Many of Motorola's patent claims against Microsoft thrown out in court

In November, Microsoft and Motorola (now owned by Google) made their cases in a Seattle-based US federal court in a long running legal battle over three patents owned by Motorola. Today, the judge in the case threw out 13 of the patent claims that Motorola claimed Microsoft violated.

CNet reports that Judge James L. Robart agreed with Microsoft's lawyers that Motorola's patent claims that concerned the encoding and decoding digital video content were in fact invalid, thanks in part to a previous US patent law. In very basic terms, the judge ruled that Motorola's patent claims were "indefinite", which means Motorola didn't do a good enough job in explaining their patents.

Not all of the patent claims Motorola has against Microsoft have been invalidated yet. Even if the judge rules in Motorola's favor in the remaining claims, there's still the matter of Microsoft's payment to Motorola for those patents. Microsoft's position is that Motorola should offer those patents under "fair, reasonable and nondiscriminatory terms", otherwise known as FRAND. If the judge rules for Microsoft in this aspect of the case, that means Microsoft would have to pay a fraction of the money that Motorola is asking from Microsoft.

Source: CNet
Gavel image via Shutterstock

Report a problem with article
Previous Story

Surface Pro and MacBook Air have similar free disk space

Next Story

Microsoft updates in-house PDF Reader for WP8

4 Comments

Enron said,
Microsoft and Google should make up and be best FRANDs.

iseewhayadithar and ya they should just drop the patent fud and be frands as well and BFF

Commenting is disabled on this article.