Grub2 Options ? Advise needed ...


Recommended Posts

Hi, at the moment I have a Triple boot config consisting of Win7, Win8 and Win7. This is how I want it and I like it this way. So, my question is, if I install a new Linux distro is it possible for me to put Grub2 onto a USB stick? This way ( i think ) if I boot my laptop without the USB inserted it will show the Windows boot loader but if I boot with the USB inserted it will load up Grub2 and allow me access to Linux. I'm thinking that this has a 2 way benefit, one it will not screw with the Windows loader and secondly it will protect access to Linux if the USB stick is not present. Is this possible and if so is it just a case of selecting the USB when it comes to the Grub2 install or am I way off the mark? Many thanks.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1131380-grub2-options-advise-needed/
Share on other sites

Yes it is possible, just install your linux distro as normal but do NOT install a boot-loader, or, when booted up mount the USB as /boot, e.g.

mount /dev/sdf1 /boot

and install as normal and I would think it'd install the grub mbr to /dev/sdf.

n_K is correct. You can choose which disk to install the bootloader to from most Linux distro's installers, but its easy to miss the prompt.

You might also consider downloading Super Grub2 Disk and putting that on your flash drive or a CD. It will let you boot most Windows or Linux installations even if the MBR is missing or corrupt.

Having not done this myself, I just want to be clear. I could install the distro of my choice to a partition on my Hard-Drive. And not install grub. That way I can still book directly to windows. However I could install grub onto my USB stick and have it so that if the USB stick is inserted on boot, it will give me the grub boot menu letting me pick either windows or linux?

Having not done this myself, I just want to be clear. I could install the distro of my choice to a partition on my Hard-Drive. And not install grub. That way I can still book directly to windows. However I could install grub onto my USB stick and have it so that if the USB stick is inserted on boot, it will give me the grub boot menu letting me pick either windows or linux?

That is correct. Super Grub2 Disk offers an easy way to do auto-detection of installed operating systems, but you could just as easily have a GRUB installation on a flash drive with a custom menu allowing OS selection. Although there are many variations of methods to accomplish this, everything other than the aforementioned Super Grub 2 Disk require some work in terminal an a minimal working knowledge of GRUB menu scripting. Since most people don't want to do this, as it creates more of a hassle, no distro that I know of makes it "1-click" or "2-click" simple to accomplish. That's why I didn't recommend anything else to the OP. Based on your other posts, I believe that you would be able to pull off a more elegant solution. Let me know if you want me to provide such instructions.

That is correct. Super Grub2 Disk offers an easy way to do auto-detection of installed operating systems, but you could just as easily have a GRUB installation on a flash drive with a custom menu allowing OS selection. Although there are many variations of methods to accomplish this, everything other than the aforementioned Super Grub 2 Disk require some work in terminal an a minimal working knowledge of GRUB menu scripting. Since most people don't want to do this, as it creates more of a hassle, no distro that I know of makes it "1-click" or "2-click" simple to accomplish. That's why I didn't recommend anything else to the OP. Based on your other posts, I believe that you would be able to pull off a more elegant solution. Let me know if you want me to provide such instructions.

well, I would be going with arch, and part of the guide is installing grub. I can probably just modify that step so that instead of installing to /dev/sda1 it installs it to a usb mounted partition. I'll give it a shot tomorrow and let you know

Yep. When installing arch, do NOT make a seperate boot partition on your hard drive, make that on the USB as ext2 and mount that as /mnt/boot, so eg;

mount /dev/sda2 /mnt

mount /dev/sdf1 /mnt/boot

then in the grub commands, use the sdf or USB drive, I'm not sure if you even need to provide the drive anymore or if grub picks it up from what device /boot is mounted on.

Yep. When installing arch, do NOT make a seperate boot partition on your hard drive, make that on the USB as ext2 and mount that as /mnt/boot, so eg;

mount /dev/sda2 /mnt

mount /dev/sdf1 /mnt/boot

then in the grub commands, use the sdf or USB drive, I'm not sure if you even need to provide the drive anymore or if grub picks it up from what device /boot is mounted on.

That is one way to pull it off, but there is a slight problem with that method. Namely, since your kernel is located on a partition on your flash drive, you will need to have it installed and mounted each time you perform a kernel update. Furthermore, when you install a new kernel in most distributions (although not Arch or Gentoo AFAIK), your grub.cfg will be regenerated - potentially causing some inconsistency.

A better method would be to leave /boot on your hard drive, and opt not to write GRUB to the MBR. Then install GRUB to the EXT2 partition on your flash drive, and write a grub.cfg that will automatically launch GRUB from your hard disk (via core.img or by loading the config file). The advantages of this method are that you don't need to have the flash drive mounted to perform kernel updates or anything else related to your system, just to boot it. You can safely remove the flash drive after Linux starts booting because init never mounts the flash drive or requires any files from it. Additionally, you have the option of limiting which installations it will automatically boot by probing for your /boot partition's UUID, including a custom "recovery kernel", or scripting other cool stuff. It takes more work than the first method initially, but its easier in the end (not to mention more elegant, which I believe is the Arch philosophy - and a leading reason why pacman should be put out of its misery).

it will protect access to Linux if the USB stick is not present.

If you have reached a point that someone wants access to your machine and is willing to spend the effort to by-pass any passwords, this will not be enough. The file system needs to be encrypted, sure keep the USB to kick start the process but only know this adds only a layer of irritation. Most likely an attack would occur while the OS was in operation or the machine has left the premise and they probably would not make use of your hardware anyways.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • NASA: This asteroid may not kill us but it probably won't be far off either by Sayan Sen Image by Zelch Csaba via Pexels New observations by NASA's James Webb Space Telescope have eliminated the last remaining impact threat posed by asteroid 2024 YR4, ruling out the possibility that the near-Earth object could strike the Moon in December 2032. NASA said observations collected by Webb on February 18 and 26, 2026, enabled scientists to refine the asteroid's orbit enough to "rule out a chance of lunar impact on Dec. 22, 2032." Instead, asteroid 2024 YR4 is now expected to pass the Moon at a distance of about 13,200 miles (21,200 km). The agency stressed that the update "reflects improved precision in our understanding of where the asteroid is expected to be in 2032 rather than a shift in its orbital path." The announcement closes a remarkable chapter in planetary defence that began in late 2024, when the approximately 60-metre-wide asteroid briefly became the most closely watched near-Earth object in the world. Discovered on December 27, 2024, by the ATLAS telescope in Chile, 2024 YR4 initially appeared to have a small chance of colliding with Earth on December 22, 2032. As astronomers gathered more observations, the impact probability briefly climbed to around 3%—the highest ever recorded for an asteroid of its size—before steadily falling as its orbit became better understood. By early 2025, international observations had ruled out any significant risk to Earth. However, astronomers were left with another possibility: a roughly 4% chance that the asteroid could instead strike the Moon. "The probability that asteroid 2024 YR4 will strike the Moon on 22 December 2032 is now approximately 4%," the European Space Agency (ESA) had said last year, noting that "there is a 96% chance that the asteroid will not impact the Moon." ESA said such an impact, while unlikely, would have presented an extraordinary scientific opportunity. "It is a very rare event for an asteroid this large to impact the Moon – and it is rarer still that we know about it in advance. The impact would likely be visible from Earth, and so scientists will be very excited by the prospect of observing and analysing it," said Richard Moissl, Head of ESA's Planetary Defence Office. "It would certainly leave a new crater on the surface. However, we wouldn't be able to accurately predict in advance how much material would be thrown into space, or whether any would reach Earth," he added. The asteroid also exposed an important blind spot in planetary defence. Because 2024 YR4 approached Earth from the direction of the Sun, it remained hidden from ground-based telescopes until after its closest approach. "We looked into how Neomir would have performed in this situation, and the simulations surprised even us," Moissl said. "Neomir would have detected asteroid 2024 YR4 about a month earlier than ground-based telescopes did. This would have given astronomers more time to study the asteroid's trajectory and allowed them to much sooner rule out any chance of Earth impact in 2032." He added, "As an infrared telescope, like Webb, Neomir would have also immediately given us a much better estimate for the asteroid's size, which is very important for assessing the significance of the hazard." The latest NASA observations underscore the value of space-based infrared telescopes in tracking faint asteroids. According to NASA, Webb made "among the faintest ever observations of an asteroid," extending the object's observational record by nearly eight months at a time when it had become too faint for other telescopes. That additional data allowed scientists to eliminate the remaining uncertainty surrounding its 2032 flyby. Although asteroid 2024 YR4 is now confirmed to pose no threat to either Earth or the Moon, scientists say its discovery remains one of the most significant real-world tests of the international planetary defence system, demonstrating how continued observations can rapidly transform an object once considered hazardous into one whose future path is known with high confidence. Source: NASA, ESA This article was generated with some help from AI and reviewed by an editor. Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, this material is used for the purpose of news reporting. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
    • Yup. Google is just scraping the entire internet for their own ad profits without sharing revenue with the sources. It's obviously stealing, but since these sites depend upon Google's search scraps to survive... As for me, I just stopped using Google for anything except Reddit searches. If Reddit's own search wasn't complete crapola, I'd never use Google search again.
    • I had a feeling this was coming. Picked up my first Mac ever last Saturday. Glad I did.
    • In a major surprise there is actually some good deals for the first time in years. At least for me.
  • Recent Achievements

    • Conversation Starter
      Admir earned a badge
      Conversation Starter
    • First Post
      The_Focal_Point earned a badge
      First Post
    • Apprentice
      daryld went up a rank
      Apprentice
    • Contributor
      Carltonbar went up a rank
      Contributor
    • One Month Later
      The_Focal_Point earned a badge
      One Month Later
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      419
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      170
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      130
    4. 4
      Xenon
      69
    5. 5
      neufuse
      69
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!