So about the beta...

By Cereal Bawks
in The Fast Ring (Insider Previews)

 Share

Recommended Posts

Collaborator

Cereal Bawks

Posted
Posted

Things are still unclear about how it'll roll.

It's kinda curious, they're already spinning the escrow builds and right now the word still seems to be "late February" for public release. Considering this short remaining timespan, it's kind of curious that there haven't been any invites for a techbeta yet. I doubt that these happen in secret, since there's always people bragging about getting one.

The public beta's going to be soon, that's for sure, because Microsoft wants app availability for RTM. But I can't see how an public only beta is good for gathering feedback.

Also, why's everything so quiet about Office 15?! You'd think they'll release it in tandem with Win8, considering its metrofication.

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1054922-so-about-the-beta/
Share on other sites
Grand Master

Chris123NT

Posted
Posted

There will not be a techbeta for Windows 8. The entire team at Microsoft that used to run the windows beta programs are no longer with the company. You can thank Sinofsky for this. The days of actually testing and having your feedback listened to are over. You have better chances of Apple listening to your feedback.

Grand Master

Dot Matrix

Posted
Posted

There will not be a techbeta for Windows 8. The entire team at Microsoft that used to run the windows beta programs are no longer with the company. You can thank Sinofsky for this. The days of actually testing and having your feedback listened to are over. You have better chances of Apple listening to your feedback.

But they HAVE been listening to us... Over on the Build 8 blog, TONS of feedback has been given. That's why all these changes have occured in Windows 8.

Veteran

greenwizard88

Posted
Posted

Heh, exactly what didn't want to hear. Which is curious, since there was a techbeta with Office 2007, when he was at the helm of it. Not sure about his involvement in Office 2010.

Office is predictable. Windows must compete with Apple's marketing. This means Windows needs to be marketed just as well, if not better, than OS X. Office doesn't need to be marketed, they just need to not screw it up like they did with Vista.

Grand Master

Chris123NT

Posted
Posted

But they HAVE been listening to us... Over on the Build 8 blog, TONS of feedback has been given. That's why all these changes have occured in Windows 8.

Go look at the posts about the start screen, and the feedback in the comments asking for CHOICE to disable it. They made a later post balking at giving the user choice. I don't define that as listening to feedback.

Grand Master

Dot Matrix

Posted
Posted

Go look at the posts about the start screen, and the feedback in the comments asking for CHOICE to disable it. They made a later post balking at giving the user choice. I don't define that as listening to feedback.

Ok, but think about that, if Microsoft gaves users choice into every little quirk in the OS, we'd still have an OS that ran like Windows 95, and computing would be perpetually stuck in the past. They're trying to move computing in new directions, and to do that, sometimes a push is needed.

Not only that, but Microsoft wants to move towards unification. Take a look at XBox and Windows Phone. They both have the same UI. It's going to take some getting used to for everyone, but I think it'll work out just fine.

Collaborator

Cereal Bawks

Posted
  • Author
Posted

They have similar UIs, not the same. On the Xbox, it's just a coat with pseudo 3D layout, which turns to plain old previous UI when going past it. Windows Phone is as plain as it can be (a single accent color, no gradients, no shadows), Windows 8 is colors all over the damn place.

Veteran

REM2000

Posted
Posted

Ok, but think about that, if Microsoft gaves users choice into every little quirk in the OS, we'd still have an OS that ran like Windows 95, and computing would be perpetually stuck in the past. They're trying to move computing in new directions, and to do that, sometimes a push is needed.

Not only that, but Microsoft wants to move towards unification. Take a look at XBox and Windows Phone. They both have the same UI. It's going to take some getting used to for everyone, but I think it'll work out just fine.

I can understand that every setting in Windows would be cumbersome, but a big change such as the start menu wouldn't be too hard to implement. This would allow people to adjust to the new changes, to transition. Some people like to use their computer is a particular way, this is a strength of windows that it is so customisable.

Grand Master

firey

Posted
Posted

Ok, but think about that, if Microsoft gaves users choice into every little quirk in the OS, we'd still have an OS that ran like Windows 95, and computing would be perpetually stuck in the past. They're trying to move computing in new directions, and to do that, sometimes a push is needed.

Not only that, but Microsoft wants to move towards unification. Take a look at XBox and Windows Phone. They both have the same UI. It's going to take some getting used to for everyone, but I think it'll work out just fine.

The problem is, that just because something looks the same doesn't make it better. I think, and truly feel, and believe that the current Windows 7 interface is perfect. I like the fact that folder up is back in W8, but I don't like Metro, or tiles, or the ribbon, so no ammount of time, and especially no forced push into it is going to ever make me like it.

Collaborator

Cereal Bawks

Posted
  • Author
Posted

When I used WDP, the only point in time I had to deal with the Metro homescreen is right after booting the system up. From then on, just as right now with Windows 7, all my necessary tools are pinned to the task bar or linked from the desktop. You don't need to see it, if you don't want to.

Collaborator

soulburner

Posted
Posted

There will not be a techbeta for Windows 8. The entire team at Microsoft that used to run the windows beta programs are no longer with the company. You can thank Sinofsky for this. The days of actually testing and having your feedback listened to are over. You have better chances of Apple listening to your feedback.

So the days of Microsoft giving free copies to beta testers are over too? I remember how I envied the Windows 7 and Office 2007 (or 2010?) testers when I heard they got a copy...

Veteran

Owen W Veteran

Posted
  • Veteran
Posted

Things are still unclear about how it'll roll.

It's kinda curious, they're already spinning the escrow builds and right now the word still seems to be "late February" for public release. Considering this short remaining timespan, it's kind of curious that there haven't been any invites for a techbeta yet. I doubt that these happen in secret, since there's always people bragging about getting one.

The public beta's going to be soon, that's for sure, because Microsoft wants app availability for RTM. But I can't see how an public only beta is good for gathering feedback.

Also, why's everything so quiet about Office 15?! You'd think they'll release it in tandem with Win8, considering its metrofication.

Most of these tech beta's have been killed because of the sheer amount of leaks. They'll only release it as a public release when they're ready to avoid things getting out before they want them to. Microsoft is slowly but surely becoming as quiet as Apple, and you can see why. Leaks hurt them.

Mentor

pack34

Posted
Posted

They could just run the techbeta next to the public one, similar to what happened with Windows 7. I'm mostly concerned that there isn't a proper feedback channel anymore, that you can run focus tests with.

Speaking of the Win7 beta. I didn't pay attention to it when I was an undergrad. Did they have the beta downloadable via MSNDAA? Or did they only allow a specified number of people apply?

Grand Master

Chris123NT

Posted
Posted

So the days of Microsoft giving free copies to beta testers are over too? I remember how I envied the Windows 7 and Office 2007 (or 2010?) testers when I heard they got a copy...

Yes, that's all over as well. At the time we knew 7 was the last hoorah for that one. It was one hell of a fight internally to give the beta testers a free copy. Sinofsky didn't want to.

Mentor

pack34

Posted
Posted

Yes, that's all over as well. At the time we knew 7 was the last hoorah for that one. It was one hell of a fight internally to give the beta testers a free copy. Sinofsky didn't want to.

However, there is supposedly going to be a consumer preview. We may not have a big impact on the finished product but they are going to release something to someone.

Grand Master

Ghost5525

Posted
Posted

Go look at the posts about the start screen, and the feedback in the comments asking for CHOICE to disable it. They made a later post balking at giving the user choice. I don't define that as listening to feedback.

Considering most people DONT want this horrible UI anyway, this completely cuts out the middle man being us. No testers, we can do what we want mentality.

Veteran

Aethec

Posted
Posted

I think part of the policy for answering comments on the B8 blog is "don't answer dumb questions".

"Will we be able to disable the start screen and all things Metro related?" is dumb. Microsoft gives high priority to backwards compatibility. The old Start Menu was there for nine years before they removed it in Win7.

This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Posts

    • The Trump administration doesn't want you to use OpenAI's GPT-5.6 without its approval

      By monterxz · Posted

      You sound like some eastern Ukrainians before the war: "I didn't vote for USSR disbanding - I want Ukraine to be part of Russia again" 🤣
    • Uninstalr 3.1

      By Copernic · Posted

      Uninstalr 3.1 by Razvan Serea Introducing Uninstalr: Easy to use and very accurate software uninstaller for Windows. It can uninstall multiple apps at the same time and we think it’s pretty cool. Developed with expertise by Macecraft Software - the minds behind jv16 PowerTools. Key Features Batch uninstall many apps at the same time. Supports unattended uninstallation of apps. Supports monitoring of new software installations. Also detects portable apps and previously uninstalled software leftovers. Shows all the data added to your system by installed software on a file by file basis. Shows all the data it will remove before starting the uninstallation. Filter and search the list of installed software. According to our benchmark, Uninstalr is the most accurate software uninstaller by leaving the least amount of leftovers when uninstalling apps. Supports detection and uninstallation of Microsoft Store, Steam, Big Fish Game System, Chocolatey, NuGet and Ninite installed software. Supports Windows Dark Mode. Supports Windows 11, 10, 8 and 7. Comes with these translations builtin: Chinese Simplified, Chinese Traditional, Czech, Danish, English, Filipino, Finnish, French, German, Greek, Hindi, Hungarian, Indonesian, Italian, Japanese, Korean, Malay, Norwegian, Polish, Portuguese, Romanian, Slovak, Spanish, Swedish, Thai, Turkish, Ukrainian and Vietnamese. Has a single executable file portable version and a normal setup version. Uninstalr is freeware, lightweight and easy to use. No bells and whistles, no nonsense. Uninstalr’s custom uninstallation engine has a dedicated support for the detection and uninstallation of 15 types of apps: Normal Windows apps Microsoft Store apps Portable apps Chocolatey apps Ninite apps PortableApps.com apps Steam games EA App games Epic Games Store games Riot platform games GOG Galaxy games WarGaming.net games Battle.net games itch.io games Big Fish platform games Uninstalr 3.1 changelog: Key Changes Uninstalr now starts and shows the list of installed apps faster after the initial scan has been completed, and with much smaller memory usage. Uninstalr now detects and highlights apps that automatically start with Windows. Greatly improved the detection of portable apps. Improvements New feature: Uninstalr now detects and highlights apps that automatically start with Windows. New feature: Uninstalr now highlights possible leftovers and apps from Russia and China. This can be disabled from the Settings. New feature: A new filter that allows you to show only software that is installed to other than the system drive. New feature: Users can now select to always do the deepest and the most accurate scan for installed apps, at the cost of the analysis taking a longer time. Greatly improved the detection of portable apps, such as added dedicated support for MiTeC, EZ Tools and SysInternals tools. Improved support for portable apps installed via Windows System Control Center (WSCC). NirSoft portable apps are now listed with "NirSoft" prefix for easier identification. Improved the speed of uninstalling apps. The main installed software listing search will now find "Xbox GameBar" if you search for "Game bar" and vice versa. The tooltip now displays more detailed information of the installed apps, such as its registry key and uninstaller path. The links in the About section now look more like clickable links. The main menu is now more clearly indicated in the main user interface. Microsoft Teams Meeting Add-in for Microsoft Office ships with some Windows 11 installations and is now considered a builtin Windows app and only listed if builtin Windows apps filter is enabled. Added a Help button to the main user interface that opens the help section of the website. Added an option not to close Uninstalr after uninstallation. If you open the Uninstalr website from the app, the website now receives the version number of your current Uninstalr version and warns you if you are using anything but the latest version. Improved the accuracy of the New Software Monitor. Improved confirmation messages for Steam and other platform related uninstalls. Improved the uninstallation performance of Steam games. Fixes: Known bug fixed: Some installed app names are capitalized incorrectly, such as "CCleaner Portable" is listed as "ccleaner portable". Known bug fixed: Some apps can be listed twice, for example, Smart Defrag can be listed once as Smart Defrag and then Smart Defrag Home. Known bug fixed: On the pre-uninstallation screen, the Scripts checkbox can be checked by default on Dark Mode but not on the normal mode. Known bug fixed: Perform Deep Analysis can be started only by clicking the button, not via the Right Click menu, main menu or F4 keyboard shortcut. Muse Hub could be incorrectly listed as Adobe Muse. SyncTrayzor was incorrectly detected as two unrelated software, SyncTrayzor and Syncthing. Smart Defrag was incorrectly listed twice as Smart Defrag 11 and Smart Defrag Home. It was possible to enter non-printable characters to the search input boxes of the main screen, and the path listing screen, which caused the UI to look funny. Changing the translation from Settings, especially many times in a row, caused the UI to distort. If you had multiple instances of portable apps on your system, such as the 64b and 32b versions of the same portable app, typically only one of them was detected, not both. In some very rare cases, Uninstalr UI could start with random characters in its search input boxes, which could make the UI look rather confusing. This was a rare issue, only reported by two users. The pre-uninstallation screen could display non-existing paths for example as the software's installation directory or main exe file. This was a cosmetic issue. New Software Monitor cannot detect the installation of Claude. Selecting all the found software made the UI look funny with the top panel covering everything else (because the names of all the selected software were listed there). Sometimes a Steam game could be listed a normal app instead of a Steam game. If the system restart after an uninstallation is delayed, e.g. because of Windows Updates being installed, this additional delay is incorrectly added to the time how long the uninstallation process took. This cosmetic bug could cause the program incorrectly report an uninstallation time longer than the actual uninstallation time. Uninstalling Minecraft could simply fail. The Only scan the system drive for installed apps setting does not fully work. If some apps are installed to a non system drive and this setting is enabled, the app could still be detected and listed on the main user interface. Changing any settings could also incorrectly alter the Only Scan The System Drive For Installed Apps setting. Microsoft OneDrive and Copilot are not always detected. If you enter something to the search filter field, then select the text and press the Delete key, this triggers the Uninstall button click even if your intent was to delete the text input. If you press the F5 key to refresh the screen during the uninstallation loading screen, the program will crash. If you enabled some setting, such as "Do not analyze installed app installation sizes", it could automatically be unchecked later. Uninstalr doesn't warn you if you try to remove Fortec antivirus. There should be a warning if user attempts to remove any antivirus or antimalware type program. Such programs should not be uninstalled using a third party uninstaller, as they are typically protected against automated uninstallation, for security reasons. With "Do not analyze installed app installation sizes" option checked from the Settings, Uninstalr could still display some installation size related elements in the UI which was confusing. The "Only scan the system drive" option moved under Improve Scan Speed from the General settings. If two software have the exact same name and version number, selecting both of them for uninstallation fails because only one is actually selected. Sorting the installed apps by size sometimes fails and the order is incorrect. The "Don't show which paths are currently analyzed" did not work correctly - some parts of the UI still show the currently analyzed path with this setting checked. The "Don't list software less than 10 MB" filter did not work correctly - some apps smaller than 10 MB could still be listed. Uninstalr could start very quickly and display an empty list of detected apps. Restarting the app usually fixed the issue and the list of installed apps was properly displayed. If you placed portable Uninstalr to a same folder with other portable apps, those were not detected because Uninstalr automatically added its installation folder to the ignore list. When trying to uninstall some specific software, Uninstalr could get stuck on the Searching for more data relating to the app phase. Uninstalr could sometimes do a silent uninstallation even if user had unchecked the Perform a silent uninstallation option. Known issues: Uninstalr can fail to run with an Out Of Memory error in systems that have a lot of installed apps. Using the New Software Monitor tool multiple times during one session can cause the program to get stuck on the Scanning stage. The "uninstallation completed" message box sometimes closes when the user moves the mouse cursor over the button before user clicks it. There is no feedback for the user after Fix Information feature has been used. The Right Click menu's Select by publisher option can display the number of apps per each publisher without correct vertical alignment. The default user interface might not display all of the found installed apps if you have over 600 installed apps. If you do, using the Screen Reader Compatible Interface solves the issue. Leftover apptype filter checkbox is shown in red font only in Dark Mode. Clicking the app's icon from the Windows Taskbar doesn't minimize/restore the app like other apps. The warning about an app that user wishes to uninstall being related to some other app user did not select can sometimes be inaccurate. If app's language is changed without restarting Uninstalr, the list of installed software might not automatically refresh. When software is being uninstalled, the UI can say it is processing paths unrelating to the uninstalled app. This is purely cosmetic and does not mean these paths are removed. Uninstalr might not properly detect and/or uninstall Steam games if they are installed to a drive different than Steam's default location in C:\. You might see "This action is only valid for products that are currently installed" error message from Windows Installer during uninstallation. This is a cosmetic issue. Download: Uninstalr 3.1 | 7.1 MB (Free, paid version available) Download: Uninstalr Setup 3.1 View: Uninstalr Website | Screenshot Get alerted to all of our Software updates on Twitter at @NeowinSoftware
    • The Trump administration doesn't want you to use OpenAI's GPT-5.6 without its approval

      By ad47uk · Posted

      I and many others did not vote to get out of the E.u because of Putin or Farage, we did so for our own reasons. You don't have to tel me what my own did or did not do when it comes to the E.U. The EEC is or was the European Economic Community, a different beast to what the E.U is now.The EEC was a mainly about trading, the E.U have gone far beyond that and as I have said before, is now more of a United States of Europe. The U.K did not vote to join a United States of Europe. Anyway, they did not want us in there in the first place, Charles de Gaulle stopped us joining as he claimed we didn’t agree with the core ideas of integration. He was not wrong and that is why we voted out of the E.U when the time came. I was not old enough to vote the first time. My only regret is that we did not have the referendum years ago and got out years ago. If we rejoined, we would have to agree to join the Euro and no doubt Schengen, agree with freedom of movement, we have enough problem with people coming over here as it is. i have no problem with people coming over here if they work and don't try to push their way of life onto us. The E.U has a currency, freedom of movement, an anthem a flag, a parliament, well they are there, not sure if they do anything. Don't sound like something that is just for trading. Oh yeah, also wanted a euro Army. How many stupid rules have the E.U made that we had to follow? I doubt I will see the Uk rejoin the E.U, which suits me. Oh yeah, my partner is Polish, she came over here before Poland joined the E.U and she got fed up of people just coming over here with ease, while she had to struggle. She is now a British citizen and have been for a fair few years
    • Why Delta Chat is the best decentralized messenger you have probably never tried

      By Fleet Command · Posted

      Hello, Paul. Thanks for the editorial. It was interesting. I'm going research more into the app and its concept. Of course, if you know me at all, you know that I'd say your articles needs some editing! I always do, don't I? For instance, the article occasionally mentions relays before defining it.
    • Weekend PC Game Deals: Steam Summer Sale 2026 Edition

      By +InsaneNutter · Posted

      Screamer is 50% off on Steam, making it £24.99 here in the UK: https://store.steampowered.com/app/2814990/Screamer/ You might remember the series from the mid 90s / early 2000s, this new game is also by Milestone who created the older games.

  • Recent Achievements

    • Week One Done
      flexorcist earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Month Later
      Woland13 earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Week One Done
      Woland13 earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Year In
      bernmeister earned a badge
      One Year In
    • Week One Done
      Scoobystu earned a badge
      Week One Done

  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      495
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      226
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      154
    4. 4
      Steven P.
      75
    5. 5
      FloatingFatMan
      71
    Show More

  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!