Hardware or Software RAID 1? What best fit for my need?


Recommended Posts

Hi guys, currently I have a machines with these spects below which is running as a server with Windows Server 2012 R2 Std:-

Intel Core2Duo E6750

Asus Commando

4 GB

500 GB X 2 (In RAID 1)

As I meantioned above, the system is currently running in RAID 1 throw the hardware configration. What I am worried about is since this motherboard is old if would be extremly difficult for me to find another motherboard that has the same configration to start the hard drives with it again. With this thought I am starting to think that it would be better for me to switch from the hardware to the software RAID 1 since it will be not throw the hardware and easy for me to start again incase of hardware failer.

Please advise me and tell me what you think before I decide.

Thank,

I'm quoting this but have long held the view that "software" raid is actually better than so called "hardware raid"!

It?s a commonly held myth that hardware RAID is unconditionally better than software RAID. That claim is not true in all cases and is particularly wrong at the low end.
There is no "hardware" RAID. RAID systems are computers running code. All RAID is software RAID. The real issue is where the RAID code is running. In hardware RAID it is running on a dedicated processor. In software RAID it is running on the system processor.
Cheap hardware RAID doesn?t have write-back caching and therefore can?t give any significant performance benefit over software RAID. Note that there are different options for how RAID stripes are laid out which can affect performance, so if a cheap hardware RAID device gives any significant performance benefit over software RAID then it?s probably due to where the blocks happen to be stored working well with your filesystem. Which is of course a benefit you could get from tuning software RAID.

The Mythical CPU Benefits of Hardware RAID:

It?s widely regarded that hardware RAID is faster due to taking the processing away from the CPU. But the truth is that for at least the last 10 years CPUs have been fast enough and in fact it?s often the case that RAID controllers are the bottleneck.

CPU benefits aside, if your OS crashes, hardware RAID will have a better chance at retaining data integrity than software.

Precisely this. In a software RAID setup you're dependent on the drivers and software alone whereas a hardware server level RAID card is engineered and tested for reliability.

"2012 R2 Std"

Really R2 -- when did that come out ;)

Booting off a software raid comes with its own issues btw. Sure if you want to mirror some data partitions, that's pretty straight forward - but actually booting off a software mirror that is done in the OS your booting bit more difficult ;)

Keep in mind that if you use software to create a RAID environment you probably won't be able to access your drives when you boot from some other media like a CD or USB drive. This can really cause havoc if you store you backup files and/or disk images on the software RAID. When the time comes and you need to restore a drive, especially your boot/system drive, you find out that your backups are nowhere to be found. A hardware RAID doesn't have this problem.

I'm quoting this but have long held the view that "software" raid is actually better than so called "hardware raid"!

"It?s a commonly held myth that hardware RAID is unconditionally better than software RAID. That claim is not true in all cases and is particularly wrong at the low end."

You seem to be reading a lot of FUD. I actually addressed a lot of this back in 2009. Of course that statement isn't true in all cases - if you can't afford hardware RAID, it's not true. If you don't need hardware RAID, it's not true. It's great if your CPU can achieve 3 GB/s of ECC calculations - unless you need that memory bandwidth and CPU cycles to actually do something useful. But if all a system does is store data, then it is useful.

"Real" hardware RAID controllers perform the ECC calculations in dedicated hardware. "Real" hardware RAID controllers leverage hardware, firmware, and software to deliver features that will be unmatched in software RAID. A reasonable analogy for a layperson is dedicated vs. onboard (now onchip) graphics. Sure, onboard will give you a desktop, but dedicated will give you gaming!

Also, you're going to need drivers for hardware RAID cards just like you're going to need drivers for software RAID arrays. Drivers for hardware have just been historically easier to come by, but any Linux rescue CD worth the CD it's burned on should be able to activate and mount (if nothing else, read only) your fakeraid/software/hardware RAID arrays.

Sounds like what you need is something cheap, so either fakeraid or software RAID will be a good choice for you. Just be sure that you:

1. Document your configuration

2. Have a recovery procedure in the event a disk fails

3. Have a spare hard drive on hand or as a hot spare (preferably more than one)

4. Periodically verify the array to ensure the contents are correct

5. Perform regular, safe, and secure backups

With a RAID 1 it doesn't matter which hardware/onboard RAID controller you use because both disks are EXACTLY THE SAME, you can freely move between any controller.

WITH RAID 1 in WINDOWS, this is a real PITA. You will need to convert to Dynamic Disk. Dynamic Disk is not a common setup and if you need to use some 3rd Party Tools to repair your Windows installation then your options are going to be very limited in what you can do.

Above all else, BACKUP. RAID is not a replacement for a backup and only a BACKUP will save your ass, a RAID will only get you keep you running temporarily until you replace a broken drive but it does not save you from anything else.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Price Drop: Save 86% on Microsoft Office 2021 Professional Plus lifetime digital license by Steven Parker Today's highlighted deal comes via our Apps + Software section of the Neowin Deals store, where you can save 86% on a lifetime license to Microsoft Office 2021 for Windows. This bundle is for families and small businesses who want classic Office apps and email. It includes Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Outlook, Teams, and OneNote. A one-time purchase installed on 1 Windows PC for use at home or work. Lifetime license for MS Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Outlook, Teams, & OneNote One-time purchase installed on 1 Windows PC for use at home or work Instant Delivery & Download – access your software license keys and download links instantly Free customer service – only the best support! Microsoft Office Professional 2021 (for Windows) includes: Microsoft Office Word Microsoft Office Excel Microsoft Office PowerPoint Microsoft Office Outlook Microsoft Office Teams Microsoft Office OneNote Microsoft Office Publisher Microsoft Office Access No faffing about with subscriptions, just classic apps that don't expire. Good to Know ONE-TIME PURCHASE INSTALLED ON 1 DEVICE Redemption deadline: redeem your code within 30 days of purchase Access options: desktop Full versions No subscriptions – no monthly/annual fees Version: 2021 Updates included* *Support for this version of Office ends on Oct 13, 2026 A lifetime subscription to Microsoft Office 2021 Professional normally costs $219.99, but this deal can be yours for just $29.97, that's a saving of $190. For full terms, specifications, and license info, click the link below. Get Microsoft Office Professional 2021 for just $29.97, or learn more Although priced in U.S. dollars, this deal is available for digital purchase worldwide. Support queries If you have queries or need support for any of the Neowin Deals, please use the contact form here. Neowin Deals are managed and sold by StackCommerce who represent Neowin on an affiliate basis. Why we post these deals We post these because we earn commission on each sale so as not to rely solely on advertising, which many of our readers block. It all helps toward paying staff reporters, servers and hosting costs. So for those that keep moaning and complaining, be thankful we're still online for you to even do that. Other ways to support Neowin Whitelist Neowin by not blocking our ads Create a free member account to see fewer ads Make a donation to support our day to day running costs Subscribe to Neowin - for $14 a year, or $28 a year for an ad-free experience Disclosure: Neowin benefits from revenue of each sale made through our branded deals site powered by StackCommerce.
    • The only reason I want to know where you from is because if you are not from the U.K, then why should you care what we in the U.K do or don't do? Racist I am not, I am fed up with the amount coming over here and feel they can come over here and think we need to support them. Do you know how much it costs this country to support these people coming over here? Even when we give them a place to live it is not good enough. We had a barge that was being used to house immigrants, oh but that was not good enough. A mate said to me at the time, when he was homeless, he would have been happy to live on the barge, instead of ending up sleeping on a bench on the beach. I am not scared to say what my family heritage is, unlike you who is scared to say where they are from or where they live. Father side U.S, mother side Wales, still have family living in the U.S. A mate who sadly died a few years ago, had a load of people from different races recording in his studio, I got on with all of them. Skin colour don't bother me, where they are from don't bother me. Religion don't bother me as long as they don't push it onto me and it is not crazy stuff. I am not religious. But if you are not living in the U.K, then why should you care if we are in the E.U or not? This the problem, too many people poking their noses into where it don't belong. But you believe what you believe, if you think I am racist, then be it, I really do not care. Just grow a pair
    • If he hasn't been able to figure that out, then why is he obsessed with tariffs? Because that's one of the most prominent tools to level the playing field when you have high cost of labor.
    • Microsoft released Windows 11 KB5102558, KB5095615 Setup and Recovery updates by Sayan Sen This past week Microsoft released the newest preview update (C-release) under KB5095093. Alongside those, Microsoft also released new dynamic updates. For those who may not know, dynamic updates bring improvements to the Windows Recovery process in the form of Windows Recovery Environment (WinRE) updates, which are also called Safe OS updates. The dynamic updates also affect the Setup file binaries in the form of Setup updates. These Dynamic Update packages are meant to be applied to existing Windows images prior to their deployment. Dynamic Updates also help preserve Language Pack (LP) and Features on Demand (FODs) content during the upgrade process. VBScript, for example, is currently an FOD on Windows 11 24H2. This time both recovery and setup updates were released for Windows 11. The company writes: "KB5095186: Safe OS Dynamic Update for Windows 11, version 26H1: June 23, 2026 This update makes improvements to the Windows recovery environment (WinRE). After installing this update, the WinRE version installed on the device should be 10.0.28000.2335. KB5102558: Setup Dynamic Update for Windows 11, versions 24H2 and 25H2: June 23, 2026 This update makes improvements to Windows setup binaries or any files that setup uses for feature updates in Windows 11, version 24H2 and Windows 11, version 25H2. KB5095615: Safe OS Dynamic Update for Windows 11, versions 24H2 and 25H2: June 23, 2026 This update makes improvements to the Windows recovery environment (WinRE). After installing this update, the WinRE version installed on the device should be 10.0.26100.8737." Microsoft notes that both the Recovery and Setup updates will be downloaded and installed automatically via the Windows Update channel.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Conversation Starter
      jessse3334 earned a badge
      Conversation Starter
    • Reacting Well
      JuvenileDelinquent earned a badge
      Reacting Well
    • One Month Later
      Excellence2025 earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Week One Done
      Excellence2025 earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Week One Done
      flexorcist earned a badge
      Week One Done
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      507
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      201
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      151
    4. 4
      Steven P.
      73
    5. 5
      macoman
      62
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!