How can I disable Journaling on an external drive?


Recommended Posts

Hi Guys,

I am trying to turn off Journaling on an external hard drive currently formatted as HFS+ (Mac OS Extended, Journaled). For some reason my media centre tv will only support HFS+ with journaling turned off.

I've completed a google search, attempted to turn off journaling through Disk Utility etc, still cannot work it out.

Before suggesting that I use another type partition format:

  • I cannot use FAT32 because file size limitations
  • NTFS is not natively supported by OS X for writing files
  • ExFAT would be perfect but is not supported by my media centre

Does anyone know how I can turn off Journaling without deleting the partition?

Thanks!

OS: Lion OS X 10.7.4

With previous OS X / Disk Utility versions you had the option to format a drive as such, but apparently Apple got rid of it in OS X Lion or Snow Leopard. Since you have a 2010 iMac you could try to startup from the OS X Snow Leopard Install DVD and check if the option is still there in Disk Utility. Otherwise you'll need OS X Leopard or some other solution.

Select the disk, press Option and then the "Disable Journal" will appear in the File menu (Press option, keep it pressed and Click File)

If you don't know what "Option" key is, it's the key between the Ctrl and Command key, left of the Apple logo, now sporting a fancy "Alt" text. :-)

With previous OS X / Disk Utility versions you had the option to format a drive as such, but apparently Apple got rid of it in OS X Lion or Snow Leopard. Since you have a 2010 iMac you could try to startup from the OS X Snow Leopard Install DVD and check if the option is still there in Disk Utility. Otherwise you'll need OS X Leopard or some other solution.

With previous OS X / Disk Utility versions you had the option to format a drive as such, but apparently Apple got rid of it in OS X Lion or Snow Leopard. Since you have a 2010 iMac you could try to startup from the OS X Snow Leopard Install DVD and check if the option is still there in Disk Utility. Otherwise you'll need OS X Leopard or some other solution.

I don't know where I put my Snow Leopard discs, haven't needed them for ages. But that might be the only solution.

Select the disk, press Option and then the "Disable Journal" will appear in the File menu (Press option, keep it pressed and Click File)

If you don't know what "Option" key is, it's the key between the Ctrl and Command key, left of the Apple logo, now sporting a fancy "Alt" text. :-)

One of the first things I tried. The option to disable Journaling has been removed from Lion. :(

Select the disk, press Option and then the "Disable Journal" will appear in the File menu (Press option, keep it pressed and Click File)

If you don't know what "Option" key is, it's the key between the Ctrl and Command key, left of the Apple logo, now sporting a fancy "Alt" text. :-)

Wait!

I re-tried this and held Option before clicking on the File menu. It revealed the Disabled Journaling command. Werid thing is, the partition still states it's journaled.

I will see how the drive works in my media centre now...

Thanks

Yes sorry, I tried to convey that you should have it pressed before going into the menu - my bad.

You may have to dismount/mount it before "Info" in the Disk Utility properly shows the state of the journalling. If it doesn't work, there is one other way to disable it by forcing it from the command line.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Posts

    • EU needs the money, and the EUC lawyers dream at night about more of those huge commissions... Personally, if companies do things I don't like I don't purchase or use their products. I can think of few things worse than the horrid specter of government designed & "approved" software. But I guess things are different in the EU. I'd likely feel differently about this stuff if the lawyers did it pro bono, and the billion-dollar fines were rebated to the consumers the EUC claims it is protecting--but that never happens. The bizarre thing is that EU consumers seem unaware that all those fines come back to the companies forced to pay them in higher costs for the goods and services those companies sell them. Why that bit of logic escapes their attention is puzzling. So, now, we just sit back and wait on the next pretext the EUC lawyers come up with to rob these companies whose products no one in the EU is forced to buy and use in the first place. Rinse, repeat. It's become a very addictive habit of the EUC.
    • When companies do "opt-out" it's because they know that no one will opt-in...
    • the chip might be a binned 5090 so no, youre actually getting the 5090
    • How to set custom folder icons in Windows 11 File Explorer by Usama Jawad Although there are many third-party tools like Windhawk, FlyOOBE, DeskScapes 2026, and more that can be used to customize and tweak Windows 11 according to your preferences, many people often forget that the operating system natively offers a lot of configurability too. One such handy option is available inside File Explorer, where you can set custom folder icons to personalize your experience very quickly. File Explorer is an interface that Windows 11 users leverage rather heavily, so it can get quite boring looking at default icons. It can also be a bit tedious reading the text of each item to navigate to the folder you need. In cases like these, custom folder icons can come in quite handy as they allow you to not only personalize File Explorer, but also offer meaningful aesthetics that can make navigation quicker. Here is how to configure custom folder icons in Windows 11: Download icon files (.ico) from a third-party website of your choice. There are lots of free options online, like Icon Archive. You'll also be able to download them directly from Google Images Open File Explorer Navigate to the folder you want to customize Right-click the folder Select Properties Go to the Customize tab Select Change Icon If you want, you can select a native icon from the Windows directory, but for the purpose of this guide, we'll select the third-party .ico file that we downloaded. As such, select Browse Navigate to the .ico file and double-click it Click Apply, followed by OK That's all there is to it! It shouldn't take more than a minute after downloading the .ico file of your choice. The good news is also that you are not married to the icon you set; you can restore it to the default icon by simply selecting Restore Defaults in the interface mentioned in step 8. It's a very easy way to customize File Explorer, with any changes in this regard being quickly reversible. I would also recommend using View > Extra large icons in File Explorer so that you can properly enjoy the aesthetics. You can also download the entire Object Desktop package. Object Desktop includes programs such as Fences, Start11, Groupy, SoundPackager, DeskScapes and Multiplicity. Disclaimer: Neowin's relationship to Stardock
    • Teams on macOS has a major bug for some users, and Microsoft is rolling out guidance by Usama Jawad Teams is one of the most used online communication and collaboration tools especially in enterprise and school environments. It is available on a variety of platforms including Android, iOS, Windows, macOS, and the web. As such, it is a major problem when users on any of the aforementioned platforms get affected. In its Message Center advisory MC1392559, Microsoft acknowledged a bug impacting Teams customers on certain versions of macOS a few weeks ago. Basically, if affected users start sharing their screen, they'll see a black or blank screen, experience interruptions while sharing, and even face complete failure in screen sharing functionality. This is impacting customers using macOS versions older than Tahoe 26.4, and PCs which are resource-constrained on disk and memory. Interestingly, the scope of this issue appears to be limited as Microsoft has only listed Government Community Cloud (GCC), GCC High, and Department of Defense (DoD) as the affected platforms. Since it can be confusing to customers when the bug appears randomly and troubleshooting methods aren't always obvious, Microsoft is working on introducing some in-product guidance that automatically gets shown to users when a screen sharing failure is detected. They'll be asked to retry sharing their screen and will also be requested to update their macOS version, when applicable. If that is not possible, the Redmond tech giant has urged users to apply a mitigation that involves navigating to Teams Settings > General > Screen sharing > Use Mac OS native sharing. A restart isn't required. Regardless, Microsoft has recommended IT admins to inform their helpdesks about this issue, update their internal documentation, communicate the problem across the organization, and update macOS Tahoe 26.4 devices, where possible. The in-product guidance will begin rolling out later this month and should hopefully be available to all by mid-August.
  • Recent Achievements

    • One Month Later
      pahariyaseo earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Week One Done
      pahariyaseo earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Week One Done
      hadiaali45 earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Week One Done
      arone_24 earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Reacting Well
      flexorcist earned a badge
      Reacting Well
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      414
    2. 2
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      143
    3. 3
      Nick H.
      89
    4. 4
      +Edouard
      82
    5. 5
      neufuse
      72
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!