Office Open XML or OpenDocument format for Office 2010?


Recommended Posts

Just installed Office 2010, and it now wants me to choose between these two formats. Having done a bit of reading up on the subject, I'm still clueless.

I?m a small business. Want to avoid any potential compatibility issues, obviously. I?ve got about 100,000+ customer excel files in Excel 97, on another PC that will need importing over to this new PC.

What do I go for?

Unless you want compatibility only with other users of Office 2010, the answer to your question is neither ODF nor OOXML. Instead, set the defaults via forced policy to the 97-2003 binary formats, i.e., .doc, .xls, .ppt.

Among the problems you will encounter with OOXML is the fact that users of earlier versions of Office will be unable to open OOXML documents generated by Office 2010. This is part of Microsoft's well-known "upgrade treadmill" strategy, with the underlying driver that people weary of not being able to open files generated by others using newer versions, so are compelled to pay for a license to use the newest version. That approach treats Microsoft users as sheep to be fleeced; there is no technical barrier to providing both backward and forward support of file formats. E.g., any document generated by any version of WordPerfect from v. 6 through 15 can be processed without data loss by any of those versions. The techniques for doing so are well understood.

The Office 97-2003 binary formats, on the other hand, were successfully decoded by competitors. Then as a result of antitrust litigation in the European Union, Microsoft published the specifications for those formats. Most major competitors now do a very decent job of reading and writing the 97-2003 binary formats. This is not the case with OOXML; e.g., some competitors offer OOXML import and have no option to export to that format, since a document may be returned to an MS Office user in the 97-2003 binary format.

The largest drawback to this approach I am aware of is that some features that are new in Office 2010 are not supported by the 97-2003 binary formats.

It should be understood that Microsoft does not provide conforming support for the official international standard ISO/IEC:29500 Office Open XML formats, but only for its own private variants. Several national standards bodies representatives in the ISO/IEC body that approved OOXML as an international standard have spoken out, saying that Microsoft had promised to support ISO/IEC:29500 in Office 2010 in order to secure approval of the standard, but then reneged on the promise. By using the Office 2010 OOXML formats, you add to the sea of documents in circulation that do not conform with the relevant international standard, making it more difficult for the international standard to gain support.

OpenDocument Formats ("ODF") are in a similar mess. Reliable interoperability of different ODF implementing programs has never been demonstrated. As with OOXML, the ODF specification is so grossly under-specified that standard-based interoperability cannot be achieved, although a number of office suites that are all derived from OpenOffice.org do passably well at exchanging documents (by definition, this is not interoperability because it is not the exchange of data between *different* data processing systems).. But Microsoft's implementation of ODF is grossly incompatible with the ODF generated by OpenOffice.org and its derivatives. ODF documents cannot be reliably exchanged between MS Office and OOo+derivatives without data loss.

In short, unless you have a compelling need to use ODF or OOXML, I strongly recommend going with the Office 97-2003 binary formats to optimize compatibility. They are the real-life de facto standard.

BTW, one of those who commented said that OOXML "is the native format for MS Office." That is incorrect. The binary formats are the native formats, the dump to file of the in-memory binary representation of a document. OOXML support is via plugin add-ons that convert between the native format and OOXML.

Paul E. Merrell, J.D.

Universal Interoperability Council

This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Posts

    • Minecraft Chase the Skies update and Vibrant Visuals graphics overhaul lands next week by Pulasthi Ariyasinghe The second major game update of the year for Minecraft is almost here. Mojang today announced that its next Game Drop, Chase the Skies, is landing on June 17. Alongside it, the highly anticipated graphics overhaul, dubbed Vibrant Visuals, will be available too, making the day a rather big occasion for Minecraft fans. The Chase the Skies update has a large number of gameplay features and content, but one of the biggest is the expansion of the Ghast. Now, players will be able to find Happy Ghasts as a tameable mob, letting up to five players ride them on journeys across the skies. To get one, players will have to find small, dehydrated Ghasts near fossil structures in the Nether, then bring it to the overworld and feed it plenty of water. It is also possible to craft dried Ghasts from Nether materials. Other features of this update include a handy player locator bar, better leads functionality, craftable saddles, a new music disc, and more. As for the Vibrant Visuals upgrade, Mojang is touting a visual refresh that lets players witness how lights and shadows affect the Minecraft world. "Fly high with your happy ghast to watch the sunrise reflect on the rippling ocean, make art with shifting shadows, descend into dark depths, or simply sit back and enjoy the vivid beauty of each biome," says the studio. "With updated in-game visuals you’ll see how light and shadow transform the Overworld – water reflects, forests become shaded, fog drifts, and waterfalls glimmer in the light." The currently supported devices for Vibrant Visuals include Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, PC, as well as Android (Android: Adreno 640, Mali-G68, Mali-G77, or Xclipse 530 or higher) and iOS (A12 or M1 or higher.)   Unfortunately, the Vibrant Visuals upgrade will only be available on the Bedrock Edition of Minecraft, at least for now. Mojang has said that it plans to bring the visual overhaul to the Java Edition of Minecraft at a later date, but no information or release window has been announced just yet.
    • Once people get use to the square-ish case, they'll probably switch the display to square as well.
    • Why would you think it's not enabled all the time? Because they said so?
    • $100 billion of the $200 billion is in N.Y. State over the upcoming 20 years plus. Obviously 20+ year spending plans are subject to change.
  • Recent Achievements

    • One Month Later
      POR2GAL4EVER earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • One Year In
      Orpheus13 earned a badge
      One Year In
    • One Month Later
      Orpheus13 earned a badge
      One Month Later
    • Week One Done
      Orpheus13 earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Week One Done
      serfegyed earned a badge
      Week One Done
  • Popular Contributors

    1. 1
      +primortal
      560
    2. 2
      ATLien_0
      255
    3. 3
      +Edouard
      163
    4. 4
      +FloatingFatMan
      158
    5. 5
      Michael Scrip
      110
  • Tell a friend

    Love Neowin? Tell a friend!