What Killed the Linux Desktop (by GNOME founder Miguel de Icaza)


Recommended Posts

vhane

The thing that I found really interesting is that de Icaza was essentially making a case that desktop Linux is developer hostile. I thought that was pretty damn ironic. After all, Linux is the poster boy of Open Source.

Link to post
Share on other sites
n_K

The thing about people saying 'you are doing it wrong' has 2 sides.

For example there's a project on github, and a lot of the issues reported with it are all covered in the manual that not many people seem to read, I used to post 'RTFM' in most of the issues but now there's so many of them that basically all say the same thing I just ignore them, and everyone else does too, so why are these people incapable of reading the documentation?

I'm not saying all problems that get the 'you are doing it wrong' line are examples of this, but at least a good 50% are.

Link to post
Share on other sites
+warwagon

I totally agree!!! I've been saying this forever!!

We have to many damn Linux Distributions! Sure at the end of the day it gives the users TONS of choices to choose from, but there is no fracking standard. Some use X package manager while others use Y package manager. Then one users Y Desktop Manger while another uses X desktop manger.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
f0rk_b0mb

I totally agree!!! I've been saying this forever!!

We have to many damn Linux Distribution. Sure at the end of the day it gives the users TONS of choices to choose from, but there is no fracking standard. Some use X package manager while others use Y package manager.

Yup. Instead of having a million half-baked things, we should have 5 or 6 good solid programs.

  • Like 4
Link to post
Share on other sites
Routerbad

? Clearly you do not have a conceptual understanding for the richness of functionality and potential Linux holds. Using linux isn't painful, if you know what works and what doesn't, you should just get on fine. If you using linux to run a bunch of stuff in wine and then want to complain "ahh linux sucks, its all backwards" then fine. Just don't come here bashing something which you associate success with market share. Linux isn't a business model, its community isn't centred on pleasing customers, rather its loyal users and contributors. Had a bad experience? Suck it up, find out what went wrong and try to find a community fix or article on it. get on with life. Don't moan and cry about it calling linux users "only the masochists stuck with it."

Some of us have responsibilities beyond sitting at home, at our desks, away from our families, trying to figure out how to make something work. The last couple of times I tried linux distros I felt that most of what I wanted to get done worked without too much manual intervention, and I love CLI so I had no problem with doing it, but 99.99999% of potential users won't go through the hassle, and that's just what it is, even for 'power users'. I don't want to feel like I'm in a boxing match with my conputer to get something done. I just want to log in and work/play/browse, etc.

  • Like 5
Link to post
Share on other sites
threetonesun

The real thing that killed it is this: what program runs on Linux that is better than all other similar programs for OSX or Windows?

Personally, it's none. Many are ok, there are a few standouts (I run Inkscape in OSX), but there's nothing I would dedicate a boot drive or VM Linux for.

But, again, that's the exclusivity no one in Linux land wants. If, say, Steam only ran on Ubuntu, and there was a big push to make Ubuntu a desktop contender, a chunk of the Linux community still wouldn't support it.

Link to post
Share on other sites
n_K

"The real thing that killed it is this: what program runs on Linux that is better than all other similar programs for OSX or Windows?"

For desktop users? Not much, open-gl is smoother, faster and less laggy than direct-3D.

For server users? Mostly everything is better on *nix.

Link to post
Share on other sites
threetonesun

"The real thing that killed it is this: what program runs on Linux that is better than all other similar programs for OSX or Windows?"

For desktop users? Not much, open-gl is smoother, faster and less laggy than direct-3D.

For server users? Mostly everything is better on *nix.

Open gl runs everywhere, though. And, although I'm not super familiar with the server side, my impression was that Linux is good + cheap, not necessarily better.

Link to post
Share on other sites
ichi

Yup. Instead of having a million half-baked things, we should have 5 or 6 good solid programs.

I don't think the theory about "focus all development resources on fewer alternatives" is actually realistic.

Gnome devs work on Gnome because that's what they want to do. If Gnome didn't exist they wouldn't magically become KDE devs.

Same for most other duplicate projects.

Also lots of those projects aren't even truly Linux specific, so devs don't even care about any kind of unification.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Cocoliso

My problem with Linux desktop is lack of games and big software titles such as Adobe, Autodesk, etc. I repeat again it does not suit my needs for the work I do yet or the entrainment that I want. But others might have different needs so it's just my opinion.

But on the server side I take Linux without thinking twice.

Link to post
Share on other sites
chrisj1968

Does it cost alot for manufacturers to create say.. games on windows? I was once told that alot of game developers create their games on linux based systems and create them for windows.

Funny how something that's free doesn't go over more well. I thought everyone liked FREE

Link to post
Share on other sites
ArialBlue

Well I didn't know that Photoshop from 2001 still runs on W8.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Duffydemon

For desktop users? Not much, open-gl is smoother, faster and less laggy than direct-3D.

Oh please, opengl is a headache, Specially if you are a developer than opengl is nightmare. Right now i am working at a gaming studio and i am tired of hearing developers complaining about it. Coming from a guy who use blender on ubuntu everyday.

comparable in performance - Yes

Superior - hell no!

Link to post
Share on other sites
Joshie

"When faced with "this does not work", the community response was usually "you are doing it wrong"."

That is the biggest problem with Linux.

And when faced with "well what's the right way to do it?", the community response was usually "RTFM n00b".

And when faced with any kind of criticism whatsoever, the community response was universal butthurt and going to extreme lengths to justify any shortcoming, and spin it into something done on purpose, for a good reason, and if you understood that you'd already like it.

Link to post
Share on other sites
simplezz

Oh please, opengl is a headache, Specially if you are a developer than opengl is nightmare. Right now i am working at a gaming studio and i am tired of hearing developers complaining about it. Coming from a guy who use blender on ubuntu everyday.

I'd take a clean C API over a Microsoft COM API any day of the week. I've programmed in both, and I'll never use COM/Direct3D ever again. Then there's the portability issue, which for me is critical.

comparable in performance - Yes

Superior - hell no!

If the Doom3/L4D2 benchmarks are anything to go by, then yes, GNU/Linux and OpenGL are superior in performance when a game is properly optimised like the Windows version.

Link to post
Share on other sites
HawkMan

"The real thing that killed it is this: what program runs on Linux that is better than all other similar programs for OSX or Windows?"

For desktop users? Not much, open-gl is smoother, faster and less laggy than direct-3D.

For server users? Mostly everything is better on *nix.

Hehe, funny. So we know two things about you, you don't game or run any serious 3d editing software. You're also not a server admin, at best you might run a web server from your basement home.

And your concept of "best tool for the job" is if it isn't Linux I haven't tried it because it sucks.

Regarding the question: "What killed the Linux desktop" - I say nothing

That's as far as you where correct. The correct continuation to that is

Nothing killed desktop Linux. You can't kill something that never existed.

If the Doom3/L4D2 benchmarks are anything to go by, then yes, GNU/Linux and OpenGL are superior in performance when a game is properly optimised like the Windows version.

Call me when that supposed superior L4D2 linux openGL version is something we can actually run and see for ourselves. And not just as statement from a very full of himself Gabe with a self made axe to grind with MS

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
n_K

Hehe, funny. So we know two things about you, you don't game or run any serious 3d editing software. You're also not a server admin, at best you might run a web server from your basement home.

And your concept of "best tool for the job" is if it isn't Linux I haven't tried it because it sucks.

Got brain damage or something?

Facebook, the BIGGEST and MOST POPULAR social network system runs on linux server (centOS and fedora mainly), using their own php compiler which they made, it doesn't work on windows at all and has a lot of bugs on freebsd and mac. So now you've already massively failed once, let's move to google, once again probably using a linux OS (google appliances are centOS), so the biggest social network site in the world followed by the biggest search engine in the world both use linux...

Oh and then there's twitter, which again, uses linux! Wow, you've failed 3 times in a row. Neowin also uses linux.

Let's look at some large-scale websites that use microsoft hosting... There's bing, pretty big but not the biggest. There's microsoft's sites, oh and ironically, skype servers are linux-based too. 4 fails? And remember, MS uses wordpress which is NOT asp.net or asp based, and is PHP. Going for 6 now...

Oh and there's faceparty, the laggy outdated website that stores all passwords in clear-text and emails them out to people... Yeah, wow, certainly looks like all the best servers and websites in the world... Oh that's right, use GNU/linux.

Serious 3D editing? Maya 3D and 3DSM both have linux programs for using as render farms, you know, pixar the company that's owned a lot by mac runs it's server farms on linux right? OH, SIX! YOU MADE IT!

And games I play run fine in linux using wine (D2, torchlight, terraria, RA2) or don't need wine at all (minecraft, openRA, commander zod, zsnes).

So, want to majorly fail again? Go on, post something else that's hilarious!

And your concept of "best tool for the job" is if it isn't Linux I haven't tried it because it sucks.

Now you must be stupid. I've got a server 03 VM and it's my main server that I do most things on, it's suited for it's job, performance wise apache on windows is slower than apache or nginx on linux though. Or maybe you want to go to say the nginx forums/documentation and double check that before posting more incorrect tosh?

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
HawkMan

Om my god, one site runs a web server that's Linux. So obviously

NX is the best server for everything and you didn't at all fail to understand the point of my post... :rolleyes:

Sorry, come back when you grow up and know what you're talking about.

Did I say windows server where bst for web servers? No I didn't. Is Linux however always the best choice for a web server ? No.

By the way, while bragging about those sites, look up the performance increase curse had when they switched to windows based servers. Either way my point wasn't about web servers at all. But your response clearly show your maturity level and that my assessment was correct. So no I didn't fail you did. Face first.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
n_K

Web servers? I didn't realise facebook, google, twitter, etc are only web servers.

Oh wait, they aren't.

'So obviously NX is the best server for everything and you didn't at all fail to understand the point of my post... :rolleyes:'

'I've got a server 03 VM and it's my main server that I do most things on, it's suited for it's job'

Are you being stupid on purpose?

And my maturity level? Haha, right, ok good luck with life.

Link to post
Share on other sites
simplezz

Om my god, one site runs a web server that's Linux. So obviously

NX is the best server for everything and you didn't at all fail to understand the point of my post... :rolleyes:

The whole internet runs on GNU/Linux and other *nix like OS's. What cave have you been living in for the past 20 years :omg:

Did I say windows server where bst for web servers? No I didn't. Is Linux however always the best choice for a web server ? No.

Every significant web site that I know of runs on *nix. Even some of Microsoft's own sites in the past have run Linux.

By the way, while bragging about those sites, look up the performance increase curse had when they switched to windows based servers. Either way my point wasn't about web servers at all. But your response clearly show your maturity level and that my assessment was correct. So no I didn't fail you did. Face first.

Windows servers have greater down time and are subject to virus and malware infections like their desktop brethren.

Link to post
Share on other sites
n_K

Anyway this threads offtopic, talking about servers and not desktops.

My opinion of GNOME2 is it was brilliant in all respects, GNOME3 came out and the initial version was awful. I still refuse to use the gnome-shell and have it in forced fallback mode and removed gnome-shell, what annoys me is that without gnome-shell, you can't use gnome-tweak-tool. Plus they really dumbed down GNOME3 like the ability to change volume steps, WHY!? And then there was the fact the screensaver is just blank and originally couldn't be turned off by any other programs but since GNOME3.3 there's a fade to black when the screensaver starts now so if you move the mouse before it completely fades, it won't lock -> Brilliant feature! Plus applications like VLC, flash and zsnesx can now stop the screensaver from activating.

I still prefer GNOME2 over GNOME3.3, and unfortunately with the way GNOME4 seems to be going (touch screen only interface) I don't think I'll be sticking with it much longer.

The pain in the arse though is that applications use GTK or QT or other, and you've got the have large QT3/4 and or GTK2/3 libraries installed, so moving to other window managers isn't all that easy.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Max Norris
Windows servers have greater down time and are subject to virus and malware infections like their desktop brethren.

I've been trying to avoid this whole inane ****ing contest, but had to comment on this one. We're not going to pretend that Linux based servers don't have malware or security issues again are we? Do we really need to go into which platform gets the most hacked servers? (It's not Windows...) And Linux servers aren't immune to malware either. How long was kernel.org down due to a rootkit again? Yes, there's a much larger base of Linux based servers versus Windows powering web sites. But please at least keep it honest, never mind completely having nothing to do with the topic at hand to begin with.. Linux on the desktop.

And remember, MS uses wordpress which is NOT asp.net or asp based, and is PHP. Going for 6 now...

Erm there's multiple Windows based servers that can run PHP. Including Apache.

  • Like 3
Link to post
Share on other sites
Growled

The Linux desktop is not dead by a long shot.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Namerah S
      How to enable the dark theme on Facebook desktop
      by Namerah Saud Fatmi

      Social media giant Facebook released dark mode for the desktop and iOS platforms in March last year. Even though testing of the Android version of the dark theme began earlier, general availability came out after the desktop and iOS versions.

      We have already done a tutorial to turn on dark mode on Android. Today's guide will walk you through the steps of toggling the desktop version of dark mode. Follow the below instructions to say hello to the dark side of Facebook on PCs.

      Step 1: Visit Facebook on your PC's web browser. Once open, locate the small arrow pointing downwards on the upper left corner of the dashboard and click on it.

      Step 2: After clicking on the little downwards-pointing arrow, a dropdown menu will pop up. Select the "Display & accessibility" option.

      Step 3: Clicking on the "Display & accessibility" option will take you to the dark mode feature. Simply click "on" to enable it.

      Here are some before and after screenshots to showcase the differences in theme on Facebook's desktop dark mode:

      With that, we conclude this short and easy tutorial to toggle the dark mode on Facebook on desktops. Happy browsing!

    • By News Staff
      Practical Linux Security Cookbook - Second Edition ($35.99 Value) Free Download
      by Steven Parker

      Claim your complimentary eBook (worth $35.99) for free, before the offer expires on 03/03.



      Over the last few years, system security has gained a lot of momentum and software professionals are focusing heavily on it.



      Linux is often treated as a highly secure operating system. However, the reality is that Linux has its share of security aws, and these security aws allow attackers to get into your system and modify or even destroy your important data. But there’s no need to panic, since there are various mechanisms by which these aws can be removed, and this book will help you learn about different types of Linux security to create a more secure Linux system.

      With a step-by-step recipe approach, the book starts by introducing you to various threats to Linux systems. Then, this book will walk you through customizing the Linux kernel and securing local files. Next, you will move on to managing user authentication both locally and remotely and mitigating network attacks. Later, you will learn about application security and kernel vulnerabilities. You will also learn about patching Bash vulnerability, packet filtering, handling incidents, and monitoring system logs. Finally, you will learn about auditing using system services and performing vulnerability scanning on Linux.

      By the end of this book, you will be able to secure your Linux systems and create a robust environment.

      This free offer expires on March 3.

      How to get it
      Please ensure you read the terms and conditions to claim this offer. Complete and verifiable information is required in order to receive this free offer. If you have previously made use of these free offers, you will not need to re-register. While supplies last!

      >> Practical Linux Security Cookbook - Second Edition ($35.99 Value) - free download <<
      Offered by Packt Publishing, view their other free resources. Expires 03/03/21.

      Not for you?
      That's OK, there are other deals on offer you can check out here.



      Home Gym Giveaway | Ultimate Gaming Giveaway (feat. PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X) Ivacy VPN - 5 year subscription for just $1 per month NordVPN - 2 year subscription at up to 68% off Private Internet Access VPN - subscriptions at up to 71% off Unlocator VPN or SmartDNS - unblock Geoblock with 7-day free trial Neowin Store for our preferred partners. Subscribe to Neowin - for $14 a year, or $28 a year for Ad-Free experience Disable Sponsored posts · Neowin Deals · Free eBooks · Neowin Store

      Disclosure: This is a StackCommerce deal or giveaway in partnership with Neowin; an account at StackCommerce is required to participate in any deals or giveaways. For a full description of StackCommerce's privacy guidelines, go here. Neowin benefits from shared revenue of each sale made through our branded deals site, and it all goes toward the running costs.

    • By Abhay V
      Google rolling out dark theme for Search on the desktop for some users
      by Abhay Venkatesh



      Google seems to be rolling out a new dark mode for Search on the desktop for some users. A new pop-up message suggesting that “Dark theme is now available has begun showing up for people, based on user posts on Twitter, which was corroborated by folks over at 9to5Google as well. The feature seems to also be showing up for users when accessing Google Search from the desktop in Incognito mode.

      The prompt reportedly redirects users to a setting that lets them choose between light, dark, or system theme. This means that the search engine will adapt to the system theme settings on Windows and macOS, making it a much more streamlined option for those that prefer to switch between themes regularly. However, it is not clear if the rollout is part of an A/B test or an actual staggered release since the feature supposedly gets disabled for some users after a page refresh or when users navigate to image search.

      This isn’t the first time that users have been able to spot dark mode for Search on the web. Back in May last year, the company was testing the theming option on mobile browsers via a hidden flag. Early this year, there were reports of a randomized test with an experience similar to what users are reporting today.

      As for the theming option itself, the company is keeping the experience in line with its mobile apps, which means that the UI adapts a dark grey background color with white text. From the screenshots posted by users, it does not look like there are too many rough edges, although, the theme is applicable only to a few pages.

      The addition of a dark theme for Search on the web will be a welcome addition for those that prefer the theming option, especially when working in dimly lit environments. It will be interesting to see if the Mountain View company expands the rollout of the feature soon or if this is another toe dip in the water to gauge reception from users.

    • By zikalify
      Debian 10.8 launches with new software patches and updates
      by Paul Hill

      Image via Alex Makas The Debian Project has announced the availability of Debian 10.8, the eighth update to its stable distribution Debian 10. Each time a point release is made available, a new ISO is spun with all the latest security fixes and software updates so that they do not need to be installed when Debian is installed on a new system.

      Some packages that have received updates with Debian 10.8 include Firefox ESR, Chromium, Flatpak, VLC, the Linux kernel, OpenSSL, X.Org, APT and Thunderbird. The NVIDIA graphics drivers have also been updated to a newer upstream version that fixes a denial of service issue.

      Appealing to users to think about the environment, the Debian Project said:

      Debian 10 was first launched on July 6, 2019, and it’s set to receive long-term support until 2024. Each new version of Debian arrives every two years but launch dates are not set in stone. If there aren’t any delays, Debian 11 should come out this year and Debian 10 will be demoted to the status of Old Stable alongside Debian 9 which is maintained by the main Debian security team until July 18, 2020.

    • By zikalify
      Canonical releases second point release of Ubuntu 20.04 LTS
      by Paul Hill



      Canonical has announced the availability of Ubuntu 20.04.2 LTS – the second point release for Ubuntu 20.04 LTS. As with other point releases, Canonical has spun a new ISO that includes all the security and software updates and it comes with the latest hardware enablement stacks so that newer hardware works properly.

      Ubuntu 20.04.2 LTS is available for the Desktop, Server, and Cloud products as well as other flavours of Ubuntu such as Kubuntu, Ubuntu Budgie, Ubuntu MATE, Lubuntu, Ubuntu Kylin, Ubuntu Studio, and Xubuntu. If you want to download any of the Ubuntu products or the spins, head over to the Ubuntu downloads page and find what you want.

      According to the Ubuntu 20.04 release notes page, Ubuntu 20.04.2 LTS ships with the Linux 5.8 kernel instead of Linux 5.4 which was the original kernel shipped last April when Focal Fossa came out. Those installing Ubuntu Server will have to opt-in to using the new kernel through the installer bootloader as it’s not the default choice.

      As with all Ubuntu LTS releases, you should expect security and software updates for five years until the first half of 2025. The derivative flavours are an exception, however, receiving support for just three years.