Detection, on 02 October 2012 - 17:13, said:
Would have been a good review if the app he used didn't rate a 2500mAh battery at 2828mAh, makes me question the results for the entire test
But if true, and his scaling down of the results to match the original OEM battery works, then 5076mAh from a 5400mAh rated non-OEM battery isn't bad
I didn't link to a review. I linked to the Accessories subforum with multiple topics about batteries, but I know what you mean. I did glance at the review you're referring to out of curiosity. As with any forum, you take it all with a grain of salt, read a few reviews to get a true idea. Most of those threads have results from multiple people and an overall conclusion of how well a product works, at least in my experience from accessory subforums on other phones I've had.