Something you would have thought would only be part of action movies may be a reality soon in the UK. The government has plans to create a massive database that will store all phone calls, emails, and internet logs of all UK citizens. The information can be stored for as long as 2 years.The database will take time to create, but there are trials and tests set in place with pre-determined people.
This is a feasible solution to solving criminal cases, and lowering crime rates, however, many will see it as a very large invasion of privacy.
UK Home Office minister, Lord West, noted:
"It is a cross-government program, led by the Home Office, to ensure that our capability to lawfully intercept and exploit data when fighting crime and terrorism is not lost."
I would like to hear you opinions, Neowin. In an act to ensure safety, is this action taking it too far?
View: TechRadar
No, Not really. The terrorist planning most likely occurs outside the country anyway. "Terrorism" is a means of controlling people via fear. If the government says terrorism is imminent, people won't be as concerned about having their phonecalls and emails monitored because hey, it will "stop terrorism."
"It's alright, we'll just go through your stuff. There will be no more terrorism very soon."
Yeah, I think that is what he was getting at...
Unfortunately with all this crap in the US, they don't seem to have been able to provide any evidence that it's helping at all. Welcome to your own Big Brother.
By the way, where are the tin foil hats? As I've seen on the forums before, anyone who believes that the government is taking advantage of us, removing our rights, or simply stepping in for more control is laughed at. Oh, but that's just some science fiction mumbo jumbo, right? Oh wait...
@ n_K: Why leave? I mean, you can't run from a problem like this. How long before the next country is doing it?
Yes, because they always make their plans over the phone.
If you want to stop terrorism, tell the UK government to stop using terrorist oil.
Middle Eastern oil = terrorism.
What terrorism? We've had one bus bomb go off and that was through home grown terrorism. Our liberties are slowly eroded thanks to this seemingly invisible terrorist threat - the government needs to start being a bit more transparent with us.
Lol true, but I hate labour entirely, they are conservative scum and don't give a crap WHAT the people think. Oh and browns a bloody hypocrite, his website is illegal in that its entirely copyright theft yet he wants everyone that breaks the copyright law to be punished so badly, hope he gets sued loads and put in prison for it
Last edited by shockz on 20 Aug 2008 - 17:13
you say you're not an idiot and you still are happy about this? riiiiight.
are you going to be happy when your goverment will "lose" your phone number, credit card and DNA string as well?
you say you're not an idiot and you still are happy about this? riiiiight.
are you going to be happy when your goverment will "lose" your phone number, credit card and DNA string as well?
I never said I'm completely happy with it or come to think of it I never said anything like I'm happy about it, I just meant I'm not completely against it.
You realize that there's a good amount of Americans who don't support this kind of stuff and don't say everything is because of terrorism. Our government says everything is for terrorism not the people.
You realize that there's a good amount of Americans who don't support this kind of stuff and don't say everything is because of terrorism. Our government says everything is for terrorism not the people.
I am in Ireland.
I am not Irish.
And I do NOT drink. At all.
You realize that there's a good amount of Americans who don't support this kind of stuff and don't say everything is because of terrorism. Our government says everything is for terrorism not the people.
I am in Ireland.
I am not Irish.
And I do NOT drink. At all.
Yes well I live in America, I was born and raised here. I'm Irish and English in decent, and guess what? I don't think everything is to prevent terrorism. So how about we don't generalize whole groups?
Why not dispense with all the other freedoms while we're at it? It will certainly be easier to spot terrorists because they'll be the ones speaking out against the government. We'll just throw them in jail to ensure the domestic tranquility. Can't have people going on about invasive government. We're doing it to keep you safe. /sarcasm
I'm an American, nmesisca. So does that make me a complete idiot. I hate that European sense of superiority. It's just as much bull**** as the American sense of superiority many exude.
I just cant still come to terms with the fact that you confirmed your president for a second mandate.
And yeah, I am a bit unfair but I do think most responsibilities for where we all are at the moment are with the USA and the usual war to terror.
Stragely enough i dont recall ever being in such a pain to travel and go around in the world prior to the war on terror.
Guess they've never seen Die Hard 4.0.
Hopefully the sheer amount of money been wasted on this will create enough media hype to stop it but then most of media works for/is in the same group that controls the gov......theres a knock at me door :s
Its been here for awhile, 14 million cameras already so it won't be long till we all have 1 each & of course we will have to pay for it, pay to run it & pay to have someone or something watch it. Thank feck I don't live in the UK but these c***s will give other gov's ideas about how to milk & police the cash cow that is the modern democratic citizen/consumer/slave.
Its been here for awhile, 14 million cameras already so it won't be long till we all have 1 each & of course we will have to pay for it, pay to run it & pay to have someone or something watch it. Thank feck I don't live in the UK but these c***s will give other gov's ideas about how to milk & police the cash cow that is the modern democratic citizen/consumer/slave.
Oi there we go some one has to start calling other people, I'd like it if you didn't call my country thanks.
Its been here for awhile, 14 million cameras already so it won't be long till we all have 1 each & of course we will have to pay for it, pay to run it & pay to have someone or something watch it. Thank feck I don't live in the UK but these c***s will give other gov's ideas about how to milk & police the cash cow that is the modern democratic citizen/consumer/slave.
Oi there we go some one has to start calling other people, I'd like it if you didn't call my country thanks.
WTF is that supposed to mean I have not slagged off the UK or any other country for that matter in my 2 comments. I also have a vested interest in what happens in the UK as I have many relations there, the UK still controls part of my country & we are also both part of the EU(which looks like it might be the only chance to save you from your countries current & probably future goverment).
Your apathetic comment at the start of the comments section pretty much sums up the problem with modern democracies. On a lighter & overplayed note I would like to take the time to welcome your Nu all seeing, all knowing, all tracking, all controlling overlords.
Latest terrorism practice is making the countries so affraid that they practically rip themselves apart by giving up their highest principles!
Such governemental actions rather make terrorists happy than stop their actions.
It's totally ridiculous that terrorists would still use such means of information exchange. many things happen on a local base anyways, too.
You don't need contact to your taliban friends in some far away countries to know "what to do" and "when".
People should immediately tell their governements to stop this BC ASAP and return to not eating ourselves up.
Terrorism starts right here, giving up our own principles for the sake of "security", which is a null point as I pointed out.
Glassed Silver:mac
Can't be "only" when there is more then one though
Think of it, emails or telephone calls from journalists to contacts, clients to lawyers, patients to doctors, anything which could or should be thought of as privileged could be read under the proposed system, and will be read under the proposed system - by anyone who can gain access to the database.
Not so long ago we were told the hordes of CCTV cameras (must be upwards of 6million now in the UK) would stop crime but now they are used to fine people whose dogs are caught fouling under the wrong tree or spy on garbage bins which may not be closed properly. Have these CCTV cameras stopped crime ? maybe a few, but with record handgun deaths, record levels of white collar fraud and politicians on the take nearly everywhere .. they don't seem to have stopped much crime ...
Remember folks, which party the current UK government are .. Labour .. yes that's right .. Labour .. famous years ago for being in with the socialists & communists east side .. who along with their organisations such as the Stasi kept such databases on their population and held them almost in terror .. neighbour telling on neighbour, even kids ratting out their own parents .. so, despite it being 'New" Labour .. the old habits seem to die hard ?
Terrorism is a scare tactic used by governments to utterly control its population by keeping them living in fear, and having them hand over their freedoms all in the name of "security".
Governments around the world who are dreaming these proposals up must be sitting having a good laugh at our expense, knowing full well that enough people dont care enough and are just docile enough to think "awww its the goverment saying we need protection. They obviously know better than us, so lets allow them to ride roughshod over us and every facet of our lives. As long as we can watch Eastenders, Big Brother, and read about vacuous celebrities then everything will be allright."
For f**ks sake everyone ... the time has long past for the people to speak up and do something, yet all the while the government have been putting measures in place to ensure that if an uprising did occur, those protesting etc.. would be either arrested or shot on site (As an example .. investigate how close to Westminster / Houses of Parliament you can get to stage a protest).
**** weather, **** government, sheep like people who just accept everything they are spoon fed by the television / newspapers / magazines. Is it any wonder Britain is a joke (and no 16 golds in the Olympics doesnt change my opinion - its a 2 week event that pales in comparison to the real world that the rest of us have to live in day by day) and needs to be cleaned up on all fronts - Education, Crime, Housing, Equal rights ...
This is not the first time this has happened. go read some Joseph Goebbels.
Absolutely, completely totally and utterly bang on.
What a joke.
I've completely lost trust with this Govt. who thinks taking away privacy will stop terrorists. If there's a will, there's a way.
just thought id point this out this guy is right and il tell you when it ends... when the 5th is recreated and succeded or when the country warsagainst the government ..which WILL happen
We're already beyond that, remember the woman who got arrested at Wal-Mart for saying the F word...
theregister.co.uk
i live not for queen nore for country (espically not this rubbish one) i live and die for the freedom of my loved ones and self and england is getting in the way of my life
Last edited by hackncrap on 20 Aug 2008 - 16:56
now if i was a terrorist or a criminal would i really be using the usual insecure ways to communicate?, i think not
I think its a terrible idea which I hope for sanities sake will fail before it becomes to late.
http://petitions.number10.gov.uk/edatabase
IT IS NOT FEASIBLE
How much petabytes they want to store? (or Zettabyte?)
how they will be able to examine it?. We talk about *a lot* of data and can growth even bigger than Internet.
how valid and trustworthy is this information?.
And, UK lacks of pre-paid cellphone, anonymous cibercafe or free and anonymous wifi spot? Or even yet to use a public telephone box?
They are afraid of something but im not sure who or what.
Last edited by Magallanes on 20 Aug 2008 - 18:14
I am wondering how secure these files are planned to be? could they be altered? what happens to it after 2 years? could citizens be retroactively convicted of crimes from past emails longer than 2 years ago?
It just seems to be a horrendous invasion of privacy for a 3rd party to hold this private information that could be potentially breached in security. Even if its to prevent terrorism, what ordinary citizens will be terrorized through a justice system for emails and phone calls that shouldn't have put them there?
Now the only question is - who the hell do we vote for next time?? All of them are a dead loss!! :s
This is nothing for whats to come.
Before you flame me, do your research.
The EU is the revival of the roman empire.
You have nothing else to loose researching this, except more of your freedom if the government chooses.
I thought that was crazy enough, but recording every telephone call, email, etc? I'd expect things like that from China...but the UK?
Sadly these days it seems that no amount of outrage can stop politicians from doing what they want so unfortunately UK citizens should brace themselves for it.
No doubt eventually we'll see it rolled across the rest of the world once the UK perfects the technology.
gonna be a looooooooooong wait....maybe they will sue MS for help.
Things like the alert system put fear into people. The ability to wiretap without a subpoena or detain someone in custody for any amount of time they want with no trial... All of that is used to put fear into people to get what they want. It's ridiculous.
Plus what do you think GCHQ does??
http://digg.com/politics/UK_Government_to_...mails_and_calls
Hop