On Tuesday, internet provider Comcast announced it would be rolling out it's "Domain Helper" nationally, having trialled it before and reported great market success. The "Domain Helper" is aimed at assisting users who have mistyped website addresses by redirecting them to an "easy-to-use page with suggestions and links."That's how Comcast have described their latest service anyway. But what Comcast describe as a "Domain Helper" has been referred to as DNS hijacking by others. Like many ISPs, Comcast now redirects their customers to a search page, but what they didn't mention in their blog post were the adverts that are on the page too, leading some customers to be less than happy with the new service.
Whilst it is possible for customers to opt-out, many have suffered delays in having the service removed. Furthermore, many customers were unhappy that they were not asked to sign up to the service, and instead had it added without their permission. Whilst Comcast claims to have sent emails to all it's customers explaining about the service and what it does, some customers claimed they never received these emails.
Comcast have created a website so that their users can opt-out, but it is only accessible by users of the network.
DNS redirection isn't new, many other ISPs, including Bell, Verizon and Orange do the same, and OpenDNS have even utilized it to block malware sites. However, it appears that the issue customers are having is the fact that the service was an opt-out service, as opposed to an opt-in one.
If you are a Comcast customer and want to try and remove the service, you can go here. You can also check out how well customers reacted to the news on Comcast's blog.
















Less than pleasant phone calls will ensue...
/edit/ and for the record, Comcast has never notified me of changes to service via email... on the rare occasion that they tell me anything, it's in tiny light-gray text on the back of the bill they send me.
Same here.
They have bought out atleast 61% of the following companies so they are co-branded as to not violate Anti Monopoly laws.
Virging Mobile Canada (Virgin Bell Mobility), Telus (Bell Telus) Aliant (Bell Aliant) Rogers (New name unknown, Fido, Koodo, and The Source (Bell) Electronics.
They hostile-take-over'ed BarbadosTel, and have their eyes on MTS and AT&T WorldWide...aka: AT&T
They also changed their name from BCE [Bell Canada Enterprises] to BE [Bell Enterprises], marking they plan for future global domination. The CRTC website is your friend.
I posted this 2x times on /. when the articled about Bell doing DNS "helping", and neither was posted...i wonder why... also...hmm... Bell and Comcast decide to do exactly the same thing at the same time... me thinks some one else was just bought out....I say good day to you!
They have bought out atleast 61% of the following companies so they are co-branded as to not violate Anti Monopoly laws.
Virging Mobile Canada (Virgin Bell Mobility), Telus (Bell Telus) Aliant (Bell Aliant) Rogers (New name unknown, Fido, Koodo, and The Source (Bell) Electronics.
They hostile-take-over'ed BarbadosTel, and have their eyes on MTS and AT&T WorldWide...aka: AT&T
They also changed their name from BCE [Bell Canada Enterprises] to BE [Bell Enterprises], marking they plan for future global domination. The CRTC website is your friend.
I posted this 2x times on /. when the articled about Bell doing DNS "helping", and
neither was posted...i wonder why... also...hmm... Bell and Comcast decide to do exactly the same thing at the same time... me thinks some one else was just bought out....I say good day to you!
Erm, since when did Bell buy out Rogers?
Source, maybe?
Rogers' mobility and third party off-shoots were bought up a few months ago, and Rogers itself is on the radar.
Telus, in signing the agreement to sell "Bell TV" branded as (Telus TV) in Alberta entered them in to an agreement for buyout. A few people that I know are already getting co-branded mobility bills.
Again, the CRTC website is your friend, if you know where to look.
I am still trying to find the references, but I seen it in the middle of June on the CRTC website.
vvv As below, OpenDNS does the exact same thing.....
4.2.2.2
etc
or opendns... f*ck this redirection bull****
You can disable it just like you can with Comcast's service.
On a side note, I sure hope they will NEVER start redirecting dns from properly registered domain names, even for the sake of "protecting" people. Think about it for a minute, if you ISP is allowed to send you wherever he wants when you want to go to Neowin, maybe it'll just decide one day that this forum is defamatory and that it is in its own right to redirect requests to Neowin to bell.ca/support/ .
On a side note, I sure hope they will NEVER start redirecting dns from properly registered domain names, even for the sake of "protecting" people. Think about it for a minute, if you ISP is allowed to send you wherever he wants when you want to go to Neowin, maybe it'll just decide one day that this forum is defamatory and that it is in its own right to redirect requests to Neowin to bell.ca/support/ .
Oh I'm sure the day that my ISP decides to do THAT is the day I start speaking to their legal department and the FCC. On that note my provider has long since done a search redirect based on opt-out policy rather than opt-in so this is nothing new. I have used OpenDNS for a long time though.
Not only that but google has already registered the common "typo" names are automatically redirects you to google anyway.
Double flawed argument
Someone in their IT staff should be fired then...lol
Lol...
I found out about it from a non-tech blog that I read occasionally and opted-out immediately.
A little late on the draw for this one, but who the hell uses Comcast email? That's what gmail is for...
These types of things are NEVER made with the users in mind. They are purely to generate revenue. That, alone, should be enough to alarm you.
Good news is, if you had your DNS set manually (like I did) you will not have noticed the change because the Helper servers are new addresses.
Commenting has either been disabled on this article or you are not logged in. Click here to login or register, its free!
Note: Anonymous commenting is disabled in order to keep the quality of responses to a high standard.