William Shatner questions Reddit's permissive culture


Recommended Posts

+Frank B.

William Shatner questions Reddit's permissive culture, suggests 'downvoting' won't deter hate

Some celebrities leave Reddit shortly after they collect easy publicity, but Star Trek'sWilliam Shatner isn't afraid to stick around and ruffle some feathers. An active user on the site since his first "Ask Me Anything" session in January, Shatner has issued some stern comments about the site's tolerance of hateful or racist users, writing that he is "appalled by some of the immature, horrifically racist, sexist, homophobic, ethnic, etc... posts that are just ignored here." Shatner questions Reddit's hands-off approach, writing that "the fact that someone could come here, debase and degrade people based on race, religion, ethnicity or sexual preference because 'they have a right' to do so without worry of any kind of moderation is sending the wrong message."

That attitude may seem to fly in the face of free speech ? a value Reddit (mostly) supports ? but Shatner's unimpressed when it comes to hate speech. In response to a comment goading him to become president of the United States ("because apparently you know best," the commenter wrote), Shatner replied: "first of all, I'm Canadian. Second of all Reddit is worldwide. So 'First Amendment' means nothing online."

While it's not the first time Reddit's model has been criticized, Shatner's comments highlight the site's ongoing struggle to gain mainstream credibility while embracing offensive or undesirable content. Shatner wrote that "Reddit has been the first 'mainstream' site that I have been to that actually appears to allow racists and other hate mongers to group, congregate, incite and spread their hatred." While some users noted Reddit's voting system, which allows users to promote or suppress content to their liking, Shatner was unconvinced about its efficacy: "you obviously agree with me that there are 'shameful comments' on Reddit that users can downvote and hide," he writes in a response to another user, "but they are still here at the end of the day as are the accounts that make them. Do you believe that the folks who don these cyber masks to post hatred will stop making them because they get downvoted?"

Reddit only has a few official rules, including no spam, no personal information, no cheating the system, and no suggestive or sexual content featuring minors. The site has a much broader set of values, called Reddiquette, that consists of suggestions about how to behave -- but it's completely up to individual community moderators to create and enforce rules. Shatner, perhaps like many others who stumble on the site, doesn't seem to appreciate the difference between Reddiquette and the community's official rules. "All I am asking is why there are rules if they are not enforced," Shatner writes. "If censoring or disabling accounts is not an outcome of breaking the rules, then what exactly is?" (Of course, users do get banned from the site and from individual subreddits, but those decisions are often left to volunteer community moderators with nearly-unlimited power.) "I do not pretend to know where the managers of Reddit wish to go with this site," Shatner writes, "but embracing that kind of culture I feel is counterproductive to where this world is heading."

As a member of polite society, Shatner may not fully understand the people he's dealing with -- but that doesn't mean he can't change hearts and minds. The "ShitRedditSays" (SRS) community ? one of the site's most controversial subreddits, often providing a running satirical commentary on Reddit's culture ? honored Shatner by placing his face on its banner. In response, Shatner asked a Reddit user to act as a digital courier: "could I ask that you send a message over to whomever runs SRS? I would like the banner removed. I do not feel it's appropriate and I am not a member there." The banner was removed shortly after Shatner's request.

Source: The Verge

Link to post
Share on other sites
n_K

I'm part of a site with little in terms of rules, yeah some prats join but the majority of people on it are fine and keep it fine as is.

Out of all the hateful comments on sites, only a handful are genuine twits, the rest are all trolls or people looking for a reaction.

Link to post
Share on other sites
theyarecomingforyou

I completely understand where he's coming from and?even though I frequently visit Reddit?I think he's right. Free speech should be protected until it infringes upon the rights of others. Racism, sexism, bigotry and other forms of hate speech should be shunned by society, not embraced under the guise of free speech. The upvote/downvote system only goes so far. The very fact that Reddit has rules - like prohibiting the posting of personal information - shows that it's not truly committed to free speech; it's being done to maintain the site's popularity. It's very similar to YouTube's incredibly relaxed rules on copyright infringement in the early days or MegaUpload's refusal to take down pirated content - it's a calculated decision in order to help the site grow.

Link to post
Share on other sites
torrentthief

people who are offended by the opinions of others should go and live in a cave, they won't be offended by anyone then.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
TheLegendOfMart

There is a line and Reddit has crossed it, I am using the site less and less now as people seem to be posting disgusting pictures in the comments, such as decapitated pigs, children with diseases that has open sores, pics of near decapitations with chainsaws.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Chasethebase

There is a line and Reddit has crossed it, I am using the site less and less now as people seem to be posting disgusting pictures in the comments, such as decapitated pigs, children with diseases that has open sores, pics of near decapitations with chainsaws.

Dude what subs are you a part of, /r/gore? I don't see any of that.

Link to post
Share on other sites
+Xinok

You Can't Please Everyone TM

Link to post
Share on other sites
TheLegendOfMart

Dude what subs are you a part of, /r/gore? I don't see any of that.

Hell no, I am very squeemish I ventured into spaced***s out of curiosity and promptly lost the contents of my stomach.

People are posting pictures in the comments of front page articles, they seem to deal with it relatively quickly but there should be no chance of people posting things like that especially subreddits dedicated to such pics.

It wasn't so long ago they had borderline childporn subreddits (not that I looked of course, it was in the news) and they were forced to remove them.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Steven P.

You Can't Please Everyone TM

It's a shame that people will still accuse sites like mine for being overly unfriendly when I know for a fact that a large percentage of it never gets seen by our active readership due to the awesome moderating team that we have. We try to make this a nice place to read through, but as Shatner points out, online anonymity makes it easy for people to act like ######, when they probably wouldn't dare it in a real life social setting. And if they dared it, then they aren't the types you want around you anyway.

  • Like 9
Link to post
Share on other sites
mudslag

I completely understand where he's coming from and?even though I frequently visit Reddit?I think he's right. Free speech should be protected until it infringes upon the rights of others. Racism, sexism, bigotry and other forms of hate speech should be shunned by society, not embraced under the guise of free speech. The upvote/downvote system only goes so far. The very fact that Reddit has rules - like prohibiting the posting of personal information - shows that it's not truly committed to free speech; it's being done to maintain the site's popularity. It's very similar to YouTube's incredibly relaxed rules on copyright infringement in the early days or MegaUpload's refusal to take down pirated content - it's a calculated decision in order to help the site grow.

There is a huge difference between someone posting someone elses personal information and someone taking "personal" offense to what is said. Posting personal information violates a person's right to privacy, that has nothing to do with free speech. Let's also not forget the FACT that "free speech" is a Right of protection from gov action, not private, to which Reddit is a part of.

Link to post
Share on other sites
theyarecomingforyou
There is a huge difference between someone posting someone elses personal information and someone taking "personal" offense to what is said. Posting personal information violates a person's right to privacy, that has nothing to do with free speech. Let's also not forget the FACT that "free speech" is a Right of protection from gov action, not private, to which Reddit is a part of.

This isn't about taking personal offence to comments - we're talking about extreme racism, sexism, bigotry, hate speech, invasion of privacy and threats. Many countries have laws against that sort of behaviour, whether it's defined as hate speech or covered under harassment or assault legislation. It's interesting that you believe people have an inalienable right to privacy but that everything else is fair game.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Knife Party

head to a specific subreddit, problem solved. the type of subreddit will dictate the type of lurker and user - aka, I hang out alot in the linux/webupd8/LAS/dota/purge/ subreddit, and the level of conversations are mature and insightful, no one is rude or a fanboy, people talk about what got shared, period. Reddit is a simple case of pick ya poison, don't have over realistic expectations all subreddit, some just attract the weirder and ruder people than most

Link to post
Share on other sites
nw2001

head to a specific subreddit, problem solved. the type of subreddit will dictate the type of lurker and user - aka, I hang out alot in the linux/webupd8/LAS/dota/purge/ subreddit, and the level of conversations are mature and insightful, no one is rude or a fanboy, people talk about what got shared, period. Reddit is a simple case of pick ya poison, don't have over realistic expectations all subreddit, some just attract the weirder and ruder people than most

It's basically this.

Each subreddit is a clique, you hang out with certain cliques because they suit your fancy, Now each clique is self moderated because the site is basically way too big to moderate at a decent pace.

So what you get is mods who don't care if you act like a bigot. Now whether you like it or not, if you don't want to see such things, don't hang out with bigots. or if you do want to, Don't be offended by the rambling of a bunch of losers anyways.

edit:typo

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
mudslag

This isn't about taking personal offence to comments - we're talking about extreme racism, sexism, bigotry, hate speech, invasion of privacy and threats. Many countries have laws against that sort of behaviour, whether it's defined as hate speech or covered under harassment or assault legislation. It's interesting that you believe people have an inalienable right to privacy but that everything else is fair game.

Those extreme comments are meant to offend, so yes we are talking about personal offense. Being offended is a personal issue and those comments ONLY have power when it's taken offensively. Ignoring people who make offensive statements is the most productive way to counter such people. Yes some countries have laws against such ways but we're talking about an Internet site, a vastly different aspect. And yes I do believe someone's privacy trumps being personally offended. You don't have a Right to NOT be offended.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Ph1b3r0pt1c

head to a specific subreddit, problem solved. the type of subreddit will dictate the type of lurker and user - aka, I hang out alot in the linux/webupd8/LAS/dota/purge/ subreddit, and the level of conversations are mature and insightful, no one is rude or a fanboy, people talk about what got shared, period. Reddit is a simple case of pick ya poison, don't have over realistic expectations all subreddit, some just attract the weirder and ruder people than most

The best one on reddit has to be

http://www.reddit.com/r/MURICA/

Link to post
Share on other sites
mudslag

There is a line and Reddit has crossed it, I am using the site less and less now as people seem to be posting disgusting pictures in the comments, such as decapitated pigs, children with diseases that has open sores, pics of near decapitations with chainsaws.

Reddit enhancement, block that stuff. Problem solved.

Link to post
Share on other sites
+Eternal Tempest

What make's reddit so popular is a) anonymity b) almost no rules (varies on subreddit). c) mob rule

This means there's a lot of useless junk, however there are amazing gems of great stuff, personal life experience, informative useful information.

The FrontPage shows a mix of hot topics across multiple subreddits, so when a person links from a web page, what most people don't realize there not one culture of reddit, subreddit's can have very different culture's and it's own rules different from each other.

Example, just compare /Askscience vs /Aww (cute animal pics) vs /Gonewild (Adults Only).

Any of the political and religious based subreddit's are walking in to a lions den.

One of my personal subreddit communites is /Abaondedpron which has zero porn, it's just urban exploration / abandoned buildings pics.

Link to post
Share on other sites
theyarecomingforyou
Those extreme comments are meant to offend, so yes we are talking about personal offense. Being offended is a personal issue and those comments ONLY have power when it's taken offensively. Ignoring people who make offensive statements is the most productive way to counter such people. Yes some countries have laws against such ways but we're talking about an Internet site, a vastly different aspect. And yes I do believe someone's privacy trumps being personally offended. You don't have a Right to NOT be offended.

Harassment, intimidation, incitement and assault (non-physical) are not the result of people simply being "offended" and you very well know that.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Skin

Here's the bottom line. Sites like reddit provide a place where you can be 'yourself'.

When you have your real name on something, you act 'correct', and as society tells us, you have to accept EVERYTHING to be 'correct', therefore, in most social circles, people act this way to not ruffle feathers.

In private on reddit for example, people care free to be themselves deep down, which is racist, homophobic, super religious or super atheist, etc.

Why does this shock anyone? People are inherently evil, and when there is no spotlight on them as a real person, they do what they want.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
mudslag

Harassment, intimidation, incitement and assault (non-physical) are not the result of people simply being "offended" and you very well know that.

That depends entirely on each situation. An anonymous post on the net of someone saying racial or intentionally insultive words isn't the same as a personal letter or directed post to you threatening your life.

Link to post
Share on other sites
theyarecomingforyou

That depends entirely on each situation. An anonymous post on the net of someone saying racial or intentionally insultive words isn't the same as a personal letter or directed post to you threatening your life.

Nor did I claim it was.

Link to post
Share on other sites
n_K

One of my personal subreddit communites is /Abaondedpron which has zero porn, it's just urban exploration / abandoned buildings pics.

LEGEND! Just bookmarked that!

Link to post
Share on other sites
Dashel

Disagree on all counts, maybe Neowin would be more to his liking?

Link to post
Share on other sites
shakey

There is a reason I don't even bother to view comments left on Reddit. I look at the posted material, but not comments. I used to read the comments, but it's quite easily seen that most people are just jackasses and it's a waste of time.

The only time I do read comments, are on gaming posting where I'm trying to get more information about something. But I couldn't care less about what people think about 99% of any articles, videos, or images posted.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Abhay V
      Some Apple Watch SE users in South Korea are reporting overheating issues
      by Abhay Venkatesh

      A new post on Reddit has collated a few users' reports from South Korea about the latest Apple Watch SE overheating and causing impressions on users’ hands. The post lists six cases where the device – all 40mm variants of both the GPS and LTE models – overheats during or after charging.

      Most users report that the watch became too hot after being charged and worn on the wrist. Some images of users’ wrist show off marks left by the watch, on the skin. In other cases, the device itself exhibits a bright, burnt spot on the display, suggesting that the heat is intensive enough to have caused a mark on the display from the bottom. The position of the burn is similar in all the images.

      Images collated from u/cozyplanes (Reddit post) It is not clear how widespread the issue is. Some responses on Reddit suggest that users have experienced other problems with Apple’s latest offering in North America that has resulted in them claiming replacement devices. It is also not known if the problems have to do with the battery. Since there are no teardowns of the smartwatch on the web, it is difficult to guess how similar the Watch SE is in design internally to the previous generations, and if any re-used parts are to blame.

      It will be interesting to see if more reports emerge in the coming days and if the Cupertino giant provides a statement about these reports. While it could just be a batch of faulty devices, the risks posed by these issues warrant some form of response from Apple.

      Source: u/cozyplanes (Reddit)

    • By Abhay V
      Samsung Galaxy S20 FE users begin reporting problems with the device's touchscreen
      by Abhay Venkatesh

      Samsung’s latest upper mid-range offering, the Galaxy S20 FE, packs impressive internals for a $699 price tag. However, reviewers and early adopters have begun reporting some touchscreen problems with the device. Reports on Reddit and Samsung Community Forums have been piling up with complaints of unresponsive touchscreens and phantom swipes, making the device difficult to use.

      Some users are experiencing problems with the ‘Pocket mode’ or accidental touch protection pop up even when the device is not in the pocket or the screens are not in proximity of other objects, in turn leading the phone to disable the touchscreen to avoid accidental touches. Other users, however, report problems including unintended touch registrations, unresponsive screens, and lag in response.

      Another user posted a detailed touch screen test on Reddit, comparing the touch responses to the Note10, noting that the S20 FE faced trouble responding to two-finger gestures like pinch and zoom. It is not clear if the issues faced by users is caused by a hardware/manufacturing defect or if the problems can be solved via software. A few users on Samsung’s forums claim that the firmware version ending with “ATIG” solved the problems, but the responses suggest that it is hit and miss.

      Folks over at 9to5Google and SamMobile both seem to have experienced this issue on their devices. Considering the increasing number of reports, it looks like the issue may be widespread, despite the South Korean giant claiming otherwise in a conversation with 9to5Google.

      Have you faced any touchscreen issues with your Galaxy S20 FE? Let us know in the comments below!

    • By News Staff
      5 Practical React Projects - free eBook download
      by Steven Parker

      Claim your complimentary copy for free, before the offer expires.



      What's it about?


      In-depth tutorials that will guide you through some fun and practical projects.

      Progress your React skills by building a Reddit clone with React and Firebase, a CRUD app with React, Redux and FeatherJS, a ToDo app with React, Redux and Immutable.js, a game with Three.js, React and WebGL, and a procedurally generated game terrain with React, PHP and WebSockets.

      How to get it
      Please ensure you read the terms and conditions to claim this offer. Complete and verifiable information is required in order to receive this free offer. If you have previously made use of these free offers, you will not need to re-register. While supplies last!

      >> 5 Practical React Projects - free eBook download <<
      Offered by SitePoint, view their other free resources. Limited time offer.

      Not for you?
      That's OK, there are other free eBooks on offer you can check out here, but be aware that these are all time-limited offers. If you are uncomfortable sharing your details with a third-party sponsor, we understand. Or via our preferred partner:

      How can I disable these posts? Click here.

      Disclosure: A valid email address is required to fulfill your request. Complete and verifiable information is required in order to receive this offer. By submitting a request, your information is subject to TradePub.com's Privacy Policy.

    • By Abhay V
      Multiple subreddits hacked in coordinated attack on Reddit, pro-Trump messages posted
      by Abhay Venkatesh



      Multiple Reddit subreddits have been compromised by hackers that are posting messages and images promoting U.S. President Donald Trump’s re-election. A post by Reddit Admin details the attacks, noting that the incident involves the compromise of moderator accounts. The firm is working to lock down accounts of bad actors and “reverting the changes”, and is also investigating the breach.

      The post also provides moderators and users a few steps to ascertain if their accounts have been compromised. It suggests that affected users note the names of their accounts in the stickied comment on that post. It also suggests that users who were removed as moderators “sit tight” as the service will be adding them back soon. However, securing the accounts will be the priority at first. Additionally, the firm reassures users that it has dedicated methods to detect compromised entities.

      Image: r/japan (Reddit) Here are the signs that users are being asked to look for to ascertain if their accounts were affected:

      Another important step that the post requests users to do is to enable two-factor authentication (2FA). The firm confirms that all accounts that were impacted did not have 2FA enabled, which made it easier for hackers to get through. The attacks apparently began about 24 hours ago and include subreddits such as r/japan, r/avengers, and more.

      Currently, not all affected users will be able to tell that their accounts have been actioned on. “The best way to tell if we're already working on your subreddit is to look for admin actions in your modlog.”, the post adds. It is also asking all users to change their passwords if they are concerned about their accounts. Some affected accounts posted screenshots of their account logs.

      Image credit: BleepingComputer BleepingComputer reports that a hacked Twitter account claimed responsibility for the coordinated attack on Reddit. The bad actors also reportedly tweeted subreddits that they intended to hack. The tweets also noted that the moderators’ passwords were weak and “easy to take over”. The account has since been suspended by Twitter.

      Reddit says that once it has dealt with the situation, it will send out messages to all affected subreddits, “letting them know they were affected but the situation is now resolved”. The firm will also be posting more detailed information about the incident on r/redditsecurity later.

    • By Jay Bonggolto
      Reddit now lets you add image galleries to a post
      by Jay Bonggolto



      Reddit has finally added support for uploading multiple photos in a single gallery. The company announced today that users can start inserting up to 20 images or GIFs into a post.

      Image Galleries, as the new feature is called, comes in handy particularly for photo-centric communities like those that focus on clothing, interior design, and make-up techniques. With the latest change, it's now possible to include step-by-step instructions, for example, in informative posts. There's also an option to add links along with captions (limited to 180 characters) in each photo.



      Tyler Swartz, Reddit Senior Product Manager, said:

      To add a gallery to a post, just select the "Image Post" option after tapping on the "Create a Post" button. Then, rearrange the photos, if necessary. In addition, you can apply a "Spoiler" or "Not Safe For Work" tag to the gallery. Finally, hit the "Post" button to share the images. That said, this feature will be available to redditors only if community moderators switch it on.

      Communities that opt in to Image Galleries can use the feature from today. Reddit plans to roll it out to Android users next week. In the future, the service intends to add support for video uploads to galleries.