MKV in Windows 8 Video app [sort of]


Recommended Posts

Despite most of what I've read on the internet, it is possible to get the Xbox video app on Windows 8 to open MKV files by following the steps below

1. First we need to add the video app to the 'open with' list for .mkv files follow the original guide here or just enter the following in a admin command prompt

reg add HKCR\.mkv\OpenWithProgids /v "AppXhjhjmgrfm2d7rd026az898dy2p1pcsyt" /t REG_BINARY /f

There is now an option for the video app in the open with menu, however the app will only open not attempt to play the video. Contrary to popular belief however it is possible to get the app to recognise other formats

2. Download and install the Shark007 Windows 8 Codecs here. After the install you will be displayed with the settings menu for the codec pack, select the MKV tab and uncheck the option 'Disable the DivX Media Foundation splitter'.

The video app will now recognise mkv files, however (this is where the "sort of" comes in) most files just throw a format not supported error. if you switch to the now playing screen you will see it list the name of the file, and the length if you try to play the file.

The problem lies in the DivX MKV Media Foundation splitter, it will only play certain profiles and codecs rather than connecting with the entire media foundation library. I have gotten files with mp3 audio to play with no video as per the attached screenshot.

post-468916-0-21181200-1353846797.png

So it is possible to expand the supported formats of the video app, the pressure is now on DivX and the community to make more Media Foundation splitters and codecs available

As a final note, don't expect subtitle support for MKVs anytime soon, the reason it was never supported is because the media foundation video renderer [EVR or Enhanced Video Renderer] doesn't allow for external modifications to the video output (e.g. subtitle overlay)

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1122026-mkv-in-windows-8-video-app-sort-of/
Share on other sites

Or you can just install Haali's Media Splitter - which is NOT a codec and will not interfere with anything else in Windows with respect to the native multiformat decoders - and watch MKV files with Windows Media Player, Media Center, or even the Xbox video app - and no Registry edits are ever required.

Codec packs installed on Windows 7 and 8 are a bad idea in general - they tend to overwrite some crucial media foundation settings (especially with Windows 8 even more so) and the OS's native multiformat decoders already handle 99.9% of the content available online.

The only video format (not container, big difference) the Windows native multiformat decoder can't open or play is Real Media content - it can handle effectively anything else, even QuickTime (without needing to install QuickTime or iTunes). Those decoders in Windows 7 and 8 are absolutely fantastic things, seriously.

Also: container != video format, but that's another thread altogether and a topic that gets many many people very confused anyway.

Haali Media Splitter has played havoc with my system in the past, don't generalise about codec packs, shark is excellent software the windows 8 version is very light and is setup by default to only fill in the gaps.

I know the difference between formats/containers and codecs/splitters.

I posted this, as in every thread I found on the topic, most people had tried and concluded it wasn't possible to add external support to the video app, moreover if these media foundation codecs/splitters were to be created for missing formats (real, flash video, FLAC, Vorbis) and containers (MKV, FLV, real media, OGG) they could be compiled and distributed through the windows store for WindowsRT/ARM devices, which have no other options than the Video app

As others have mentioned, MKV is only a container. A simple remux to MP4, while maintaining streams makes it work fine in Xbox Video. Of course, MP4 does not support multiple streams.

There's a Windows Store app that has been playing MKV just fine, with subtitiles, for several months now - PowerDVD. Fairly expensive, so here's hoping for a free MXPlayer type app in the Store in the coming months.

Or you can just install Haali's Media Splitter - which is NOT a codec and will not interfere with anything else in Windows with respect to the native multiformat decoders - and watch MKV files with Windows Media Player, Media Center, or even the Xbox video app - and no Registry edits are ever required.

Codec packs installed on Windows 7 and 8 are a bad idea in general - they tend to overwrite some crucial media foundation settings (especially with Windows 8 even more so) and the OS's native multiformat decoders already handle 99.9% of the content available online.

The only video format (not container, big difference) the Windows native multiformat decoder can't open or play is Real Media content - it can handle effectively anything else, even QuickTime (without needing to install QuickTime or iTunes). Those decoders in Windows 7 and 8 are absolutely fantastic things, seriously.

Also: container != video format, but that's another thread altogether and a topic that gets many many people very confused anyway.

Well I'm a K-Lite Codec pack user since quite looooong time and there hasn't been a single problem iwth it, Media Player Classic is a real Video Player.

nothing will work with RT, RT is not x86 based, its arm code.

and i use windows 7 codec pack from shark on both windows 7 and windows 8. windows 8 codec pack is useless its missing halli, ffdshow etc...

most video encoding tools like ripbot, multiavchd simply will not work when halli, fddshow are missing.

WMP is ok player, the new metro video is pathetic.

Whats a Codec? I use The KMPlayer =P (I realise that IS a separate app, and not entirely helpful)

If you have your media on a home server, i would also consider using something like PS3MediaServer and transcoding to an acceptable format (I do realise this is not always ideal if your ENTIRE collection was mkv)

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • If I could, I would commemorate it the best way possible: Replacing old machines that are still running Windows XP with something more modern, stable and better.     Noone and nothing should be running Windows XP in 2026.
    • Google's new hand-wave reCAPTCHA can be bypassed with a stock photo by Ivan Jenic Image: Screenshot Google is testing a new reCAPTCHA method that asks you to wave at your camera to prove you're human. So, besides solving puzzles and reading distorted text, you can now use your computer’s camera to pass the verification test. When the hand gesture verification is triggered, your browser asks for camera access and prompts you to perform a simple gesture, like a wave or an open palm. Google says it records a short video of the movement and uses AI to extract 21 hand-knuckle coordinates to complete the verification process. The video is then immediately deleted, and Google swears it doesn't keep it. The process alone can be uncomfortable for people who wouldn’t want their biometric data, which hand scans technically qualify as, recorded. But it gets even more nuanced, as early testers discovered that the new hand-waving reCAPTCHA can be passed with a simple stock image. A user on X tested the new challenge using a stock image of a hand fed through OBS Virtual Camera, and it passed. I wanted to verify it, so I tried the same thing. It took me a few tries and a few stock images, but in the end, I was also able to pass the test. I simply had to readjust the stock image of a generic person waving inside OBS, and Google’s mechanism registered it as a legitimate hand gesture. Once again, it didn’t even have to be a video or an AI-generated hand animation. Given the simplicity of the process, the entire action can be automated in minutes. All it takes is a simple Python script to render the new reCAPTCHA method obsolete. And it doesn’t even have to be an AI bot, which is usually used for solving puzzles and other verification methods. The new reCAPTCHA method is still in its early phase, and Google will, hopefully, update its AI to at least reject still images. However, this incident, combined with users’ initial skepticism about Google’s practices regarding user data, likely won’t make too many people wave at the camera anytime soon.
    • 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 "to fund healthcare and tuition" 🤣🤣🤣🤣 Who do you think you are talking about, some COMMUNIST? We are better than them, doG bless Murica!!! p.s. I'm from a country where government does exactly that, i.e. not form US.
    • Apparently not. I know it is on Edge for business at the moment, but how long will it be before it become on the home version of Edge?
  • Recent Achievements

    • First Post
      carols23 earned a badge
      First Post
    • One Month Later
      Tom Willson earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Apprentice
      Asgardi went up a rank
      Apprentice
    • One Month Later
      sunrisea2milk earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Week One Done
      sunrisea2milk earned a badge
      Week One Done
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      494
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      257
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      151
    4. 4
      Steven P.
      90
    5. 5
      macoman
      66
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!