NeoGamr as a computer games only site, an evaluation


Recommended Posts

So it's now been quite some time since NeoGamr changed to focus on just PC gaming.

Now lets see if this has really been a good or even necessary change.

Firstly I was skeptical of the whole change to start with. the idea was to focus the site. Of course the problem was that the site had very few visitors to start with so narrowing the focus of a site with very few visitors to start with seems counterproductive.

From what I can see since then, Visitations to the site have not really increased, there's still barely a handful of comments and many topics are never commented at all. Meanwhile at the same time. a lot of big and important console gaming news have come and gone, news that could have been used to pull traffic to NeoGamr. But instead Neowin insist on keeping the site focused on PC gaming. At the same time those same big gaming news have been posted on the Neowin frontpage.

The irony in this is that the big news that have been posted on Neowin have pulled a lot of visits and comments, while the ones posted on Neogamr draws nothing.

So then it seems that either neogamr should again become a site for all gaming news, console and PC alike, especially now at the dawn of a new generation. alternatively, drop the whole neogamr project and pull gaming back as a category on Neowin where the news get lots of visits and comments.

As it is right now I, as I guess many others, see little reason to visit Neogamr. with the limited amount of gaming news I can't go there for all my gaming news, and the PC gaming news is generally later. Had the site had all gaming news I wouldn't have minded if it was later than other sites as it could be my one stop gaming news site. In addition the lack of any discussion in the comment section also makes me less interested in visiting. As such it would make most sense to just merge Neogamr back into Neowin where there's healthy visitors and discussion, that or at the very least make Neogamr an all gamign site and make the connection with neowin a lot stronger and cross link news posts between Neogamr and Neowin.

What was the reason for straying away from consoles? Fanboys?

I think most of the staff besides Larry are more PC focussed, and it's a lot of work to cover both realms.

If they want a good run they'd best spend time following the Playstation Event on the 20th and GDC/E3. Thing is though in general, gaming news sites are everywhere, it's a very saturated website market.

The irony in this is that the big news that have been posted on Neowin have pulled a lot of visits and comments, while the ones posted on Neogamr draws nothing.

It also seems to me that sometimes stories that are on the NeoGamr site are put on after they've been in the gaming forums. Plus, considering the fact you can just visit https://www.neowin.net/forum/forum/296-neogamr-news/ and see the titles and choose not to bother going to neogamr.net doesn't help.

I think the only time I check the neogamr is to look at weekend sales.

Here is some of my opinions,

1: broad subjects sometimes can reduce viewership vs focused subjects. The traffic and audience would be the decider of the approperiate change. I would agree that PC gaming would drive more traffic based on the fact traffic competition would be reduced.

2: This would be opinion for lack of growth (knowing we have not used any shared metrics to determine this), people are going to where traffic exists. I.e. why would someone go to a social site where only a small amount of social activity exists?

My first assumption would be that traffic sent to NeoGamr primarily is driven from Neowin, which would raise the question: Why would one leave Neowin where all their friends operate within and already has active discussions for a new site where this is not the case?

I do not think the question is: Whether NeoGamr's focus change is a problem but more that was segmenting Neowin in the first place was a good strategy when the subject is clearly already handled.

Since money and time was spent I would of invested in strengthening the offerings within the current Neowin gaming forums. Long term costs would have been reduced, resources pooled, traffic shared. We could of worked within the already existing successes and geared more for the audience.

I'm quite pleased with this stance. Too much of the Internet seems to cater specifically to console junkies these days, it's nice to see someone that gives PC gamers some attention.

NeoGamr has changed?

That's the problem for me. I can't comment on NeoGamr due to work filters. It was a shame for me, as I used to enjoy reading the articles. Now I just go straight to the gamer's hangout for information.

I'm quite pleased with this stance. Too much of the Internet seems to cater specifically to console junkies these days, it's nice to see someone that gives PC gamers some attention.

And how does also having console news prevent that ? right now you have a basically dead site with few visitors and no traffic or discussion in the comments. people who play both PC games and console games don't go there because it only caters to one selection and has no traffic.

At the end of the day, having neogamr as such a focused site, will just mean there isn't going to be a neogamr.

Actually the time to drag in the console news is now, before launch, this when the rumor mill is the hottest. after launch the rumors are gone and you're left with just regular game news.

Seems to me like the rumors just recirculate the same crap for page views.

BREAKING NEWS: THE SAME BREAKING NEWS WE HAD FOUR MONTHS AGO! Woo!

Well, it's a news site. The point is to post news people want to read. Like it or not. People want rumors about next gen consoles, more than news about current games.

Also there has been a lot of new stuff in the rumors the last few months.

https://www.neowin.net/news/bungie-reveals-footage-of-first-post-microsoft-game-destiny

Another f the many recent examples of why the pc only focus of neogamr needs to be rethought, or the whole neogamr needs to be put down.

I've only ever dropped into it to skim over a news article.

I would prefer it merged back with Neowin - where I feel it belongs. :)

As it is, that's the best decision. Look at the comment section on that article I posted. It's full of comments and discussion. It has more visits and comments than all of neogamr's articles over a month.

Just roll the gaming section back not neowin and call neogamr a failure. Or duplicate the neowin gaming section with neogamr, and make it all gaming news,

As it is, that's the best decision. Look at the comment section on that article I posted. It's full of comments and discussion. It has more visits and comments than all of neogamr's articles over a month.

Just roll the gaming section back not neowin and call neogamr a failure. Or duplicate the neowin gaming section with neogamr, and make it all gaming news,

Or instead of duplicating the exact content, they could just create a link on neowin front page so it can refer it to neogamr.

Somewhere, at some point, there is a big "I told you so" coming. All of these concerns were expressed when it was announced they would be breaking NeoGamr off into it's own site. Aside from the ridiculous name (my personal opinion of course), it really didn't do anything to spur traffic as it was apparently intended to do. The whole "Let's officially become a gaming news site, but not bother with most of the news in the industry!" wasn't really a sound plan...

To be honest, I never even saw the announcement of the site's intention to shift focus to PC games. It's definitely not a sound decision, especially when the true next-gen consoles are very likely to be released this year. And I fully agree with you, HawkMan; I think it'd be best if NeoGamr was just merged back into the main Neowin site. It wouldn't hurt as well to turn to some of the Gamers Hangout regulars for help on some aspects, like articles, and the podcast. I reached out a few times in the past to help out with the podcast, but nothing ever came to fruition; I'd still love to give it a shot though. :)

Since we no longer are doing the podcast I was thinking of starting to write some stuff again but forgot it was a PC only focus. That pretty much eliminates most of what I would want to write about.

NeoGamr, as a gaming site, has ZERO personality. You can get gaming news anywhere, what drives people to sites like Giant Bomb are the people that run it.

I hadn't even realised NeoGamr had changed focus to PC gaming, and I try and make an effort to click on it at least a few times a week.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • With the current hardware prices Microsoft should lift the restriction. Then if you have the correct TPM then allow you to use X feature, if you don't have the correct TPM then don't but still actually let you run windows. 11. With a disclaimer during install that X features would be unavailable.
    • It's good for recycling of course. But commence inflation of a second hand RAM bubble and price gouging on DDR 4 inventory in 3... 2... 1...
    • Bypassed Windows 11 shows surprising stability on ancient, completely unsupported hardware by Sayan Sen When Windows 11 was first released, one of the most complained-about issues with the new desktop Microsoft OS was its higher system requirements, which pushed many relatively modern and powerful processors and devices onto the officially unsupported list. Thankfully, they have not been updated again for the base OS, though systems require four times the memory and storage if they want to run AI-powered apps and features. As such, Windows 11 technically runs on 4GB of memory, and there is no imposed restriction on the generation of memory it supports. Speaking of memory, prices are extremely high nowadays for hardware, especially DDR5 and DDR4 kits due to the current silicon shortage, and there are also reports of it affecting DDR2 as well, and it might only be a matter of time before even DDR1 gets affected. Before that could happen, an enthusiast took an ancient DDR1-based system and decided to try out Windows 11 on it to see how well the modern OS would fare on such hardware. The system runs an outdated graphics card interface standard based on AGP, or Advanced Graphics Port, called AGP 3.0 or AGP8x. AGP was essentially succeeded by the modern PCI Express (PCIe) bus standard. The user behind the experiment is retro hardware enthusiast Omores, who built the system around an ASRock ConRoe865PE motherboard based on Intel's i865PE chipset from way back in 2003, around the time when AGP was still in fashion. What made this board special back in the day was its unusual support for newer Core 2 Duo and even Core 2 Quad processors while still retaining older DDR1 memory support and an AGP8X graphics slot, making it an ideal bridge or link between two vastly different generations. Powering the machine was Intel's Core 2 Quad Q6600 alongside 3GB of DDR1 RAM and an ATI Radeon HD 4650 AGP graphics card, one of the final and most capable GPUs released for the aging AGP interface. While installing Windows 11 itself was relatively easy by bypassing Microsoft's hardware checks, getting the graphics card fully functional proved to be some challenge. Microsoft had quietly dropped native AGP support after the earliest releases of Windows 10, meaning newer versions of Windows no longer include the necessary Graphics Address Remapping Table (GART) drivers required for proper AGP acceleration. Without them, AGP graphics cards typically boot up, though with limited functionality, and can often throw a Code 43 error in Device Manager. To work around the limitation, Omores extracted Intel's legacy AGP440 SYS driver from an early Windows 10 release and paired it with a modified INF file so Windows 11 would correctly recognize the chipset. Following this and combined with AMD's final 64-bit Catalyst AGP drivers from 2012, the Radeon HD 4650 was able to operate with full AGP 8X acceleration intact. The result was said to be surprisingly usable for hardware that is over two decades old. Hardware-accelerated H.264 video playback worked correctly and benefited apps like Firefox, while legacy applications and games ran without major graphical issues. The system also successfully completed the 3DMark 2001 benchmark, although performance naturally lagged behind what the same hardware achieves under Windows 7, which is significantly lighter than Windows 11. There was, however, one unavoidable limitation as Microsoft's Windows 11 version 24H2 introduces a mandatory SSE4.2 CPU instruction requirement that cannot be bypassed through installer modifications or registry tweaks. Since no AGP-era processor supports SSE4.2, Windows 11 version 23H2 effectively becomes the final release capable of running on such systems. Regardless, it is still a very cool feat and quite fascinating to see just how stable Windows 11 turned out to be on such unfamiliar hardware. Source: Omores (Patreon) via O_MORES (Reddit)
    • That will only really help other players that are also responsible for creating the problem.
    • Well, it's good to know that they have found a workaround to a problem that they helped create, I guess...
  • Recent Achievements

    • Reacting Well
      NovaEdgeX earned a badge
      Reacting Well
    • Week One Done
      NovaEdgeX earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Year In
      BA the Curmudgeon earned a badge
      One Year In
    • Conversation Starter
      rosiecharles earned a badge
      Conversation Starter
    • First Post
      KMilenkoski1202 earned a badge
      First Post
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      538
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      266
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      151
    4. 4
      Steven P.
      98
    5. 5
      macoman
      66
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!