11 replies to this topic

[Michael K. Hansen]

Hi All

I am putting together a machine for personal use, which is based on a pre-built machine I got a good deal on. Unfortunately the deal only included the built-in HD graphics which is bit light for my taste, so I am looking to change that.

The current spec's of the machine are:

CPU: i7-3770
RAM: 20 GB
Storage: 180 GB Intel 520 SSD + 3 TB HDD
Graphics: Intel HD
OS: Windows

My main reason for adding some discrete graphics is some light and occasional gaming, but I do not play the latest and greatest games. Most of the time is used with browsing, programming and a little photo editing.

For more specific requirements I have, in order of importance:

• Low noise. It does not have to be silent, but low enough noise level not to stand out.
  
• Brand. A proven brand (ASUS, Sapphire, etc) and there will be no OC of the system or graphics card.
  
• Size. It can be full length and dual-slot if needed.
  
• Price. Price is not the deal breaker, but I don't want to pay for the latest and greatest.

I was looking mostly at AMD Radeon card, as I have had those in the past, but the Nvidia 600 series seems to be quite powerful and not so noisy.

Let me know what your experiences and recommendations are.

[Tyler R.]

If all you're doing is light gaming, get yourself an NVIDIA 610. It's a lot better than any integrated graphics to my knowledge. Or would you like something more?

[Astra.Xtreme]

Depends on your budget, I guess. For around $200, the GTX 660 is a good choice. For a little bit more, the AMD 7870 is a good one too.

This list might help a bit:
http://www.videocard...h_end_gpus.html

[threetonesun]

660 or a 7850. They're both single power'd units are will be relatively quite. Beyond that you're starting to drop cash on the "latest and greatest".

[Astra.Xtreme]

Tyler R., on 07 March 2013 - 18:39, said:

If all you're doing is light gaming, get yourself an NVIDIA 610. It's a lot better than any integrated graphics to my knowledge. Or would you like something more?

Actually his Intel HD 4000 (integrated) is more powerful than a 610.

[Michael K. Hansen]

Thanks for the quick replies, and the G3D Mark score. I've never been a fan of on-board or built-in graphics, and a score of ~450 for the HD4000, even my phone can do better.

My main problem is the noise of the card, as it difficult to estimate and you need to dig into the reviews to see what it is like. I was thinking to stay away from anything that required additional power connections, because of the logic more power = more cooling = more noise.

At the moment I am looking at Radeon 7750 cards, with 1 or 2 GB of memory. Popular choices seems to be MSI, Club3D and Sapphire.

Any brands I should focus on for lower noise?

[threetonesun]

Michael K. Hansen, on 07 March 2013 - 19:28, said:

Thanks for the quick replies, and the G3D Mark score. I've never been a fan of on-board or built-in graphics, and a score of ~450 for the HD4000, even my phone can do better.

My main problem is the noise of the card, as it difficult to estimate and you need to dig into the reviews to see what it is like. I was thinking to stay away from anything that required additional power connections, because of the logic more power = more cooling = more noise.

At the moment I am looking at Radeon 7750 cards, with 1 or 2 GB of memory. Popular choices seems to be MSI, Club3D and Sapphire.

Any brands I should focus on for lower noise?

The 7750 is a waste of money. Also your logic is a bit flawed, the noise really comes down to a combination of power use and the fans used. Most of the popular mid range cards (7770, 7850, 650Ti and 660) are relatively low power, depending on the brand will depend on the amount of noise they make. In general, the better the brand the better the fan.

For reference, I have a 660, and I can't hear it over my CPU fan.

[YounGMessiah]

560 Ti is decent

[Detection]

The 7870 is nice bang for buck, I have my machine on the floor to the right of me and I can only hear the case fans, even stressed to death with benchmarks I rarely see the temp pass 61c this time of year, before it got so cold 70c~ was the highest I saw it, but I've also given my case a good clean since then

[Astra.Xtreme]

All the modern cards do really well with keeping the noise down. I used to run GTX 570s in SLI, and they got kind of loud when gaming. I now have a 680 and it doesn't get loud at all.

Regardless, the noise comes down to how sound-proof your case is. If it's a big concern of yours, there are special cases that are made with sound-proofing materials. You can also buy a watercooler for your CPU and quieter case fans.

[Tyler R.]

Astra.Xtreme, on 07 March 2013 - 18:44, said:

Actually his Intel HD 4000 (integrated) is more powerful than a 610.

Is it really? That tells you how much I know about Intel stuff. My apologies.

[Michael K. Hansen]

Big thanks to all of you for giving advise, and especially for setting me straight on power, cooling and noise. Perhaps I should consult you more often!

Old habits die hard, so I ordered an Radeon 7870, and hoping for it to be quiet.

In the meantime enjoy the weekend, and for those who are old enough have a virtual beer.