Study: Facebook is depressing but Instagram maybe even more so

By now you might have heard and even felt that Facebook is truly depressing. And no we’re not referring to the reposted bad jokes, the weird stuff from brands you follow, the incessant ads, the friend requests from creepy unstable uncles etc. We’re referring to actual clinical depression due to the way you end up seeing yourself through the Facebook lens.

Researchers from Carnegie Mellon as well as other universities and research institutions have found that spending your day looking through other people’s pictures, especially holiday pictures and begrudgingly “liking” them can have a sometimes severe effect on the way you view yourself and your life and it can lead to depression and self-loathing.

But Jessica Winter, of Slate Magazine, took the conclusions of this research one step further. If looking at stranger’s holiday photos and liking them makes you feel bad about your own life, this research must surely apply even more so to Instagram, where viewing “fabulous” photos from strangers is all you do.

There’s little official research on what effects Instagram has on you but Hanna Krasnova of Humboldt University Berlin, co-author of the study on Facebook and envy said:

“You get more explicit and implicit cues of people being happy, rich, and successful from a photo than from a status update. A photo can very powerfully provoke immediate social comparison, and that can trigger feelings of inferiority. You don’t envy a news story.”

Krasnova talks about an “envy spiral” that can take place on any medium, including in casual day to day conversation, but it’s especially pronged to take place on Instagram. “If you see beautiful photos of your friend on Instagram,” she says, “one way to compensate is to self-present with even better photos, and then your friend sees your photos and posts even better photos, and so on. Self-promotion triggers more self-promotion, and the world on social media gets further and further from reality.”

This disconnect between what you see and the real world is where the damage happens, where the feelings of self-doubt and depression come in and where all the damage happens.

Of course you as a user can take from this research what you may, but if nothing else remember to log-off once in awhile.

Source: Slate | Three young friends taking picture via Shutterstock

Report a problem with article
Previous Story

Apple site hack done "in the name of research", complete overhaul inbound

Next Story

New Nexus 7 unveiled by Best Buy ahead of Google event

22 Comments

Commenting is disabled on this article.

People need to grow a pair. Depressed by people posting pretty vacation photos? Wow, just do something every once in a while instead of sitting like a loser in front of Facebook, then.

I agree. FB and Instagram people I read about are so much more outgoing than me....not. lol. It's all smoke and mirrors and self-obsessing do-nothing teens/20-somethings.

In contrast, I'm elated when I use Twitter and exchange ideas and information with people. I'm in a better mood there than with other socials.

Makes sense to me. FB can be a flame war of 1up-manship. I've seen it happen over and over. Instagram probably more so since it's purely visual and we're visual creatures if nothing else.

People just put too much info on FB... like a girl who posted a pic of her house and said she was going on holiday... when she returned home from the holiday and found her house robbed. Now she's definitely not happy. LOL

Most socialites are unhappy. When you are constantly updated on other people's lives, you are automatically taking in their problems also. I had co-worker log in to her Facebook and saw that her best friends kid fell and busted his head. She was sad for the rest of the day because of that. Me, I was like, "who the fck cares?" I don't need constant updates on everyone's life.

Her best friend's family is understandable as a source of concern. A stranger's son would be much less so.

Where it's an issue is where people end up soaking up everyone's worries - this is a problem with any form of news. We don't have the capacity to deal with everyone else's issues - and there is always somebody in difficult.

singularity87 said,
Her best friend's family is understandable as a source of concern. A stranger's son would be much less so.

Where it's an issue is where people end up soaking up everyone's worries - this is a problem with any form of news. We don't have the capacity to deal with everyone else's issues - and there is always somebody in difficult.

Agree

Raa said,
I feel happy that I don't use either!

I can dig that!!

Facebook has/had the potential to be a cool tool, but with the way it's used/abused, it's nothing more than stupid!

You're just not narcissistic enough, but don't sell yourself short! One day, you too could be a FacebookTwitterInstagram whore permanently tethered to your phone!