Review

Review: HTC EVO 3D [updates and video]

Is that phone 3D or is it just happy to see me?

The mobile market these days has gadget lovers planning their next purchase based on roughly four key items: size, hardware specs, OS, and the key features or special touch that separate their phone from the competition. The HTC EVO 3D pushes forward in most of these categories (with Android being a personal preference) with its dual core 1.2GHz CPU, Adreno 220 GPU, 1GB RAM, 4.3" QHD 3D screen and 3D video recording and picture taking capabilities. The phone comes packaged with an 8GB class 4 microSD card as well as a USB wall charger and micro-USB cable. The EVO 3D is by no means a small phone, but for those used to the EVO 4G or similar phones it will feel at home in your hand.

General Use
Booting up the EVO 3D for the first time is straightforward. It asks to activate the phone, asks which wireless network to connect to, and then walks you through a quick tutorial and links in your Google, Flickr and other accounts. Immediately you can tell you are in for a great experience. Flipping through the home screens is smooth and animations in general are nice and not overly done.

HTC's Sense 3.0 will feel comfortable for those who have used other versions of it in the past. It does add a few nice features such as customizable lock screens that allow you to set four apps you can launch directly by swiping them as well as give you information on your friends through Twitter and Facebook updates. One change I have not been fond of so far is the application list paging. On the EVO 4G you were able to swipe the list and it would scroll until you stopped it or it reached the end. In contrast, on the EVO 3D you have to swipe for every full screen page of applications installed.

The battery life was a major concern due to the updated hardware being much more powerful than its predecessor. So far I have found it to be comparable to my EVO 4G where it lasts a full day of use (approximately 14hrs) and still has decent amount of life left. The phone also feels nice in the hand and has a good grip with the textured case backing. Since today was the first full day of having the phone as well as having it in my office it was getting a lot of use showing off the 3D features, including shooting 3D photos and video, so it may actually be even doing better than the 4G but only time will tell for sure.

3D
Faster hardware aside the key feature that currently separates this phone from the market is of course its 3D features. Not only can this phone display 3D photos and videos using glasses-free technology, it can also record 720p 3D video and take 3D photos using its dual 5mp cameras located on the back of the device. To be honest, when I decided to upgrade to the EVO 3D I didn't care about the 3D and assumed it was mostly a sales gimmick; I just wanted the upgraded CPU, GPU, RAM and QHD display. For the first minute or two I hated the 3D effect; it looked poor (much like those old 3D cards that looked 3D when you moved side to side) and overall just didn't look that "3D". Since I had been setting up the phone, I had it closer to my face than normal. Just before I gave up on 3D features I moved it further away and then it became clear: that is a neat feature! I then loaded up The Green Hornet 3D that comes preloaded and found that watching a movie in 3D was far simpler and less strain on the eyes than still photos. The positioning of the phone also seemed far more forgiving while watching video. The general consensus at my office was the 3D feature was better than expected and pretty favorable.

After taking a few 3D photos I headed outside to try out 3D video recording. The video and photos recorded from the EVO 3D are not nearly as crisp and distinctly 3D as the preloaded examples but they still hold their ground. I did find it difficult to try and take a 3D photo or record 3D video since the phone displays the live view in 3D. If you are holding the camera anywhere but right in front of your face the 3D effect is not quite right so it is hard to tell if it is in focus or if it is just a bad angle to the screen. General camera usage is easy thanks to the dedicated camera button on the side of the phone. The camera button is a two step button - half press to focus and full press to take the photo. I found this to be much easier than having to tap a button on the screen, especially when the phone is not at a great viewing angle. Next to the camera button is a 2D/3D toggle switch to disable/enable 3D photo and video capture.

The EVO 3D also comes preloaded with a 3D Spider-Man game. Unfortunately the first time I attempted to play it the phone froze and I had to pull the battery out. Since then it has been fine and I was able to play the game for some time. I noticed with the game that after a short period the 3D effects weren't as noticeable and didn't seem to affect my eye strain. It will be interesting to see what developers come up with as 3D makes its way into more phones and more hands.

Usage
Call clarity and signal strength have been the same for me at both locations I primarily use my phone – work and home. The calls I have made seemed no better or worse than my EVO 4G had been. I tried connecting to 4G in Detroit where I work and the signal was also just as good as the EVO 4G. Note that Sprint's 4G network has not yet officially launched in my area.

I ran a few checks to compare a few underlying features of the EVO 3D vs the EVO 4G. When the EVO 4G came out it had a limit on the frames per second (fps) it could output which cause some areas of the phone to slightly tear when scrolling or in general feel slow. That was changed after HTC released an update that allowed it to increase the frame rate. The 4G after the frame rate unlock would see around 50fps using an app called fps2d. The EVO 3D scores on average 60fps which gives a nice upper limit for whatever content you throw at it. Another test that was run on the 4G was with a program called Dotty. What Dotty did was check how many multi touch inputs the phone was capable of detecting. Different EVO 4Gs had differing amounts depending on the revision ranging from 3 to 5 touch points. The same test run on the EVO 3D shows the launch units are capable of 4 touch points. Most people and apps will not need this many, but the capability is there.

Overall
With the HTC EVO 3D priced at $200 with a 2yr contract with Sprint only a year after the EVO 4G was released, it shows that mobile technology is not only moving fast but staying reasonably priced. If you want a lot of power in your hands that is capable of tackling everything from solitaire and emails to 3D movies and games, the HTC EVO 3D is definitely a good choice. If you need a phone that can last days away from a charger, however, this phone, like many other of the powerhouse phones, won't cut it without adding an extended battery.


Pros:
Average price for a high end smartphone
3D viewing and capture is a fun new feature not yet readily available elsewhere
Powerful CPU and GPU
Large screen

Cons:
Battery life lasts only about a day with normal usage
Large phone (if you are looking for a powerful smartphone, this shouldn't be an issue, but for some it is too big)
HDMI out requires a MHL adapter which is not yet readily available
 

2011-06-25 Updates:
As requested I took some sample 3D videos and posted them both here and here. These were taken at the Detroit River Days festival. While taking these videos I did notice one issue with my phone and 3D recording - the right camera seemed to shift around part way through the first video. If you look at the side-by-side version on YouTube and start paying attention around 22 seconds in you will see the right camera shift its view to the left some. When viewing on the phone it is noticeable that the 3D does not quite  look right when it happens. I have not seen other reports of this yet, but the phone has only been officially released for almost two days so we will have to see if it is a common issue. 

To clarify the battery life, after a full day (7:30 AM unplug through around 8:30 PM) I still had around 40% battery life remaining. This time included taking several videos and photos at the festival as well as showing the phone off to more people at my office, so it had a fairly decent workout. While the phone would not last over a weekend getaway without charging, in most cases it has ample power to get you through an average day.

A quick walkthrough of using the phone and how smooth it feels


A comparison between the EVO 4G and EVO 3D when loading two PopCap games
The difference is around six seconds for Plants vs. Zombies and Peggle which means the EVO 4G takes 50% longer than the EVO 3D to load the game. I also noticed in Plants vs. Zombies the transitions between levels and when you get upgrades at the end of the level are much smoother than the EVO 4G which became really choppy. Overall it gives a much nicer experience when playing these games

Report a problem with article
Previous Story

Winklevoss twins to continue different court fight with Facebook

Next Story

Motorola Atrix 4G bootloader unlocked

35 Comments

Commenting is disabled on this article.

I love my iPod touch but still the phone part is the crapiest of apple iOS family, so for a phone definitely the android OS is the best, and now I think a found mine

I got a chance to play with one yesterday and the phone is smoking fast. I did not get to view any 3D movie but the 3D stills were not great.

Good review Doug, could you please reveal what part of the country or area code your review the phone in? More importantly the coverage for the particular carrier you are reviewing. My kid lives in S. Cal and a tin can gets great coverage there.
TIA

davidtb said,
Good review Doug, could you please reveal what part of the country or area code your review the phone in? More importantly the coverage for the particular carrier you are reviewing. My kid lives in S. Cal and a tin can gets great coverage there.
TIA

FWIW, I played with one in BB when i was getting my NExus, and the signal was pretty good.. this is in sunnyvale, CA (NorCal)

davidtb said,
Good review Doug, could you please reveal what part of the country or area code your review the phone in? More importantly the coverage for the particular carrier you are reviewing. My kid lives in S. Cal and a tin can gets great coverage there.
TIA
I tested it in Detroit, MI and just south of Detroit where I live

I have a serious question although this might come off as odd. If you take a 3D picture of a naked lady, does the 3D really make it look realistic? So when you look at the picture later is it really clear and 3D and maybe takes your breathe away? Or is it no big deal?

no-sweat said,
I have a serious question although this might come off as odd. If you take a 3D picture of a naked lady, does the 3D really make it look realistic? So when you look at the picture later is it really clear and 3D and maybe takes your breathe away? Or is it no big deal?

You mean, does 3D picture give better experience while having coitus with hand than standard picture?

jackkk1 said,
3D pics and videos or it doesn't exist!
I'll look into how I can share 3D photos. I will get some video up later today

jackkk1 said,
3D pics and videos or it doesn't exist!

Can we even watch/see 3D without 3D compatible screens? Like on our laptops, they are not 3D. I think its impossible without a 3D capable screen...

i went to pick up a nexus 4g yesterday from BB (49$) and they had the 3d to play with there. The 3d was a little gimmicky, i didn't watch the movie on it though. I like the "carbon fiber" look of the back case though, makes it look high tech, and the phone feels more solid than that nexus. I may end up getting the 3d as the nexus, which is replacing my evo, has issues with the back key...sometimes it doesn't work. I'm trying to narrow it down but it appears to be wide spread from reading googles forums.

still rockin' my rooted + unlocked original EVO (hw 002), w/CM7 nightly. the 3D is not worth the upgrade for me. i do wish the camera was better like the iPhone.

NEXT!

leeoniya said,
still rockin' my rooted + unlocked original EVO (hw 002), w/CM7 nightly. the 3D is not worth the upgrade for me. i do wish the camera was better like the iPhone.

NEXT!

I will be uploading a video comparison of some 4G vs 3D load times and similar. The hardware in the 3D is far superior (even ignoring 3D capabilities) and overall feels much zippier and smooth than my rooted 4G ever was

This phone looks like a nice complete package... I am also considering the Nexus S as I am looking to buy a phone in the near future .. Not sure what to do though...

este said,
This phone looks like a nice complete package... I am also considering the Nexus S as I am looking to buy a phone in the near future .. Not sure what to do though...

LG Optimus 2x. Same price as Nexus, a ton more hardware on it (Tegra), plus a nice smooth IPS screen (the AMOLED panel on the Nexus S looks like crap next to the 2x)

glen8 said,
Pros - Large Screen
Cons - Large Phone

ROFL

Yeah I love the large screen but a lot of people don't like large phones

Digitalx said,
would so pass on it if one is wise... don't buy into this hurp durp 3D rubbish.

But... But.. it's 3D man!!! 3D I tell you!... marketing folks FTW....

xendrome said,

But... But.. it's 3D man!!! 3D I tell you!... marketing folks FTW....

About as 3D as a panoramic photo lol. not to mention it's HTC so meh.

Digitalx said,

About as 3D as a panoramic photo lol. not to mention it's HTC so meh.

I hope the 3D trend dies. HTC = meh? Nah. Moto, Samsung, LG, etc are the same. HTC has great build quality + Sense UI > any other Android skin. Very polished, and if you don't like it, the dev. community behind HTC phones are unbeatable.

hey im happy with a day if it last me a full day ( since i use my phone for work ) and im on my phone ALL the time


reviewer nice review

(Spork) said,
hey im happy with a day if it last me a full day ( since i use my phone for work ) and im on my phone ALL the time


reviewer nice review

have fun with your locked bootloader!

"Cons: Battery life lasts only about a day with normal usage"

Is this still considered a con nowadays? Most new smartphones don't last more than a day, unless you leave them in standby + aircraft mode...

Jeex said,
"Cons: Battery life lasts only about a day with normal usage"

Is this still considered a con nowadays? Most new smartphones don't last more than a day, unless you leave them in standby + aircraft mode...

apparently with the EVO 3G battery life is a real problem

Julius Caro said,

apparently with the EVO 3G battery life is a real problem


rofl no its not i get a full day out or mine ( 12 -15 hours ) with normal to heavy use

Jeex said,
"Cons: Battery life lasts only about a day with normal usage"

Is this still considered a con nowadays? Most new smartphones don't last more than a day, unless you leave them in standby + aircraft mode...

Personally I am fine with getting a day out of my phone but many people are not which is why I listed it as such

(Spork) said,


rofl no its not i get a full day out or mine ( 12 -15 hours ) with normal to heavy use


24-28 hours normal usage...calls, texts, email, FB, games....

Jeex said,
"Cons: Battery life lasts only about a day with normal usage"

Is this still considered a con nowadays? Most new smartphones don't last more than a day, unless you leave them in standby + aircraft mode...


You sir, are quite wrong, I text all day, and surf online plenty, along with app usage. ~2 to 2.5 days til low