Briandl79 Posted December 11, 2009 Share Posted December 11, 2009 The one thing that was clearly subjective was the design category. I'm not even sure the Slim version is any better than the original version, accept that it's slimmer. I personally like the piano black look. If you swap the scores for design you have a tie, and you could easily do that depending on your preference. Having said that, the video wasn't as bad as I thought it would be, they were pretty spot on in a lot of places but the one that I would argue with is graphics. Two of the reviewers called it a tie, but the third guy gave the edge to the PS3 because it had a couple of games that he considered top notch graphics wise (Killzone 2 and Uncharted 2?). I won't argue with that but when you say most third party games look better on the 360 (Which is almost a consensus in general) and you consider that the bulk of games on both consoles are third party-cross platform games, it's hard not to give the edge to the 360. So for example, out of a list of the top 50 PS3 games, 34 of those were third party. Now if you have 34 third party games available on both consoles, and many of them look better on the 360, and only 16 PS3 specific titles and only a few of those look better than 360 exclusives, it seems to me the 360 wins that battle. I guess if we're just talking best graphics period, I suppose the PS3 would win that category, but if we're talking about the quality of graphics across the entire lineup as a whole, I think the 360 would take the nod. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts