Fans going crazy, CPU 100% idle


Recommended Posts

I'm going insane over the behavior of my 27-inch, medio 2010 iMac. The CPU fan continues to spin up even though the iMac doesn't do a thing. I've reinstalled OS X Lion multiple times, I reinstalled OS X Mountain Lion several times. I did PRAM-resets more times I can count, same goes for SMC resets. Today I even disconnected the iMac, laid it down on my bed and cleared all the vents with the vacuum cleaner on the weakest setting. The other day a friend of mine walked in and immediately asked why my iMac was making so much noise.

The first picture shows the CPU Fan right after startup. The second less than two hours later. I haven't done a thing with the iMac except play music and browse the web a bit.

How on Earth is it possible the fans spin up, sometimes over 4000 rpm, when the CPU sits next to idle most of the time? The worst part is they won't power down once the iMac cooled off. There are no optical drives in the SuperDrive either.

The measurements are in Celsius. The room temperature averaging at 20,5 degrees throughout my apartment. It's only 14 degrees here in Amsterdam.

post-128385-0-15321200-1348764232_thumb.

post-128385-0-38335300-1348764664_thumb.

post-128385-0-02210400-1348765019.png

Link to comment
https://www.neowin.net/forum/topic/1108523-fans-going-crazy-cpu-100-idle/
Share on other sites

assuming your temps are in Celsius it is spinning up because the chip is hot. Is there anything to justify the chip being hot? Dust on the HSF, high ambient temp, etc?

I can't really say for sure how much dust has accumulated inside the iMac itself, but judging by how little there was directly underneath the grill I seriously doubt it's a lot. I tried looking inside with a flashlight but everything seemed clear.

If I leave my iMac on for long periods of time the fans will gradually get faster and faster until they are 100% on, and they will not go back to normal speeds unless I shut down and power back on. Rebooting just keeps them running at full tilt.

It's strange. It's like the driver/sensor controlling it has failed to do it's job properly. :/

Yeah if it's THAT hot at idle, you have a problem on your hands.... either your system has absolutely 0 airflow or the heatsink aint applied correctly, if so I'd take the computer and bring it to a store.

Did you recently install an SSD?

http://forums.macrum...d.php?t=1235234

That actually affects the hard drive fan, not the CPU fan (at least it did in my Late 2010 iMac). Also, it happens a lot sooner than 2 hours after boot. :p

Maybe your GPU is being taxed by something? The CPU fan cools both, so...

Yeah if it's THAT hot at idle, you have a problem on your hands.... either your system has absolutely 0 airflow or the heatsink aint applied correctly, if so I'd take the computer and bring it to a store.

It's an iMac. It's normal for things to run a little bit hotter.

Did you recently install an SSD?

Everything is stock. No modifications whatsoever have been made to the iMac after I unpacked it. Also, the SSD issue wouldn't affect the CPU fan, rather the HDD fan.

Maybe your GPU is being taxed by something? The CPU fan cools both, so...

Okay, this is something I can work with. Is there any way of checking what the GPU load is?

If I leave my iMac on for long periods of time the fans will gradually get faster and faster until they are 100% on, and they will not go back to normal speeds unless I shut down and power back on. Rebooting just keeps them running at full tilt.

It's strange. It's like the driver/sensor controlling it has failed to do it's job properly. :/

That's EXACTLY what ****es me off. The fans won't slow down once things are cooling off.

UPDATE:

Okay this is incredibly interesting. I'm now 100% sure this is indeed a software issue, rather than a hardware related one. For whatever reason OS X Mountain Lion is telling my iMac to increase CPU fan speed in order to cool off. But apparently this is a one-way street. As time progresses the fan speed just continues to go up until it hits a maximum of about 4150 rpm. Like jamesyfx noticed they it will continue running at its maximum until I do a full shutdown. So for whatever reason OS X Mountain Lion won't tell my iMac to reduce fan speeds once it cooled off.

After a lot of Googling I noticed other people having the same issue with OS X Mountain Lion. Not just iMacs but MacBook Pros too. One person came with the suggestion to temporarily download and install iStat Menus 2, set Fan speed control to "Medium" (it's on of the default "rules") and then return to "Default". In literally an instant my iMac's CPU fan would drop from its maximum of ?4150 to a quiet 1940 and then continued to drop.

Check out the below screen shot and note the uptime: Over 6 hours and a regular CPU fan speed of 1885 (it's still dropping as I type).

So what's going on here people?

post-128385-0-90926700-1348790216_thumb.

It does a similar thing on my system, CPU fan speed drops down to a steady 1190rpm when I set to default.

Seems like it kicks the default behaviour back in once you set it as such.

My iMac is a completely different model to yours, so the issue must be software related.. and I think using this utility has proven that.

Yeah that's exactly what seems to happen. iStat basically slaps OS X on the wrist telling it do proper fan control. After a while CPU fans would indeed drop to an average of 1190 rpm on my model as well. Here I was thinking my CPU/GPU fan was constantly triggered because it couldn't handle the new OS X Lion/Mountain Lion graphics effects. But that's not it either.

Anyway, it seems like you can uninstall iStats Menu from your system until you do a SMC reset.

I'm not familiar with Mac since i never owned one but why does OSX has to control the fan ?

I would never ever trust any OS to control the fan speed of my computer. Right now i have a fan controller but if i would not have one i would let my Motherboard control the fan speed or at worst install my MB software (or a 3rd party alternative like speedfan) to control them.

Here's an interesting blog post about the issue. You probably have already read it since it was in the first 10 results of a google search but i still post it just in case.

http://gigaom.com/ap...lion-heres-why/

Spotlight reindexing doesn't take days or weeks.

  • 2 weeks later...

Maybe this helps:

http://www.hddfancontrol.com/

OR:

Symptoms

After plugging in the iMac and turning it on, the fans (blowers) may be noisy and appear to run at full speed. In this event, shutting the iMac off and turning it on again wouldn't fix the issue.

Resolution

If you press the iMac power button while you are inserting the power cord, the iMac will enter a mode in which the fans (blowers) run at full speed. In order to correct the issue, reset the SMC and then start the computer by pressing the power button after the power cord has been fully inserted.

The iMac should now start up and operate as expected.

http://support.apple.com/kb/TS1433

AND:

First download and install smcFanControl 2.2.2. Set it up to provide (still quiet) minimum fan speeds of 2200 rpm for the HD and 2800 rpm for the CPU, leave the Optical Drive fan at 600 rpm to minimize dust accumulation (or just tweak it up if/when you will be using it much) ....

http://hints.macworl...110606033134359

UPDATE:

Okay this is incredibly interesting. I'm now 100% sure this is indeed a software issue, rather than a hardware related one. For whatever reason OS X Mountain Lion is telling my iMac to increase CPU fan speed in order to cool off. But apparently this is a one-way street. As time progresses the fan speed just continues to go up until it hits a maximum of about 4150 rpm. Like jamesyfx noticed they it will continue running at its maximum until I do a full shutdown. So for whatever reason OS X Mountain Lion won't tell my iMac to reduce fan speeds once it cooled off.

After a lot of Googling I noticed other people having the same issue with OS X Mountain Lion. Not just iMacs but MacBook Pros too. One person came with the suggestion to temporarily download and install iStat Menus 2, set Fan speed control to "Medium" (it's on of the default "rules") and then return to "Default". In literally an instant my iMac's CPU fan would drop from its maximum of ?4150 to a quiet 1940 and then continued to drop.

Check out the below screen shot and note the uptime: Over 6 hours and a regular CPU fan speed of 1885 (it's still dropping as I type).

So what's going on here people?

I'm confused. Did that software package end up solving the problem for you or is it still an issue?

Off hand I would say the temp gauges are wrong, without touching the cpu or the motherboard touch the bottom of the heat sink(while the computer is on) and see if its hot. That feels like the CPU is over heating(which would cause the 100% cpu usage).

I have no idea what you're talking about or why you think there is 100% CPU usage. :/

  • 2 weeks later...
  • 2 years later...

Hi there, old thread, but hopefully someone is still around.

I have an iMac 27 late-2009, 3.06 Ghz, 8gb RAM, running OS 10.8.5, and all the hardware is original (no HD swap...). So, it has a similar problem: it takes about an hour for the CPU fan to gradually speed up from the initial approx 1200 RPM to around 4000 RPM. Then, all I have to do is to put it to sleep for enough time to let the fans stop spinning (that's not even 5 seconds) and then wake it up to see the CPU fan at normal speeds. And here it goes for another hour of gradual increase... See the screenshot of the iStats Menu, the graph shows the increase in the last hour, and the three previous increase/sleep patterns... The other two fans are just fine. All of that time, the iMac is at idle, nothing running at all. My iMac isn't my main computer, so i kinda left the problem as it was, spending an hour or so every couple of months trying to solve the issue, but after these 5 years of fruitless efforts, I can't believe I haven't solve it yet! Even though I get answers a lot from forums, here's my first post in one of them (ever!), in hope it will help.

 

Here are the solutions I tried already: smcFanControl, HDD Fan Control, iStats Fan Rules... Nothing seems to be able to override the fan speeds, nothing at all! I vacuumed the air input and output... And of course, I did the SMC reset. I try to remember all the other things I tried to do, but it gets confusing after those years of diverse problem solving. I did many upgrades (and even downgrades) too but I doubt it has anything to do.

 

Even though I never opened the iMac's case (I DID open the bottom latch to replace RAM memory at some point, comes to my mind... but that's not the back case) I wonder if it has anything to do with some hardware that would just be misplaced at the factory of because of a shock while moving the computer around... 

 

Anyone has any idea? Anything I could try?

 

Screenshot:

https://www.dropbox.com/s/vfvkr1zordrbznb/Screen%20Shot%202015-01-14%20at%2011.59.57%20PM.png?dl=0

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • With the current hardware prices Microsoft should lift the restriction. Then if you have the correct TPM then allow you to use X feature, if you don't have the correct TPM then don't but still actually let you run windows. 11. With a disclaimer during install that X features would be unavailable.
    • It's good for recycling of course. But commence inflation of a second hand RAM bubble and price gouging on DDR 4 inventory in 3... 2... 1...
    • Bypassed Windows 11 shows surprising stability on ancient, completely unsupported hardware by Sayan Sen When Windows 11 was first released, one of the most complained-about issues with the new desktop Microsoft OS was its higher system requirements, which pushed many relatively modern and powerful processors and devices onto the officially unsupported list. Thankfully, they have not been updated again for the base OS, though systems require four times the memory and storage if they want to run AI-powered apps and features. As such, Windows 11 technically runs on 4GB of memory, and there is no imposed restriction on the generation of memory it supports. Speaking of memory, prices are extremely high nowadays for hardware, especially DDR5 and DDR4 kits due to the current silicon shortage, and there are also reports of it affecting DDR2 as well, and it might only be a matter of time before even DDR1 gets affected. Before that could happen, an enthusiast took an ancient DDR1-based system and decided to try out Windows 11 on it to see how well the modern OS would fare on such hardware. The system runs an outdated graphics card interface standard based on AGP, or Advanced Graphics Port, called AGP 3.0 or AGP8x. AGP was essentially succeeded by the modern PCI Express (PCIe) bus standard. The user behind the experiment is retro hardware enthusiast Omores, who built the system around an ASRock ConRoe865PE motherboard based on Intel's i865PE chipset from way back in 2003, around the time when AGP was still in fashion. What made this board special back in the day was its unusual support for newer Core 2 Duo and even Core 2 Quad processors while still retaining older DDR1 memory support and an AGP8X graphics slot, making it an ideal bridge or link between two vastly different generations. Powering the machine was Intel's Core 2 Quad Q6600 alongside 3GB of DDR1 RAM and an ATI Radeon HD 4650 AGP graphics card, one of the final and most capable GPUs released for the aging AGP interface. While installing Windows 11 itself was relatively easy by bypassing Microsoft's hardware checks, getting the graphics card fully functional proved to be some challenge. Microsoft had quietly dropped native AGP support after the earliest releases of Windows 10, meaning newer versions of Windows no longer include the necessary Graphics Address Remapping Table (GART) drivers required for proper AGP acceleration. Without them, AGP graphics cards typically boot up, though with limited functionality, and can often throw a Code 43 error in Device Manager. To work around the limitation, Omores extracted Intel's legacy AGP440 SYS driver from an early Windows 10 release and paired it with a modified INF file so Windows 11 would correctly recognize the chipset. Following this and combined with AMD's final 64-bit Catalyst AGP drivers from 2012, the Radeon HD 4650 was able to operate with full AGP 8X acceleration intact. The result was said to be surprisingly usable for hardware that is over two decades old. Hardware-accelerated H.264 video playback worked correctly and benefited apps like Firefox, while legacy applications and games ran without major graphical issues. The system also successfully completed the 3DMark 2001 benchmark, although performance naturally lagged behind what the same hardware achieves under Windows 7, which is significantly lighter than Windows 11. There was, however, one unavoidable limitation as Microsoft's Windows 11 version 24H2 introduces a mandatory SSE4.2 CPU instruction requirement that cannot be bypassed through installer modifications or registry tweaks. Since no AGP-era processor supports SSE4.2, Windows 11 version 23H2 effectively becomes the final release capable of running on such systems. Regardless, it is still a very cool feat and quite fascinating to see just how stable Windows 11 turned out to be on such unfamiliar hardware. Source: Omores (Patreon) via O_MORES (Reddit)
    • That will only really help other players that are also responsible for creating the problem.
    • Well, it's good to know that they have found a workaround to a problem that they helped create, I guess...
  • Recent Achievements

    • Reacting Well
      NovaEdgeX earned a badge
      Reacting Well
    • Week One Done
      NovaEdgeX earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • One Year In
      BA the Curmudgeon earned a badge
      One Year In
    • Conversation Starter
      rosiecharles earned a badge
      Conversation Starter
    • First Post
      KMilenkoski1202 earned a badge
      First Post
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      538
    2. 2
      +Edouard
      266
    3. 3
      PsYcHoKiLLa
      151
    4. 4
      Steven P.
      98
    5. 5
      macoman
      66
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!