FLAC support

By funkydude
in Windows Phone/Mobile

 Share

Recommended Posts

Veteran

Melfster

Posted
Posted

I suppose there wouldn't be any major obstacle to it. Microsoft will not support FLAC on the Windows Phone platform, probably ever. There's just no point, it's far too fringe a format to waste engineering effort on. Might see WMA Pro Lossless in WP8.

What's funny is I think more people use FLAC then use WMA Pro Lossless. So I don't think it is fringe at all.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1078027-flac-support/#findComment-594877437
Share on other sites
Grand Master

Prince Charming

Posted
Posted

What's funny is I think more people use FLAC then use WMA Pro Lossless. So I don't think it is fringe at all.

Quite possible.

Still, I wouldn't say that FLAC isn't a fringe codec because it's used more than another obscure fringe codec. WMA PL just has a higher chance of being supported because it's in the WMA family, not because anybody is clamouring to get it.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1078027-flac-support/#findComment-594877439
Share on other sites
Grand Master

HawkMan

Posted
Posted

FLAC doesn't make sense on a mobile media player anyway, audio quality is to low to make use of it and low storage space makes it leaven less useful.

Especially with windows 7's ability to hardware encode lossless or non supported audio when copied to devices at nearly live data copy speed. Of course this doesn't really work in Zune as far as I'm aware, just for devices that use the win7 device center/manager.

Anyway, my pointis, keep FLAC or whatever lossless codec for archive and for listening upon high end networked media players connected to an actual amp/receiver with proper speakers, and encode in lossy formats in your proffered quality for PMPs.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1078027-flac-support/#findComment-594877569
Share on other sites
Grand Master

HawkMan

Posted
Posted

Also if you absoolutely think you need lossless in your PMP, the advantage is that you can convert all your FLAC to wma lossless without quality loss. When it comes to lossless it doesn't matter which format you chose, except of hardware and software support, where wma lossless wins hands down over FLAC anyway.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1078027-flac-support/#findComment-594877581
Share on other sites
Grand Master

Farstrider

Posted
Posted

Also if you absoolutely think you need lossless in your PMP, the advantage is that you can convert all your FLAC to wma lossless without quality loss. When it comes to lossless it doesn't matter which format you chose, except of hardware and software support, where wma lossless wins hands down over FLAC anyway.

Sorry but this is absolutely incorrect! This from Hydrogenaudio website.

post-23703-0-14651800-1337549768_thumb.j

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1078027-flac-support/#findComment-594877617
Share on other sites
Grand Master

HawkMan

Posted
Posted

Uh, right. Now name all the pmp's that support FLAC, compared to how many support wma. On original firmware. No rock box or mer mods. Plain old original firmware. Using the built in library functions on the device.

FLAC was pretty much only supported on a few high end river devices that where way over priced as cool s they where. While every plays for sure device supported wma, which was everything not iPod pretty much. Today on phones. It's a different matter, but on without using awkward this party players that rules out FLAC as well. And let's get down to actual receivers and amps. There's a lot of them that support all kinds of wma, but no FLAC.

So I'll take that table with a grain of salt.

Also Hving done both wma and FLAC and monkey and many other encodings, I can tell you the encoding speed in that table is plain wrong. Wma breezes through encoding even on slow hardware. But then again, on today's hardware encoding speed is pretty irrelevant anyway. All of these are fast enough it won't matter.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1078027-flac-support/#findComment-594877665
Share on other sites
Community Regular

funkydude

Posted
  • Author
Posted

I suppose there wouldn't be any major obstacle to it.

Thanks, here's hoping some apps crop up.

Also if you absoolutely think you need lossless in your PMP, the advantage is that you can convert all your FLAC to wma lossless without quality loss. When it comes to lossless it doesn't matter which format you chose, except of hardware and software support, where wma lossless wins hands down over FLAC anyway.

WMA lossless isn't supported either. It may look like it is, but secretly it's converted to mp3 in the background during the transfer. Either that's the OS or the Lumia 800, shrug.

2 ways of verifying this: 1. The size of the file on the phone. 2. The fact that random tmp files are being generated in the Transcoded Files Cache folder.

I'd personally rather keep a single collection rather than double it anyway.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1078027-flac-support/#findComment-594878595
Share on other sites
Grand Master

Prince Charming

Posted
Posted

Yeah, that's not really a bad plan, stash the audio in WMA Lossless, and it will lossy convert it at sync time in Zune. I don't really want to get into an audiophile argument, but on a phone, I don't think it's really possible to distinguish lossless from 320kbps WMA. And it will murder your storage.

Native WMA Lossless support would be cool, and like I said, might arrive in WP8, but I wouldn't hold your breath. Third party app might do it.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1078027-flac-support/#findComment-594879153
Share on other sites
Proficient

iKenndac

Posted
Posted

Ignoring the sensibilities of storing lossless files on a device with limited storage and containing a DAC worth pennies at best?

Even if you can't run libFlac directly on the silicon, the FLAC codec is fairly fast to decode so there's technically nothing stopping someone writing a decoder completely in C# in WP's managed environment. It wouldn't be hardware accelerated or as efficient (since it's running in a managed environment) but if someone can write a h264 decoder in JavaScript, someone can write a FLAC decoder in C#!

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1078027-flac-support/#findComment-594879177
Share on other sites
Community Regular

BumbleBritches57

Posted
Posted

Whilst I'm not holding my breath for MS to suddenly support FLAC in WP8 (though it would be cool, and if anything a result of Nokia pressure), does anyone know with all the new app capabilities that will be added such as native code, will apps be able to be written to playback FLAC files?

I hope Microsoft'll include Apple Lossless decoding as well, it's Open Source, there's no reason not to.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1078027-flac-support/#findComment-594879235
Share on other sites
Grand Master

HawkMan

Posted
Posted

That actually doesn't mean it doesn't infringe on any patents, just that so far no one has cared to bother them about it, and that the codec itself is free to implement from them and that it's developed open source. However as far as patents go, it means nothing. And I think you'd see the patent trolls come out if it where ever officially implemented in a larger system like a major OS.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1078027-flac-support/#findComment-594882083
Share on other sites
Community Regular

funkydude

Posted
  • Author
Posted

That actually doesn't mean it doesn't infringe on any patents, just that so far no one has cared to bother them about it, and that the codec itself is free to implement from them and that it's developed open source. However as far as patents go, it means nothing. And I think you'd see the patent trolls come out if it where ever officially implemented in a larger system like a major OS.

Like who exactly? Just look at the amount of companies using FLAC: http://flac.sourceforge.net/news.html

You'd think it would have stirred some attention by now if music from the Beetles, Eagles and Metallica is published using it ;) What are they waiting for, they can sue these giant records labels!! Oh wait, they can't.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1078027-flac-support/#findComment-594882575
Share on other sites
Grand Master

BajiRav

Posted
Posted

Like who exactly? Just look at the amount of companies using FLAC: http://flac.sourceforge.net/news.html

You'd think it would have stirred some attention by now if music from the Beetles, Eagles and Metallica is published using it ;) What are they waiting for, they can sue these giant records labels!! Oh wait, they can't.

Did we see anyone suing giant record labels for using MP3? Did we see anyone suing Microsoft for using MP3? Yes!

There is a difference.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1078027-flac-support/#findComment-594883131
Share on other sites
This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Posts

    • Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 8, Flip 8, Z Fold Wide: Everything you need to know

      By The Werewolf · Posted

      Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 8, Flip 8, Z Fold Wide: Everything you need to know The ONLY thing I need to know is the price, which I know will be way higher than I (and most people) are willing to pay for a phone... so basically nothing here I need to know. PS: Nice job getting that Apple reference to a non-existent and unrevealed product as "competition" in there. Cheque is in the mail.
    • AMD 9070XT

      By Steven P. · Posted

      Well I really think the repasting helped if your higher clocks have returned, maybe the next thing to look at is if there is a problem with your case airflow? I guess this because your 3080 has returned to optimal state, but is still staying too warm, which might suggest it was thermal throttling before you repasted, of which the only logical conclusion could be outside factors.
    • The official Funny Pictures thread

      By Steven P. · Posted

    • Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 8, Flip 8, Z Fold Wide: Everything you need to know

      By Hamid Ganji · Posted

      Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 8, Flip 8, Z Fold Wide: Everything you need to know by Hamid Ganji Galaxy Z Fold 7 - Image via Samsung The next generation of Samsung foldables is set to be unveiled next month at the second Unpacked event of the year. Samsung’s 2026 foldables are not expected to offer significant upgrades over their predecessors, with the Korean firm instead focusing on design refinements and conventional upgrades such as faster processors and better cameras. However, Samsung is reportedly planning to unveil an all-new passport-style foldable this year to rival Apple’s first foldable iPhone, which is expected to debut this September. Here’s a roundup of everything we know about Samsung’s upcoming foldable devices ahead of their official debut. When can we expect Samsung’s new foldables? The Galaxy Z Fold 7 and Z Flip 7 series were unveiled in July, and Samsung is expected to maintain this timeframe in 2026. Based on previous reports from Korean sources, Samsung will hold its Unpacked event on July 22 in London, UK, to pull back the curtain on the Galaxy Z Fold 8 series. The devices are also expected to hit the shelves a few weeks after launch. However, Samsung has yet to announce an official date. A new naming scheme? One of the most interesting changes we might see this year is a new naming scheme for Samsung’s latest foldables. SamMobile reported that since Samsung is expected to unveil three foldables this year, it has adopted a new naming strategy to simplify product identification for customers. Accordingly, the standard Galaxy Z Fold 8 will reportedly be called the Galaxy Z Fold 8 Ultra and will serve as the direct successor to last year’s Galaxy Z Fold 7. The “Ultra” suffix suggests the phone could feature higher-end specifications, such as additional rear camera modules. Samsung’s new passport-style foldable is expected to carry the Galaxy Z Fold 8 name without any suffix. This model is reportedly equipped with two rear cameras. No major changes are expected for the Flip model. Galaxy Z Fold 8 Ultra and Z Flip 8 anticipated specs Rumors over the past few months suggest Samsung is preparing several upgrades for its upcoming foldables, although the devices may continue to rely on larger batteries and faster charging speeds rather than dramatic design changes. The primary focus this year is expected to be the Galaxy Z Fold 8 and its wide-screen design. Galaxy Z Fold 8 Ultra official CAD renders - Image via AndroidHeadlines Here are the anticipated specifications for the Galaxy Z Fold 8 Ultra based on previous leaks: 6.5-inch outer display and 8-inch inner display, 120Hz refresh rate, and 2,600 nits peak brightness Snapdragon 8 Elite Gen 5 processor, paired with 12GB or 16GB of RAM and 256GB, 512GB, or 1TB of storage 4.1mm thickness when unfolded and a weight of 210g 200MP main camera, 50MP ultrawide camera, 10MP or 12MP telephoto camera, 10MP cover camera, and 10MP selfie camera 5,000mAh battery with 45W wired charging Android 17 and One UI 9 As for the Galaxy Z Flip 8, the device is not expected to be a major departure from its predecessor, although it could become slightly slimmer. Expected specifications include: Snapdragon 8 Elite Gen 5 or Exynos 2600 processor 12GB of RAM with 256GB and 512GB storage options 6.9-inch Dynamic AMOLED 2X inner dispaly and 4.1-inch Super AMOLED outer dispaly 50MP main camera, 12MP ultrawide camera, and 10MP selfie camera 4,300mAh battery with 25W wired charging Android 17 and One UI 9 Samsung’s foldables are also expected to launch with Gemini Intelligence, Google’s AI suite for automating tasks in Android ecosystem. Moreover, given current memory and component costs, some Galaxy Z Fold 8 Ultra and Z Flip 8 variants could see a price hike. Galaxy Z Fold 8 adopts a wide-screen design The centerpiece of the upcoming Unpacked event could be the Galaxy Z Fold 8, previously rumored as the Galaxy Z Fold Wide. This model adopts a passport-style form factor and is expected to compete directly with Apple’s iPhone Fold. Galaxy Z Fold 8 official CAD renders - Image via AndroidHeadlines Here’s what to expect: 7.6-inch primary OLED display and 5.4-inch cover display, 120Hz refresh rate, 2,600 nits peak brightness, and 4:3 aspect ratio Snapdragon 8 Elite Gen 5 processor, 12GB or 16GB of RAM, and 256GB, 512GB, or 1TB storage options 4,800mAh battery with 45W wired charging 50MP main camera, 50MP ultrawide camera, and 10MP selfie camera Android 17 and One UI 9 The three new foldable phones are unlikely to be the only devices unveiled at Samsung’s Unpacked event. The company is also expected to introduce the Galaxy Watch Ultra 2 and the Galaxy Watch 9 series.
    • Dopamine 3.0.6

      By Jaybonaut · Posted

      Thanks

  • Recent Achievements

    • Week One Done
      rolfus earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Month Later
      Leroy Jethro Gibbs earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Conversation Starter
      flexorcist earned a badge
      Conversation Starter
    • One Month Later
      AndreaB earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • One Month Later
      agatameier earned a badge
      One Month Later

  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      505
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      196
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      141
    4. 4
      ATLien_0
      89
    5. 5
      Steven P.
      81
    Show More

  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!