Recommended Posts

There is absoutly NO reason for W2K8 to be a workstation... with SP1 anything that was in W2K8 has been updated to be the same in Vista... this is something they didnt do in XP with w2k3...

the kernel even in Vista was updated to match W2K8! which was the main reason for the w2k3 workstation thing...

even IIS7 was updated in vista to match the new version in w2k8...

all the performance is the same... now they are using the same exact code basically minus the server components...

so in the end there is no real reason for it

Is anyone doing a Win 2008 Server as a workstation guide?

That won't be published, of course?

I have it on a workstation - very impressive responsiveness compared to Vista, but I haven't installed the "desktop enhancements"

thanks --

Can you please show your testing method to show your claimed "very impressive responsiveness compared to Vista"

In Vista SP1, At a administrative command prompt, type 'net stop themes'.

You have now turned off the desktop experience.

Vista will operate like Windows Server 2008, only without most server components.

re: why

- same reason they had the 2k3 as a workstation guide - some people need the server components for everyday work.

re: show your testing method

- nothing to show - I have 2 identical dell workstations that sit side by side. one has vista pre-sp1, one has 2008. The speed difference, as I said in my post, is probably because of the desktop stuff not being on - and almost nothing is installed yet...

Sooo - I'm guessing that's a "no" -- nobody is working on one...

Thanks --

re: why

- same reason they had the 2k3 as a workstation guide - some people need the server components for everyday work.

re: show your testing method

- nothing to show - I have 2 identical dell workstations that sit side by side. one has vista pre-sp1, one has 2008. The speed difference, as I said in my post, is probably because of the desktop stuff not being on - and almost nothing is installed yet...

Sooo - I'm guessing that's a "no" -- nobody is working on one...

Thanks --

and what server components do you need? Terminal services? DNS? DHCP? MSMQ? IIS? A lot of them you can get in Vista with out wasting the money on server... IIS is there to start with in business... DNS and DHCP you generally get with a router... or a freeware tool... Terminal services... if you are running this on a workstation then you should rethink why (not talking remote desktop here)...

re: show your testing method

- nothing to show - I have 2 identical dell workstations that sit side by side. one has vista pre-sp1, one has 2008. The speed difference, as I said in my post, is probably because of the desktop stuff not being on - and almost nothing is installed yet...

The reason you probably see the speed difference is because your Vista desktop is pre-SP1. Install SP1 on it and it should run the same as Server 2008, except it will have the eye candy (which you can disable) and it won't have all the server components that you probably wouldn't use on a normal desktop.

Wow, it's amazing how fast you jumped down the guy's throat for wanting to use Server 2008 as a desktop OS. You want a reason?

HYPER-V

Google it. If any of you knew anything about Server 2008 you'd know that right there is reason enough for A LOT of people to want to use it as a desktop OS. It's the main reason I am using it as one. And don't bother countering with VMware. VMware Server doesn't work correctly with Vista x64, and Workstation doesn't allow VM's to run as services and launch at boot. Not to mention, Hyper-V is DAMN FAST in 2008, even in beta form.

And as for your insistence that Server 2008 is no faster than Vista just because it uses the same kernel, have any of you ACTUALLY TRIED running the two in comparable states? You say the speed difference is "probably because of the desktop stuff not being on." Go ahead, turn it all on. It still MUCH faster than Vista. I'm running 2008 with the Desktop Experience on, Aero Glass with full effects, AND THREE VIRTUAL MACHINES, (two running Server 2008, and one Vista x64 SP1, each with 1 CPU and 1GB of RAM) and the OS is STILL faster and more responsive than Vista SP1.

If you check out TheHotfix.net's forums, you'll see that people have pared down Vista's services to match 2008's running services and they are still getting upwards of 20FPS improvements in games like F.E.A.R.

Think of 2008 like this: Basically, Microsoft took Vista and streamlined and tweaked the hell out of it for a year, and made it as efficient as possible. Then they added in all the server role options. That's what Server 2008 is.

I have to say that I never bought into the "2003 Server as a workstation" scenario before, but if it yielded the kinds of performance gains I've gotten with 2008 vs. Vista, I completely understand now.

I know this is my first post, and I usually start off with something pleasant to say, but I had to back the OP up on this one. OP, just wait a bit. As more people discover what we have someone will make a great "how-to" for running 2008 as a workstation. I'm really only waiting for someone to hack DreamScene and/or Media Center into it and I'd be happy as a clam!

What the price of a Server 2008 license ? , can one buy a single license ?, I think it would be too costly.

Most users will probably get it from MSDN or Academic MSDN (I get XP, 2003 Server, Vista Business free). It will cost probably as much as 2003 Server, maybe $800 for a 5CAL OEM.

Think of 2008 like this: Basically, Microsoft took Vista and streamlined and tweaked the hell out of it for a year, and made it as efficient as possible. Then they added in all the server role options. That's what Server 2008 is.

Think of Vista SP1 like this: They brought the Server '08 and Vista code branches back together, so in a LOT of cases, the code you're running on Vista SP1 will be exactly the same as with Server '08.

Think of Vista SP1 like this: They brought the Server '08 and Vista code branches back together, so in a LOT of cases, the code you're running on Vista SP1 will be exactly the same as with Server '08.

Hmm, yeah.. except a lot of un-necessary services are disabled on Server 2008 at Default, unlike Windows Vista where a lot of those services are enabled (or set to manual -which still loads it into memory) for compatibility reasons.

just install Vista SP1...kill the services...then you will be just as fast at Server......when XP and 2k3 were out, there was a valid reason to run 2k3 as a desktop OS...it was faster with better memory management...thats not the case anymore, Vista and Server 08 have teh same codebase, the ONLY difference is Vista got end user tools added in, Server has Admin tools added in. The only "speed increase" is that Server has some of Vistas services off by default.

There were a lot of complaining from so called knowledgeable people here last time regarding 2003 and I can safely say they were all proven wrong.

2003 and of course xp x64 which was based on 2003 were a lot better than XP in a lot of ways, not compatibillity though but those were problems artificially created by software firms to take more money from people who want to use the software on a server OS.

In this case however, it's probably mostly the same as Vista, but if you don't have to pay for the license, then why not use 2008?

I use 2008 server as a desktop OS right now, though it also works as a server some of the time, at least I plan to use it that way.

It's easy to manage and there isn't so much crap by default settings.

Just install firefox, install desktop experience, disable shutdown tracker, and it's pretty much the same thing. (enable themes and win audio services too)

just install Vista SP1...kill the services...then you will be just as fast at Server......when XP and 2k3 were out, there was a valid reason to run 2k3 as a desktop OS...it was faster with better memory management...thats not the case anymore, Vista and Server 08 have teh same codebase, the ONLY difference is Vista got end user tools added in, Server has Admin tools added in. The only "speed increase" is that Server has some of Vistas services off by default.

not really. i installed vista last friday, and with sp1 it takes 17gb. win 2008 on the other hand only 5gb.

anyway those tips from server 2003 as workstation + the ones about 2008 makes a complete package :)

not really. i installed vista last friday, and with sp1 it takes 17gb. win 2008 on the other hand only 5gb.

anyway those tips from server 2003 as workstation + the ones about 2008 makes a complete package :)

Sounds like media center & the other desktop software that isn't installed on server.

Unless you're developing software, Windows server 2008 is overkill. It's like choosing Windows 2000 Server over Windows 2000 Pro, they are the same codebase.

why 2k8? same as 2003 + more new features - Hyper-v, enterprise versions of databases, development testing, all on one box..

Thanks for the pointers!

Vijayshinva's blog entry was pretty much what I was thinking -- I wasn't aware of the audio service (don't listen on those machines...)

As a developer who also likes to play games, would you guys recommend a dual-boot between 2008 and Vista, or are most games that are compatible with Vista compatible with 2008? Are there any issues/regrets with using 2008 over Vista as a workstation OS? Driver support/application compatibility/etc?

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Internet Download Manager (IDM) 6.43 Build 2 by Razvan Serea Internet Download Manager (IDM) is a tool to increase download speeds by up to 8 times due to its smart dynamic file segmentation technology. Unlike other download managers and accelerators, Internet Download Manager segments downloaded files dynamically during download process, and it reuses available connections without additional connect and login stages to achieve the best possible acceleration performance. Comprehensive error recovery and resume capability will restart broken or interrupted downloads due to lost connections, network problems, computer shutdowns, or unexpected power outages. All popular browsers are supported IDM integrates seamlessly into Google Chrome, FireFox, Microsoft Edge, Opera, Safari, Internet Explorer, Maxthon and all other popular browsers to automatically handle your downloads. You can also drag and drop files, or use Internet Download Manager from command line. The program supports proxy servers, ftp and http protocols, firewalls, redirects, cookies, authorization, MP3 audio and video content processing. IDM includes web site spider and grabber IDM downloads all required files that are specified with filters from web sites, for example all pictures from a web site, or subsets of web sites, or complete web sites for offline browsing. It's possible to schedule multiple grabber projects to run them once at a specified time, stop them at a specified time, or run periodically to synchronize changes. Easy downloading with one click When you click on a download link in a browser, IDM will take over the download and accelerate it. You don't need to do anything special, just browse the Internet as you usually do. IDM will catch your downloads and accelerate them. IDM supports HTTP, FTP, HTTPS and MMS protocols. Changes in Internet Download Manager 6.43 Build 2: Resolved the problem that caused a "403 Forbidden" error when downloading some files Fixed a problem causing IDM download panel not to appear on some websites Fixed a bug that caused a crash when converting some TS files to MP4 Download: Internet Download Manager 6.43 Build 2 | 11.9 MB (Shareware) Links: Internet Download Manager Website | Screenshot Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware
    • It's in Experimental (26H2). Settings->Windows Update->Windows Insider Program. Then a) select Experimental, b) below that, select "Advanced Options" (where you will see the three options for "Experimental" builds -> select 26H2 (name change from 25H2 is rolling; so might be 25H2)
    • I am not a US citizen nor a Trump fan. Respect to both left and right. But I will, for the sake of fun, predict something for my own. There will come a day when the US and China will collide like titans ( over Taiwan or anything else ). Then, on that day, some people in this comment section will realize how good an idea it was to become independent in areas like that. ( Or atleast try )
    • Microsoft Edge gets tons of security features, including AI model that can see your screen by Usama Jawad Microsoft Edge may not be the most popular browser out there, but it does receive quite frequent updates that sometimes bring surprising new features and axe others that are not as popular. Now, Microsoft has detailed some of the new security enhancements that it has introduced in Edge for Business, typically used by commercial customers. Microsoft has emphasized that security features are baked into Edge for Business and offer native integration with security and governance tools like Defender and Purview. Browser sessions are governed by default on managed devices but can also be governed through dedicated work profiles on unmanaged devices. An important aspect in this area is controlling the use of shadow AI. We have talked about this before, but it essentially restricts employees from using unsanctioned AI apps through data loss prevention (DLP) policies, with Edge redirecting them to trusted AI services like Microsoft 365 Copilot. This feature, available as a pay-as-you-go (PAYG) license, ensures that confidential data never exits AI boundaries set by your organization in Purview. Additionally, Microsoft also has strong DLP policies for contractors. Contractors leveraging a Entra ID-joined work profile provisioned by their contracting company on a device managed by their actual employer can be restricted from downloading files locally. In such scenarios, the file is saved on the contracting firm's OneDrive rather than being downloaded locally. Another useful Edge security feature disallows copying and pasting from unmanaged locations and apps. Similarly, DLP policies can be configured at a granular level to restrict screenshots or downloading of files from certain locations. In the same vein, IT admins can block the installation of extensions, hosted apps, themes and scripts, and control if users can install extensions from external locations. They can also enable the installation of specific extensions and allow users to request access to certain extensions, so that they can be managed on a case-by-case basis. Finally, Edge for Business now has an on-device AI model that uses computer vision to see what's on your screen and block potentially malicious content immediately. This does not rely on site reputation, as it simply monitors what is being displayed on your screen, which means that it is effective against malicious content that takes over your screen and employs scareware tactics. Since this is an on-device AI model, it does use your system's resources, so it's enabled by default only on devices with at least 2GB of RAM and four CPU cores. You can find more details in the Microsoft Mechanics video here.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Dedicated
      Zeynel earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • One Month Later
      JKR earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Dedicated
      Asgardi earned a badge
      Dedicated
    • Conversation Starter
      jessse3334 earned a badge
      Conversation Starter
    • Reacting Well
      JuvenileDelinquent earned a badge
      Reacting Well
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      495
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      247
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      154
    4. 4
      Steven P.
      86
    5. 5
      macoman
      65
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!