Gamespot gave GTA4 a 10


How would you rate this game?  

59 members have voted

  1. 1. Your score

    • 10
      30
    • 9
      15
    • 8
      8
    • 7
      3
    • Lower than 7
      3


Recommended Posts

Here is the link

http://www.gamespot.com/ps3/action/grandth...;om_clk=topslot

First of all graphics are not as good as COD4. I know this game is way mroe detailed and we can not expect a COD4 graphics but still its as good as UNREAL not COD4. For me Graphics would be a 8 TOP... no more than it

I have a 40 gig version of the game and have a 250 gb harddisk in it, and the game DOES HAVE framerate issues at times. For those of you say the game is 100% smooth, it definitely is not...

So far played it 30 mins and the game is AMAZING.. I love the gameplay and controls are better. Did not test the online mode but online mode seems even better than single player so i will be playing this game for many months. Its a great value and voice acting and cinematics are nice

Still i can not ignore some of the framerate issues and not top of the class graphics..

I would give it a 9...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We already have an official topic for reviews :p

But anyway, staying ontopic, this is the only game to get a 10/10 on the PS3 from gamespot, and probably the first game ever - Putting aside smaller review websites that maybe gave something like Uncharted a 10.

Probably the last 10 gamespot will give the PS3, even if MGS4 is absolutely awesome, I bet it gets a 9.5 :laugh:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

People still look at Gamespot? I thought after that 'Kane & Lynch' fiasco they lost the little bit of credibility they had left.

I agree with you, 9/10! Zelda OoT is still my only 10/10 game :p

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Probably the last 10 gamespot will give the PS3, even if MGS4 is absolutely awesome, I bet it gets a 9.5 :laugh:

9 most likely. -1 for being PS3 exclusive. :laugh:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

shoot did not realize the review thread.. my bad.. feel free to remove the post if you like dear moderators :$

anyway yeah i had seen metroid prime getting a 10 in gamecube but thats all...

Cant see this to be achieved in a while...

10... what a rating.

People still look at Gamespot? I thought after that 'Kane & Lynch' fiasco they lost the little bit of credibility they had left.

I agree with you, 9/10!

i did not buy kane & lynch because gamespot gave it a 6.0... u mean its a better or worse game than that?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i did not buy kane & lynch because gamespot gave it a 6.0... u mean its a better or worse game than that?

no.. its because the Reviewer got fired for giving the game a 6.0.. meaning that GameSpot employee's were getting paid to give good reviews.. now i think like 90% of their reviewers have quit since then

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i did not buy kane & lynch because gamespot gave it a 6.0... u mean its a better or worse game than that?

it was a huge mess. This 1 reviewer (Jeff G...something) said the game was actually crap, but that didn't fly well with CNET because they had a lot of advertising from Kane & Lynch, so they ended up firing him and changed his review to 8 or 9 /10. Was a huge deal and then after a bit I guess they changed it back to the original review.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

"I have a 40 gig version of the game and have a 250 gb harddisk in it"

Huh?

"I have a 40gb version of the PS3 and have a 250GB hard disk in it"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

your not the only one! my pre-order got delayed because of low stock...dammit

hehe no but I didn't preorder or anything. Not a big fan of GTA games, maybe I'll get it later.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great game! I don't know how it got 10 in the graphics department my these review sites. They are 8.5 - 9 at best.

The only other thing is I feel the cars drive too heavy and spin out a lot.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great game! I don't know how it got 10 in the graphics department my these review sites. They are 8.5 - 9 at best.

The only other thing is I feel the cars drive too heavy and spin out a lot.

They drive very "American" but if you get a decent car it's much better.

I just wish the cars themselves didn't block so much of your view :p

Link to comment
Share on other sites

lol everyone on my list is playing GTA4. I think I'm the only one not playing it. :p

You aren't the only one. My 360 is currently RRoD'ed and awaiting being sent to MS for repair :(

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you list top games of all time on gamespot (by score), then you'd see that there are more 10's on Sony consoles than on Nintendo's or Microsoft's. (GTA4, THPS3, Chrono Cross)

Not that gamespots opinions matter all that much. If it was my list, tens would be reserved for genre changers; games so good that they become the basis by which all others are judged. (Mario 64, Ocarina of Time, Gran Turismo 3, Soul Calibur, Portal, GTA3, Diablo2, Starcraft, etc)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great game! I don't know how it got 10 in the graphics department my these review sites. They are 8.5 - 9 at best.

The only other thing is I feel the cars drive too heavy and spin out a lot.

Man I agree. I got the 360 version due to the extra content but the pop up is really really bad and anyone that says it is minor is blind. I'm sure all these sites were paid off for there 10/10 ratings or they are all just retards. I feel even rating it a 9 would have been excessive. Great game though don't get me wrong. I really thought that pop up was so ps1 and sega suturn :( .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.