editorial
Report a problem

Marshymellow: The day the Zunes stood still

Marshalus   on 01 January 2009 - 19:37 · 30 comments & 8534 views

Advertisement (Why?)
Yesterday morning, thousands of previously happy Microsoft Zune 30 owners woke up to a interesting situation. Their Zunes were dead in the water.

As Neowin reported yesterday, "At exactly 2am CDT (12am PDT), the docked Zune made the 'unplugged from USB port' bong-noise and went to the boot-up screen with the 100% loading bar...and froze." This situation was similar if not identical for every other Zune 30 owner who had their devices turned on.

Microsoft acted quickly, undoubtedly after being bombarded with angry phone calls, emails, Tweets and message board posts. Shortly after 2pm PDT, Microsoft posted on their ZuneInsider blog and explained the problem and the solution.
Early this morning we were alerted by our customers that there was a widespread issue affecting our 2006 model Zune 30GB devices (a large number of which are still actively being used). The technical team jumped on the problem immediately and isolated the issue: a bug in the internal clock driver related to the way the device handles a leap year.

The issue should be resolved over the next 24 hours as the time change moves to January 1, 2009. We expect the internal clock on the Zune 30GB devices will automatically reset tomorrow (noon, GMT). By tomorrow you should allow the battery to fully run out of power before the unit can restart successfully then simply ensure that your device is recharged, then turn it back on. If you're a Zune Pass subscriber, you may need to sync your device with your PC to refresh the rights to the subscription content you have downloaded to your device.
Microsoft says they'll have an updated firmware for the Zune 30 out before 2012, which is the next leap year and the next time this problem is scheduled to happen.

The impact of this problem will be one that will haunt the Zune for some time. While the device is a fairly solid platform, with millions of happy customers, it still has its issues. Mostly, marketshare. For a long time I've recommended the Zune as an alternative to the iPod for many friends and family. My wife (Zune 4), father (Zune 4) and brother-in-law (Zune 30) have them, and I had a Zune 30 for a short time as well. But chances are most people who were of the non-geek persuasion have no idea what the Zune really is... but they probably do now.

Microsoft received a lot of negative press (and perhaps rightfully so) from this glitch in the mainstream media including CNN, Reuters, The Wall Street Journal and even their own MSNBC. (Et tu, Brute?)

Add to that press, the old adage that a satisfied customer will tell a one or two people about their experience but an angry customer will tell 10 and you have somewhat of a public relations nightmare for the Zune. Consider that the story on Neowin yesterday (at the time of writing) received nearly 9k views in one day, and garnered over 150 comments. These numbers are lightyears ahead of any other Zune story posted on the site in at least the last year, if not more. My Twitter feed was lit up yesterday with angry users, but also tech bloggers and other technology social networking butterflies who were commenting most of the day about the problem. It was hard to have your head anywhere yesterday and not at least see that the Zune 30, at least for a day, was an expensive and black/brown/white, brick.

Thankfully this glitch didn't take down Zune 4, 8, 80 or 120 users, otherwise what is a nightmare would be somewhat apocalyptic. As of August 2008, marketshare of the Zune was at around 4%, which is actually really strong, especially if you take all iPods out of the market, which enjoy nearly 71%. The Zune sits on top of the "non-iPod" MP3 player market. This is great news, except for one pesky problem... all the iPods are still there, with at least 18x the number of customers. The iPod has become synonymous with the term MP3 player. And to my knowledge, it has never bricked for a day.

Microsoft needs to act quickly to offer a remedy to all Zune 30 owners who may or may not have been hit with this bug. First off, the idea to offer them discounted upgrades is a horrible one. The conspiracy theorists out there already are talking about how this is all an evil plot by Redmond to force users to migrate to newer devices. While I don't see this problem as being that sinister, the fact is Microsoft will have to face up to this outlook despite everything they've done to prevent the perception in the past.

Microsoft has gone out of their way to make sure that early adopters of the Zune platform, with the Zune 30, have not been left behind in feature upgrades after each software release. The only thing the new Zune 4/8/80/120s can do that the Zune 30 can't, is navigate with a touch sensitive keypad. (Oh yeah, and not brick for a day.) This is because the hardware for the newer devices is physically different. The Zune 30 still has all of the latest firmware updates in parody with the new devices, features Wifi sync and sharing, etc, etc, all for free. To Microsoft's credit this is something that Apple either cannot or does not offer users of the iPod. Early adopters of the iPod Touch were charged $20 to upgrade their devices when the 2.0 version of the firmware came out with features like the App Store and Exchange sync. +1 to Microsoft there.

What Microsoft needs to do is offer a financial remedy to Zune 30 users who were without their devices for the day. Microsoft should be offering free song downloads, or a month of free Zune pass to Zune 30 owners. They need to act quick to make sure that the thousands of angry Zune owners don't soon become thousands of new iPod owners.

Post a comment · Send to friend Comments · There are 30 additional comments
(4 replies) #1 iamwhoiam on 01 Jan 2009 - 19:40
I absolutely love the title.
#1.1 Marshalus on 01 Jan 2009 - 19:50
-- I called it that and then after submitting it to Digg noticed a lot of other stories we called that. Guess I'm not as original as I thought
#1.2 Recon415 on 01 Jan 2009 - 20:11
Well, no one is original. If you think of something, someone has probably already thought of it before.

Then it's just a matter of who got the patent.
#1.3 MitchLeBlanc on 01 Jan 2009 - 20:12
I also like the title. ^_^
#1.4 vetGerry on 01 Jan 2009 - 23:01
I like it too, but just replace "still" with "stupid".
#2 MightyJordan on 01 Jan 2009 - 19:45
I don't think free song downloads or a free Zune pass will do. Quite a large majority of Zune 30 owners are outside America and Canada, and so they can't access the Zune Marketplace.

I think they should reward the non-NA customers for their loyalty by giving them access to all the Zune Social features.
(1 reply) #3 thealexweb on 01 Jan 2009 - 20:09
Only one build of Zune failed, misleading title.
#3.1 Marshalus on 01 Jan 2009 - 20:27
thealexweb said,
Only one build of Zune failed, misleading title.


So only one person's Zune died? My bad, I guess all the fuss was for nothing
(4 replies) #4 +Hell-In-A-Handbasket on 01 Jan 2009 - 20:10
2012 ? isnt that the year the aztec/maya/inca ( whoever ) said the world was goign to end. lol
#4.1 MitchLeBlanc on 01 Jan 2009 - 20:11
December 12, 2012 is when the Mayan calendar ends, it was never explicitly said by the Mayans that it will be the end of the world. That has only been insinuated by catastrophe theorists.
#4.2 Glendi on 01 Jan 2009 - 20:55
MitchLeBlanc said,
December 12, 2012 is when the Mayan calendar ends, it was never explicitly said by the Mayans that it will be the end of the world. That has only been insinuated by catastrophe theorists.


There will be a strong sun flare which is arguably strong enough to damage the electromagnetic field of earth... or so they say -> scientists (even NASA), not theorists. Though the end of the earth is clear BS.
#4.3 GreyWolfSC on 02 Jan 2009 - 01:54
More than likely the calendar would have required adjustment after 2012.
#4.4 LoSt187 on 03 Jan 2009 - 06:49
Glendi said,
There will be a strong sun flare which is arguably strong enough to damage the electromagnetic field of earth... or so they say -> scientists (even NASA), not theorists. Though the end of the earth is clear BS.


Also December of 2012 is when we pass from the age of Pisces into the age of Aquarrius. And by that I mean that our planet will have moved enough within the universe that the sun will no longer rise with the constellation Pisces above it, but the constellation Aquarrius.
(3 replies) #5 GEIST on 01 Jan 2009 - 20:33
What a horribly written article...
#5.1 Marshalus on 01 Jan 2009 - 20:36
GEIST said,
What a horribly written article...


Thanks!
#5.2 MioTheGreat on 01 Jan 2009 - 23:40
Marshalus said,
Thanks!


No mention of what actually caused the problem: http://www.zuneboards.com/forums/zune-news...m-isolated.html

So yeah, not particularly informative, at the very least.
#5.3 duneworld on 02 Jan 2009 - 14:01
Talking of horribly written, the following sentence doesnt even make any sense, even when you ignore the grammatical errors.
"Those who didn't received the New Years Eve surprise when their [should be they] turned on their device to be greeted by the Zune boot screen, and nothing else."

Apart from that the article isnt that bad.
(3 replies) #6 ahhell on 01 Jan 2009 - 21:04
"What Microsoft needs to do is offer a financial remedy to Zune 30 users who were without their devices for the day. Microsoft should be offering free song downloads, or a month of free Zune pass to Zune 30 owners. They need to act quick to make sure that the thousands of angry Zune owners don't soon become thousands of new iPod owners."

Can this be any more sensationalist?
Compensation for a 1 day "outage"? Get real.
#6.1 roadwarrior on 01 Jan 2009 - 21:26
ahhell said,
Can this be any more sensationalist?
Compensation for a 1 day "outage"? Get real.


It was an outage caused by a programming error that even a first semester programming student should have caught.
#6.2 kl33per on 02 Jan 2009 - 00:58
roadwarrior said,
It was an outage caused by a programming error that even a first semester programming student should have caught.


That's an exaggeration, I really doubt many first year programming students know the difference between procedural, OO, and functional programming let alone have the ability to debug the firmware of a consumer electronics device.

The error was really in testing the code anyway.
#6.3 GreyWolfSC on 02 Jan 2009 - 01:55
roadwarrior said,
ahhell said,
Can this be any more sensationalist?
Compensation for a 1 day "outage"? Get real.


It was an outage caused by a programming error that even a first semester programming student should have caught.


No, it was a flaw in the firmware for a third-party chip. It's not an issue anymore and it will be fixed.

Wasn't this already discussed to death in the original FPN article that's still on the front page?
#7 zivan56 on 01 Jan 2009 - 21:29
The Toshiba Gigabeat S also had the same issue...which leads me to believe Toshiba (or one of it's part suppliers) didn't write the driver to support a leap year.
(1 reply) #8 +NeoFlux on 01 Jan 2009 - 21:54
Firstly, it was their first Zune they made, so possible problems were highly likely to happen.

Secondly, only the Zune 30's had this problem.

Thirdly, my Zune 30 wasn't bricked, if it was, then I would of naturally been ****ed about it, but it hasn't, my Zune has started back up normally now.

Fourthly, Toshiba was the people who built the Zune 30, the rest were designed and built Microsoft themselves and none of the other zunes has this problem, so it's quite possible Toshiba's fault.

Conclusion, you haven't got a dead device, yes, you lost a days worth of use, but seriously, most likely a lot of peoples warranties expired and not really entitled to a replacement, this isn't RRoD which the Xbox 360's suffered, this was just a bug in the devices driver.

If Microsoft do respond by giving people free stuff, or even discounted upgrades to newer zunes, that is a lot more than a lot of companies would offered. There was a mistake, this was unexpected, but the problem was just a bug and not hardware failure.
#8.1 seethru on 02 Jan 2009 - 02:28
NeoFlux said,
Firstly, it was their first Zune they made, so possible problems were highly likely to happen.

Secondly, only the Zune 30's had this problem.

Thirdly, my Zune 30 wasn't bricked, if it was, then I would of naturally been ****ed about it, but it hasn't, my Zune has started back up normally now.

Fourthly, Toshiba was the people who built the Zune 30, the rest were designed and built Microsoft themselves and none of the other zunes has this problem, so it's quite possible Toshiba's fault.

Conclusion, you haven't got a dead device, yes, you lost a days worth of use, but seriously, most likely a lot of peoples warranties expired and not really entitled to a replacement, this isn't RRoD which the Xbox 360's suffered, this was just a bug in the devices driver.

If Microsoft do respond by giving people free stuff, or even discounted upgrades to newer zunes, that is a lot more than a lot of companies would offered. There was a mistake, this was unexpected, but the problem was just a bug and not hardware failure.

+1, any compensation for a one day 'outage' is ridiculous.
#9 yert* on 02 Jan 2009 - 01:45
One song credit should be enough compensation. Wasn't that big of a deal =/
(1 reply) #10 bahuma on 02 Jan 2009 - 02:26
Why is such a big deal being made of this? I have a Zune30 myself and I could not use it for one day - who cares?

Some people are acting as if the world has ended and their Zune exploded. My Zune30 has already outlasted my Dell DJ and the creative vision M i used to own. Get over it people, move on!
#10.1 NPGMBR on 02 Jan 2009 - 14:56
Wow, my first media device was a Dell DJ as well. But I got seriously ticked when Dell dropped support for it. Then I got a Toshiba Gigabeat S. Nice device but Toshiba support sucked when I dropped it and needed to get it fixed. Then I got a Zune at about two years ago and have never been happier. Actually im on my second Z80 because I dropped the first one and because I had the warranty MS replaced it but I still ran out and bought a new Z80. I love this thing! I'm the type of person that just does not like to have the same thing as everyone else so I've never owned and likely will never have an iPod.
#11 zivan56 on 02 Jan 2009 - 03:34
Also keep in mind, this device is over 3 years old...and hasn't had almost any issues since its debut. So people are just trying desperately to find a fault in it.
#12 JonathanMarston on 02 Jan 2009 - 09:06
Several of my friends' iPods died in less than 2 years of use. I'd say not being able to use my Zune for 1 day out of the 2 years I've had it is better than a dead device...
#13 Glen on 02 Jan 2009 - 20:06
I have to admit that I was really worried when this happened since I recommended Zune to several friends, but I'm glad it worked itself out and will be permanently fixed with a firmware update. Overall, I will continue to recommend the Zune for feature support (free feature upgrades) and ease of use. Not to mention the Zune software is still superior to iTunes. I'm just glad I waited it out and didn't attempt any of the "fixes" to reset the internal clock just to get frustrated later when the problem corrected itself.

If MS wants to give me a free song for my troubles, I think that would be a good PR move on their part.

Commenting has either been disabled on this article or you are not logged in. Click here to login or register, its free!

Note: Anonymous commenting is disabled in order to keep the quality of responses to a high standard.

Advertisement (Why?)