USB2 or Firewire external harddrive?


Recommended Posts

I think that the difference is so small that you won't notice it, I have used a USB 2 hard disk by Lacie, and it worked as well as the IDE drives in that machine. Also every computer doesn't have Firewire, but every should have USB these days (unless you find a computer that is 5 years old :) ). USB is also usually cheaper, so I'd go with the USB one :)

Also every computer doesn't have Firewire, but every should have USB these days (unless you find a computer that is 5 years old :) ).

585763900[/snapback]

Well, since you are in the Mac section, it's pretty much a given that all the computers in use here will have FireWire. Every Mac made in the last 5 years does, but only Macs made in the last 18 months or so have USB 2.0.

For the Mac mini, I'd recommend getting a FireWire drive if for no other reason than it will free up one of the USB ports for other things. It WILL be somewhat faster since the speed rating for USB 2.0 is only a burst speed. FireWire has higher sustained throughput than USB 2.0.

Well, since you are in the Mac section, it's pretty much a given that all the computers in use here will have FireWire.  Every Mac made in the last 5 years does, but only Macs made in the last 18 months or so have USB 2.0.

Yep, I was just thinking about that it is an external hard drive, so he might want to plug it in other computers too. And every computer ain't a mac :). It's always up to what you will do with it and do you want to pay some extra. He stated that he got a mac mini, so theres both connections :)

Thanks for the quick answers, i I think I will go for the Firewire from LaCie they have some nicelooking stuff and free USB ports are always good.

585764192[/snapback]

Great choice. The LaCie triple interface drives are a great thing. I believe they use a Western Digital Special Edition 8MB Cache 7200RPM IDE hard drive, and have three different ways to connect, via USB1.1/2.0, Firewire 400, and Firewire 800. Plus LaCie gives you ALL the cables you will ever need. USB 2.0, Firewire 400 6pin to 6pin, Firewire 400 6pin to 4 pin (for PC laptops generally), and Firewire 800 cable. LaCie makes sure you have the drive ready, plus they are more pro-Mac, as my drive was pre-formatted with Mac HFS+ Filesystem! I do notice it is somewhat faster than my laptop's internal drive (5400rpm) but if your mini has a 4200RPM, this will be leaps and bounds faster no doubt.

I have a drive with a USB connection and two Firewire connections. With the iBook I use the Firewire, but if I take it round to a friends for some reason, I use the USB on their PC.

I sometimes boot off the external drive when testing other OS's such as Linux, OS X Server, and Tiger beta. I also have a panther partition which is handy in case things ever go pear shaped.

Dougal.

Food for thought: You can boot from an external firewire drive.? You can't boot from a USB drive.

585764142[/snapback]

:rolleyes::

:trout::

YES YOU CAN!!!!!!!!!!! AAARRRRRRRGGGGGGGGHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!! When are people going to stop spreading this rumor that Macs can't boot from USB???????:argh::

Edited by roadwarrior
Go for firewire a lot quicker, have a look here

http://www.span.com/catalog/index.php?cPath=20_32

They do some nice external harddrive case's and disks.

585763992[/snapback]

you said go for firewire a lot quicker... but the link you showed .. had usb2 beating firewire by 10 meg

you said go for firewire a lot quicker... but the link you showed .. had usb2 beating firewire by 10 meg

585765619[/snapback]

Yeah, but it's those "up to's" that get ya. As stated earlier, the sustained transfer rates for FireWire are higher than for USB 2.0.

That was a weird link to post though, I didn't really see much info there relating to performance differences.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Wow, imagine you dump hundreds of hours into completing things and unlocking stuff and you lose it all. Back in the day when cheats were built into games, you could at least unlock things again that way without spending hundreds of hours again. But those days are long gone for some reason as no one builds cheats into games anymore. So it's even more painful that studio that's on its 6th installment **** it up so badly.
    • Spotify finally removes the disco ball app icon in the latest update by Ivan Jenic Image: Spotify Spotify has just released an update that removes its now infamous disco ball icon. The update reverts the app icon to the familiar flat green logo after weeks of mixed reactions online. The icon arrived on May 13 as part of the company's 20th anniversary celebration and was always intended to be temporary, though Spotify only confirmed that after the backlash started. The disco ball took the internet by storm, as the reception was split. A vocal group of users called it ugly and disorienting, with some iOS users noting that the 3D glowing effect made the app look like it was stuck mid-update. On the other end, the icon picked up a following of its own. Its retro, three-dimensional look immediately stood out against the flat, minimalist aesthetic that has dominated app design for years. It even started a small movement, spawning what people started calling "discomorphism," a mashup of disco and skeuomorphism. Other brands started posting disco ball versions of their own logos, probably in an effort to ride the wave of memes that flooded the internet during late May. Spotify has had a turbulent relationship with its user base lately. Besides the disco ball icon, which certainly wasn't appreciated by everyone, the company has also received backlash for its willingness to include AI-generated music on its platform. On May 17, Spotify promised the old icon would return “in a few weeks.” And now it looks like that time has finally arrived. So, whether you liked the disco ball or it made you uncomfortable, it’s now gone for good. The next time you update the Spotify app on your phone, the old, flat-design icon will return.
    • Playground Games confirms Forza Horizon 6 save wipe bug by Taras Buria Forza Horizon 6 was launched last month to critical acclaim (check out our review here), and it became a smash hit in an instant. Now, weeks into the launch, with die-hard fans clocking hundreds of hours, Forza Horizon 6 is facing a serious issue: save wipes. After multiple complaints on Reddit and social media, the studio issued a statement. The problem with missing saves came shortly after Playground Games promised the initial batch of gameplay tweaks and improvements. Unfortunately, there seems to be no temporary fixes for those affected by unexpected save wipes. However, the studio published a new support document with a few important steps users should try. First, affected gamers should open a support ticket immediately (go here to file one) so that the support team can try recovering the lost progress by reverting to an earlier save. Playground Games says this should be done the same day the issue occurs. Meanwhile, gamers are urged not to start new play sessions or create new saves. The studio also published a few things gamers should try to avoid to prevent potential progress loss: Ensure your Gaming Services app on PC or XBOX Series X|S console is fully up to date. On XBOX Series X|S consoles, disable Quick Resume for Forza Horizon 6: To disable Forza Horizon 6 from using Quick Resume, highlight the game box art anywhere in the console experience (Home, My Games & Apps, Pins, etc) and then press the Menu button, then go to Manage game and add-ons > Quick Resume settings > Disable Quick Resume. Ensure you are online when ‘quitting’ the game. Give your saved time to sync to the cloud before powering off or switching devices. Do not force quit the game during save screens. Do not power off the device during gameplay. Always "Quit" (console) or "Exit to desktop" (PC) once you've finished your play session, ensuring the save icon is not visible when you’re closing the game. Before turning off your console, shutting down your PC, or force-closing the Steam app, give your devices or clients at least a few minutes to ensure your latest progress has been synchronized with the cloud. This will reduce the risk of progress reversions as you switch between different platforms. XBOX Series X|S consoles, Steam, and the XBOX app on PC all include game save indicators that confirm your progress has been synced. You can read more about the bug in the official support document here. Forza Horizon 6 is currently available on PC (Steam and the Microsoft Store), Xbox Series X|S, and Game Pass. The game is also coming to PlayStation 5 later this year.
  • Recent Achievements

    • One Year In
      slackerzz earned a badge
      One Year In
    • One Year In
      highriskpaym earned a badge
      One Year In
    • One Month Later
      highriskpaym earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Week One Done
      highriskpaym earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Week One Done
      FBSPL earned a badge
      Week One Done
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      519
    2. 2
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      198
    3. 3
      +Edouard
      158
    4. 4
      Steven P.
      84
    5. 5
      ATLien_0
      75
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!