One of the ISPs that the British recording industry tried to strong-arm into terminating customers" accounts on accusation of file-sharing has refused. In a letter to the British Phonogram Industry, Tiscalis legal department lectures the BPI on how the law works and why the "overwhelming" evidence of wrongdoing was quite underwhelming.
Webuser has more details on this, including a complaint from Tiscali that the grandstanding BPI issued a press-release about its letter before it had been reviewed at Tiscali: "A Tiscali spokeswoman described the move as a "media ambush". She said the BPI had "[sent] their letter to the media before we even had a chance to read it and the information they went to press with was not strictly correct"."
"You have sent us a spreadsheet setting out a list of 17 IP addresses you allege belong to Tiscali customers, whom you allege have infringed the copyright of your members, together with the dates and times and with which sound recording you allege that they have done so. You have also sent us extracts of screenshots of the shared drive of one of those customers. You state that such evidence is "overwhelming". However, you have provided no actual evidence in respect of 16 of the accounts. Further, you have provided no evidence of downloading taking place nor have you provided evidence that the shared drive was connected by the relevant IP address at the relevant time.
Similar requests we have dealt with in the past, have included such information and, indeed, the bodies conducting those investigations have felt that a court would consider it necessary to see such evidence, supported by sworn statements, before being able to grant any order."
View: Full Article @ Boing Boing