route, but also imagine that they would not have to deal with manufacture and distrubution of the discs and they would be able to place their entire catalog at a minimal cost.

There is also another benefit to the studio and the consumers. They will be able to notice the types of programs/films that we view and market to us the programs we actually want to view. Spam is only spam when it is items we do not want.

Food for thought.

Peace,
James Rose
New York City
(1 reply) #7 excalpius on 13 Mar 2008 - 16:28
Sven Davidson, stated "Demand for downloading is very small and the satisfaction is smaller."

That's what SHE said...
#7.1 alister on 13 Mar 2008 - 18:16
(excalpius said @ #7)
Sven Davidson, stated "Demand for downloading is very small and the satisfaction is smaller."


"Demand for downloading is very small", but they blame the internet and users downloading movies on poor ticket and dvd sales ?????
#8 HalcyonX12 on 13 Mar 2008 - 18:17
Digital downloads are not ready because there is no standard for them. You can't take one digital download and use it on whatever device... this is MS's storefront using MS's hardware. Yeah it's the same as iTunes, but there was always the alternative of CD, which you can use in any device, so you weren't stuck using iTunes. This is trying to raise the question of Bluray vs Digital Downloads in an either/or situation, and if you only had to pick one, then digital downloads is more restrictive and kinda more expensive in the end since you could never borrow them or get used copies, and who knows if you have to buy one for each device in your home or what.
#9 turtledude23 on 13 Mar 2008 - 18:31
I have broadband and I dont like leaving my house, downloading ftw
#10 Dogward on 13 Mar 2008 - 19:13
Download all the way here too !

Anyway, here in France, many ISP offer VOD and most recently offer many online video services directly streamed to the TV, as youtube and so on...
With an almost "standard" 24Mb connection and new 100Mb Fiber connections coming, digital HD through internet is right on the corner at least here, in France.
#11 bush on 14 Mar 2008 - 08:02
what are analog downloads then?
#12 leo221 on 14 Mar 2008 - 15:07
torrents and emule says they were ready a year ago.

Commenting has either been disabled on this article or you are not logged in. Click here to login or register, its free!

Note: Anonymous commenting is disabled in order to keep the quality of responses to a high standard.

Advertisement (Why?)