Surfcast v. Microsoft "live tile" suit date set for September 3rd

As you may have heard late last year, Microsoft is being sued by a company called SurfCast for their use of live tiles. Surfcast claims they have a patent on this type of GUI and wants Microsoft to license it from them.

Cnet now reports that the trial has been set for September 3rd of this year and as of now both companies are in discovery making claims and counterclaims about the validity of each other’s patents.

Surfcast, which is comprised of a handful of bankers and some former IBM executives, filed a complaint on the 30th of October last year against Microsoft’s Windows 8 live tile or modern interface. Back in 2004 Surfcast was granted US patent #6,724,403 which covers a “system and method for simultaneous display of multiple information sources” and in its broad definition would most likely also cover Microsoft’s live tiles.

However that broader definition may not be accepted by the court as Microsoft themselves have a more specific patent titled “ Tile space user interface for mobile devices” which was filed for in 2006 and issued in 2011.

What’s interesting here is that Surfcast’s patent would have entitled them to go after Microsoft long ago, when they first launched Windows Phone 7, the original user of the “live tiles”. However WP7 was never really popular and didn’t sell very well but when Microsoft adopted the tile interface for their main product, Windows, things changed and Surfcast saw its chance to get a slice of the pie.

It is quite unlikely this case will actually go to trial. Most such cases usually settle out of court, however if that doesn’t happen Surfcast will be demanding royalties for the 60+ million machines that are running Windows 8, not to mention the other few million phones out there with Windows Phone.

This story be worth following and we’ll keep you up to date with future developments.

Source: Cnet | Image via Microsoft

Report a problem with article
Previous Story

Asus considering making Windows Phones

Next Story

TechSpot: Apple's 10-Year Run, where they succeeded and others were too lazy to innovate

19 Comments

Commenting is disabled on this article.

I can tell you we are lucky the car was not invented today. It would be a complete and total disaster.

The gouvs need to do something about patent trolls.

"System and method for simultaneous display of multiple information sources"

How is this even patentable? Doesn't this apply to RSS readers and even something like a news channel which shows the latest news and weather on screen?

I don't see how surfcast can win with such a broad patent that could Mio be voided with some prior art from both MS and others. I mean “system and method for simultaneous display of multiple information sources” could be any type of ui that shows you lots of data on screen. At least the Microsoft patent is specific to live tiles and not just anything and everything.

Actually, MS already BUY the metro patent,
Yes, MS buy metro patent.

MS buy it from AOL, from bulk patents purchase, April last year.
Evident: http://i.imgur.com/d1Rd8.jpg

It seem someone from MS were alerted by that image,
but it seems AOL doesn't realize that they already invented the Metro before MS did,
so MS did manged to buy plenty of patents (metro interface included) with very 'reasonable' price.

I hope Microsoft doesn't settle this with Surfcast. Surfcast doesn't deserve to receive any money from Microsoft for being such a troll.

Jarrichvdv said,
I hope Microsoft doesn't settle this with Surfcast. Surfcast doesn't deserve to receive any money from Microsoft for being such a troll.

actually that can be said from all patent trolls.

FoxieFoxie said,
I hope they buy surfacast so apple, google, samesong can't clone metro
They already can't, Microsoft is already owner of Metro.

Jarrichvdv said,
I hope Microsoft doesn't settle this with Surfcast. Surfcast doesn't deserve to receive any money from Microsoft for being such a troll.

I think Surfcast brought Start8 and that's why they want a lawsuit. lol

Do you realize that the Surface name is actually the MS Surface table/desk a long time ago? Now that table is called PixelSense.

Torolol said,
i wonder if MS named the device Surf-ace may came from the company name Surf-cast ?